Civil Court Case Information - Case History


« Return to search results
Case Information
Case Number: LC2021-000180 Judge: Hannah, John
File Date: 6/30/2021 Location: Downtown
Case Type: Lower Court Appeals  
Party Information
Party Name Relationship Sex Attorney
Phoenix Newspapers Inc   PLF/Appellant    David Bodney 
Kathy Tulumello   PLF/Appellant  Female  David Bodney 
Arizona State Senate   DEFT/Appellee    Thomas Basile 
Karen Fann   DEFT/Appellee  Female  Thomas Basile 
Warren Petersen   DEFT/Appellee  Male  Pro Per 
Susan Aceves   DEFT/Appellee  Female  Thomas Basile 
Cyber Ninjas Inc   DEFT/Appellee    John Wilenchik 
Case Documents
Filing Date Description Docket Date Filing Party
5/24/2022  019 - ME: Ruling  5/24/2022   
5/10/2022  906 - ME: Response/Reply Times Set  5/10/2022   
4/6/2022  056 - ME: Hearing Set  4/6/2022   
3/22/2022  019 - ME: Ruling  3/22/2022   
3/3/2022  019 - ME: Ruling  3/3/2022   
3/2/2022  019 - ME: Ruling  3/2/2022   
1/19/2022  053 - ME: Case Consolidation  1/19/2022   
1/18/2022  066 - ME: Case Reassigned  1/18/2022   
1/14/2022  001 - ME: Disqualification  1/14/2022   
1/14/2022  906 - ME: Response/Reply Times Set  1/14/2022   
1/12/2022  MOT - Motion  1/12/2022   
NOTE: TO DISQUALIFY JUDICIAL OFFICER FOR CAUSE 
1/11/2022  028 - ME: Status Conference Set  1/11/2022   
1/11/2022  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  1/11/2022   
1/6/2022  ORD - Order  1/6/2022   
NOTE: GRANTING RENEWED MOTION TO HOLD CYBER NINJAS IN CONTEMPT FOR ITS FAILURE TO COMPLY 
1/6/2022  ORD - Order  1/7/2022   
NOTE: AMENDED 
1/6/2022  ORD - Order  1/7/2022   
NOTE: SUPREME COURT ORDER 
1/6/2022  ORD - Order  1/7/2022   
NOTE: SUPREME COURT ORDER 
1/5/2022  RES - Response  1/6/2022   
NOTE: TO MOTION FOR CONTEMPT 
1/5/2022  LET - Letter  1/6/2022   
NOTE: SUPREME COURT 
12/30/2021  056 - ME: Hearing Set  12/30/2021   
12/28/2021  RES - Response  12/29/2021   
NOTE: TO EX PARTE MOTION TO WITHDRAW 
12/22/2021  MOT - Motion  12/23/2021   
NOTE: TO WITHDRAW/EX PARTE 
12/20/2021  028 - ME: Status Conference Set  12/20/2021   
12/17/2021  REQ - Request  12/21/2021   
NOTE: FOR SUMMARY ADJUDICATION OF PLAINTIFFS RENEWED MOTION TO HOLD CYBER NINJAS IN CONTEMPT FOR ITS FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH COURT ORDERS TO PRODUCE PUBLIC RECORDS 
12/3/2021  029 - ME: Status Conference  12/3/2021   
12/3/2021  NOT - Notice  12/7/2021   
NOTE: OF DECEMBER 1 2021 DECISION 
12/2/2021  ORD - Order  12/2/2021   
NOTE: SUPREME COURT/ 
11/30/2021  NOT - Notice  12/2/2021   
NOTE: OF DECISION DENYING WITHOUT PREJUDICE CYBER NINJAS APPLICATION FOR STAY 
11/30/2021  ORD - Order  12/1/2021   
NOTE: SUPREME COURT 
11/24/2021  MOT - Motion  11/24/2021   
NOTE: RENEWED/TO HOLD CYBER NINJAS IN CONTEMPT FOR ITS FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH COURT ORDERS TO PRODUCE PUBLIC RECORDS 
11/24/2021  ORD - Order  11/29/2021   
NOTE: SUPREME COURT ORDER 
11/23/2021  028 - ME: Status Conference Set  11/23/2021   
11/15/2021  RES - Response  11/18/2021   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR EXPEDITED STATUS CONFERENCE 
11/12/2021  REQ - Request  11/16/2021   
NOTE: FOR EXPEDITIED STATUS CONFERENCE 
11/10/2021  REL - Reply  11/10/2021   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF FINDING OF WAIVER OF LEGISLATIVE PRIVILEGE 
11/10/2021  RES - Response  11/10/2021   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF REQUEST FOR FINDING OF WAIVER OF LEGISLATIVE PRIVILEGE 
11/4/2021  SOF - Statement Of Facts  11/8/2021   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF REQUEST FOR FINDING OF WAIVER OF LEGISLATIVE PRIVILEGE 
11/3/2021  ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal  11/4/2021   
11/3/2021  CAO - Court Of Appeals Order  11/4/2021   
NOTE: DISMISSING SPECIAL ACTION PETITION IN PART 
11/3/2021  RES - Response  11/4/2021   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR FINDING OF WAIVER 
11/1/2021  029 - ME: Status Conference  11/1/2021   
10/27/2021  RES - Response  10/28/2021   
NOTE: TO MOTION FOR CONTEMPT OF COURT OF APPEALS ORDER 
10/26/2021  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  10/26/2021   
10/22/2021  RES - Response  10/27/2021   
NOTE: TO SENATE DEFENDANTS NOTICE OF SUBMISSION OF DOCUMENTS IN CAMERA AND REQUEST FOR BRIEFING SCHEDULE 2 REQUEST FOR FINDING OF WAIVER OF LEGISLATIVE PRIVILGE AND 3 RENEWED REQUEST FOR ADEQUATE PRIVILEGE LOG 
10/22/2021  950 - ME: Sealed - Paper Only Access  10/22/2021   
10/22/2021  SDD - Notice: Sealed Document  10/22/2021   
NOTE: A SET OF COPIES OF THE SIX RECORDS REVIEWED IN CAMERA, INCLUDING A REDACTED VERSION OF THE RECORD FOUND TO CONTAIN A PRIVILEGED COMMUNICATION 
10/22/2021  SDD - Notice: Sealed Document  10/22/2021   
NOTE: AN UNREDACTED COPY OF THE RECORD FOUND TO CONTAIN A PRIVILEDGED COMMUNICATION 
10/21/2021  019 - ME: Ruling  10/21/2021   
10/21/2021  028 - ME: Status Conference Set  10/21/2021   
10/15/2021  MOT - Motion  10/18/2021   
NOTE: TO HOLD CYBER NINJAS IN CONTEMPT FOR ITS FAILURE TO COMPLY WITH THIS COURTS ORDER TO PRODUCE PUBLIC RECORDS 
10/12/2021  926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling  10/12/2021   
10/12/2021  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  10/12/2021   
10/12/2021  NOT - Notice  10/13/2021   
NOTE: OF SUBMISSION OF DOCUMENTS FOR IN CAMERA REVIEW AND REQUEST FOR BRIEFING SCHEDULE 
10/11/2021  926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling  10/11/2021   
10/8/2021  ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal  10/11/2021   
10/8/2021  CAO - Court Of Appeals Order  10/11/2021   
NOTE: AMENDED ORDER ACCEPTING SPECIAL ACTION JURISDICTION, DENYING RELIEF 
10/7/2021  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  10/7/2021   
10/1/2021  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  10/1/2021   
9/29/2021  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  10/1/2021   
NOTE: PURSUANT TO SEPTEMBER 23 2021 ORDER 
9/28/2021  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  9/28/2021   
9/24/2021  REL - Reply  9/24/2021   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY IN CAMERA REVIEW AND TO COMPEL ADEQUATE PRIVILEGE LOG 
9/23/2021  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  9/23/2021   
9/23/2021  019 - ME: Ruling  9/23/2021   
9/22/2021  RES - Response  9/24/2021   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR IN CAMERA REVIEW AND TO COMPEL AN ADEQUATE PRIVILEGE LOG 
9/20/2021  019 - ME: Ruling  9/20/2021   
9/17/2021  REP - Report  9/20/2021   
NOTE: SENATE DEFENDANTS STATUS REPORT AND RENEWED MOTION TO TRANSFER AND CONSOLIDATE 
9/16/2021  MOT - Motion  9/17/2021   
NOTE: PLAINTIFFS/FOR PRELIMINARY IN CAMERA REVIEW AND TO COMPEL ADEQUATE PRIVILIGE LOG 
9/8/2021  ORD - Order  9/9/2021   
NOTE: SUPREME COURT 
9/2/2021  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  9/2/2021   
8/24/2021  NOT - Notice  8/24/2021   
NOTE: OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY 
8/24/2021  ORD - Order  8/25/2021   
NOTE: TO PRODUCE PUBLIC RECORDS 
8/20/2021  NOT - Notice  8/23/2021   
NOTE: OF SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY 
8/17/2021  022 - ME: Order Signed  8/17/2021   
8/17/2021  REL - Reply  8/17/2021   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF SENATE DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS 
8/17/2021  REL - Reply  8/19/2021   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS 
8/16/2021  ORD - Order  8/17/2021   
NOTE: GRANTING MOTION TO ASSOCIATE COUNSEL 
8/11/2021  MOT - Motion  8/13/2021   
NOTE: TO ASSOCIATE COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE 
8/10/2021  RES - Response  8/10/2021   
NOTE: PLAINTIFFS/IN OPPOSITION TO SENATE DEFENDANTS MOTIN FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS ADN CYBER NINJAS MOTIN TO DISMISS AND PLAINTIFFS REPLY INSUPPORT OF THEIR APPLICATION FOR ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE 
8/3/2021  ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal  8/9/2021   
7/27/2021  RES - Response  7/27/2021   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS APPLICATION FOR ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE 
7/27/2021  MOT - Motion  7/27/2021   
NOTE: FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS 
7/27/2021  MTD - Motion To Dismiss  7/29/2021   
NOTE: ORAL ARGUMENT REQUESTED 
7/27/2021  RES - Response  7/29/2021   
NOTE: TO APPLICATION FOR ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE/ORAL ARGUMENT REQUESTED 
7/23/2021  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  7/23/2021   
7/19/2021  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  7/19/2021   
7/19/2021  ANS - Answer  7/19/2021   
7/15/2021  001 - ME: Disqualification  7/15/2021   
7/15/2021  003 - ME: Hearing Reset  7/15/2021   
7/15/2021  019 - ME: Ruling  7/16/2021   
7/13/2021  CME - Credit Memo  7/13/2021   
NOTE: CYBER NINJAS INC 
7/13/2021  REL - Reply  7/13/2021   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF SENATE DEFENDANTS MOTION TO TRANSFER AND CONSOLIDATE 
7/13/2021  019 - ME: Ruling  7/13/2021   
7/12/2021  RES - Response  7/13/2021   
NOTE: TO MOTION TO TRANSFER AND CONSOLIDATE 
7/9/2021  NJR - Notice of change of Judge for right  7/13/2021   
7/8/2021  ACS - Acceptance Of Service  7/13/2021   
7/7/2021  OSC - Order To Show Cause  7/8/2021   
7/6/2021  RES - Response  7/9/2021   
NOTE: IN OPPOSITION TO SENATE DEFENDANTS MOTION TO TRANSFER AND CONSOLIDATE BY PHOENIX NEWSPAPER INC AND KATHY TULUMELLO 
7/2/2021  504: Me: Record Appeal Assignment  7/2/2021   
7/1/2021  MOT - Motion  7/6/2021   
NOTE: TO TRANSFER AND CONSOLIDATE 
7/1/2021  NAR - Notice Of Appearance  7/6/2021   
6/30/2021  CSA - Complaint Special Action  6/30/2021   
6/30/2021  CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject  6/30/2021   
6/30/2021  APL - Application  6/30/2021   
NOTE: FOR ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE AND SUPPORTING MEMORANDUM OF LAW OF PHOENIX NEWSPAPERS INC AND KATHY TULUMELLO 
6/30/2021  CSH - Coversheet  6/30/2021   
Case Calendar
Date Time Event
7/14/2021  9:30  Order To Show Cause 
7/21/2021  16:00  Order To Show Cause 
8/23/2021  9:30  Oral Argument 
9/17/2021  16:00  Status Conference 
9/24/2021  13:30  Oral Argument 
10/28/2021  8:30  Status Conference 
11/30/2021  9:30  Status Conference 
1/6/2022  9:30  Status Conference 
1/6/2022  9:30  Order To Show Cause 
1/21/2022  11:30  Status Conference 
1/25/2022  13:30  Status Conference 
Judgments
There are no judgments on file