Civil Court Case Information - Case History

« Return to search results

Case Information

Case Number:

CV2025-004555

Judge:

Gordon, Michael

File Date:

2/4/2025

Location:

Downtown

Case Type:

Civil

Party Information

Party Name

Relationship

Sex

Attorney

Party Name

Esteban Ballez

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

SUZIE ZACHAR HARDY

Party Name

(2)City of Phoenix

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

Attorney

Victoria Torrilhon

Party Name

Omar Torres Herrera

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

Male

Attorney

Thomas Hall

Party Name

Audon Aguilar Torrez

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

Male

Attorney

Pro Per

Party Name

Arizona Department Of Transportation

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

Attorney

Christopher Davis

Party Name

State Of Arizona

Relationship

Consolidated

Sex

Attorney

Christopher Davis

Case Documents

Filing Date

Description

Docket Date

Filing Party

Filing Date

11/12/2025

Description

NAR - Notice Of Appearance

Docket Date

11/14/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

NOTICE OF CHANGE OF COUNSEL WITHIN THE SAME FIRM

Filing Date

10/27/2025

Description

CCA - Cert Compulsory Arbitration

Docket Date

10/28/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendant State of Arizona's Certificate of Arbitration

Filing Date

10/27/2025

Description

ANS - Answer

Docket Date

10/28/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendant State of Arizona's Answer to Plaintiff Ballez's First Amended Complaint

Filing Date

10/24/2025

Description

019 - ME: Ruling

Docket Date

10/24/2025

Filing Party

Filing Date

10/21/2025

Description

MFR - Motion For Reconsideration

Docket Date

10/22/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

CROSS-CLAIMANT/PLAINTIFF HERRERA’S AND PLAINTIFF BALLEZ’ JOINT MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION

Filing Date

10/13/2025

Description

005 - ME: Hearing

Docket Date

10/13/2025

Filing Party

Filing Date

10/9/2025

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

10/9/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANT CITY OF PHOENIX’S NOTICE TO THE COURT RE. SUPPLEMENTAL BRIEFING ON MSJ ARGUMENT

Filing Date

10/1/2025

Description

DPR - Deposition Report

Docket Date

10/3/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

BRIIANA MARIA DAMARIS VELEZ / JUNE 27 2025

Filing Date

9/4/2025

Description

021 - ME: Nunc Pro Tunc Order

Docket Date

9/4/2025

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/3/2025

Description

094 - ME: Oral Argument Set

Docket Date

9/3/2025

Filing Party

Filing Date

8/22/2025

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

8/25/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANT CITY OF PHOENIX’S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AGAINST PLAINTIFFS BALLEZ AND HERRERA

Filing Date

8/21/2025

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

8/21/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

, it is hereby ordered that the City of Phoenix's reply will be due on August 22, 2025.

Filing Date

8/14/2025

Description

STP - Stipulation

Docket Date

8/15/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

PARTIES’ JOINT STIPULATION TO EXTEND DEADLINE FOR DEFENDANT CITY OF PHOENIX TO FILE ITS REPLY IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

8/12/2025

Description

CER - Certificate

Docket Date

8/12/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

ARIZONA RULE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 7.1(h) GOOD FAITH CONSULTATION CERTIFICATE

Filing Date

8/5/2025

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

8/6/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA’S REPLY BRIEF IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS

Filing Date

7/30/2025

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

7/31/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Plaintiff/Cross Claimant Herrera's and Plaintiff Ballez' Response to Motion for Summary Judgment

Filing Date

7/24/2025

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

7/25/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

PLAINTIFF BALLEZ’S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA’S and ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION’S MOTION TO DISMISS

Filing Date

7/8/2025

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

7/8/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

ORDER RE: JOINT MOTION TO EXTEND TIME FOR PLAINTIFF BALLEZ'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA AND ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION'S MOTION TO DISMISS

Filing Date

7/7/2025

Description

023 - ME: Order Entered By Court

Docket Date

7/7/2025

Filing Party

Filing Date

7/1/2025

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

7/2/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

JOINT MOTION TO EXTEND TIME FOR PLAINTIFF BALLEZ’S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA AND ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION’S MOTION TO DISMISS

Filing Date

6/25/2025

Description

MTD - Motion To Dismiss

Docket Date

6/26/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANTS STATE OF ARIZONA AND ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION’S MOTION TO DISMISS WITH PREJUDICE

Filing Date

6/23/2025

Description

053 - ME: Case Consolidation

Docket Date

6/23/2025

Filing Party

Filing Date

6/23/2025

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

6/23/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

ORDER CONSOLIDATING CASE NOS. CV2025-004555 and CV2025 016977

Filing Date

6/18/2025

Description

STP - Stipulation

Docket Date

6/19/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Stipulation to Consolidate

Filing Date

6/17/2025

Description

ODI - Order Of Dismissal

Docket Date

6/17/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

ORDER DISMISSING THIRD-PARTY PLAINTIFF OMAR HERRERA'S THIRD-PARTY COMPLAINT AGAINST THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA WITHOUT PREJUDICE

Filing Date

6/13/2025

Description

019 - ME: Ruling

Docket Date

6/13/2025

Filing Party

Filing Date

6/13/2025

Description

SFD - Stipulation For Dismissal

Docket Date

6/14/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

STIPULATION TO DISMISS THIRD-PARTY PLAINTIFF OMAR HERRERA’S THIRD-PARTY COMPLAINT AGAINST STATE OF ARIZONA WITHOUT PREJUDICE

Filing Date

6/11/2025

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

6/16/2025

Filing Party

Filing Date

6/11/2025

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

6/16/2025

Filing Party

Filing Date

6/11/2025

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

6/16/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

ARIZONA DEPARTMENT OF TRANSPORTATION

Filing Date

6/11/2025

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

6/16/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

STATE OF ARIZONA

Filing Date

6/4/2025

Description

029 - ME: Status Conference

Docket Date

6/4/2025

Filing Party

Filing Date

6/3/2025

Description

ANS - Answer

Docket Date

6/4/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendant Herrera's Answer to Plaintiff Ballez's First Amended Complaint

Filing Date

6/2/2025

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

6/3/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

CROSS-CLAIMANT/THIRD-PARTY PLAINTIFF’S JOINDER IN PLAINTIFF BELLEZ’S REQEUST FOR RULE 56(d) RELIEF FOR EXPEDITED HEARING

Filing Date

6/2/2025

Description

AMC - Amended Complaint

Docket Date

6/3/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

First Amended Complaint

Filing Date

5/29/2025

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

6/2/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANT CITY OF PHOENIX’S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF BALLEZ’S RULE 56(D) MOTION

Filing Date

5/29/2025

Description

028 - ME: Status Conference Set

Docket Date

5/29/2025

Filing Party

Filing Date

5/28/2025

Description

MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment

Docket Date

5/29/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendant City of Phoenix's Motion for Summary Judgment Against Plaintiff Herrera

Filing Date

5/28/2025

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

5/30/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANT CITY OF PHOENIX’S JOINDER TO STATE OF ARIZONA’S MOTION TO SEVER PURSUANT TO Ariz.R.Civ.P. Rules 14(a)(4) and 42(b)

Filing Date

5/28/2025

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

5/30/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANT CITY OF PHOENIX’S SEPARATE STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AGAINST PLAINTIFF HERRERA

Filing Date

5/27/2025

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

5/28/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

PLAINTIFF BALLEZ’S RESPONSE TO CITY OF PHOENIX’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

5/27/2025

Description

REQ - Request

Docket Date

5/28/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

PLAINTIFF BALLEZ’S REQUEST FOR RULE 56(d) RELIEF FOR EXPEDITED HEARING

Filing Date

5/27/2025

Description

OBJ - Objection/Opposition

Docket Date

5/28/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

PLAINITFF BALLEZ’S OBJECTION TO THIRD-PARTY DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA’S MOTION TO SEVER

Filing Date

5/12/2025

Description

CCA - Cert Compulsory Arbitration

Docket Date

5/13/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Third-Party Defendant State of Arizona's Certificate of Arbitration

Filing Date

5/12/2025

Description

ANS - Answer

Docket Date

5/13/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Third-Party Defendant State of Arizona's Answer to Third-Party Complaint

Filing Date

5/12/2025

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

5/12/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Third-Party Defendant State of Arizona's Motion to Sever / CO-CHG $263.00 R# 303007403

Filing Date

5/1/2025

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

5/2/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANT CITY OF PHOENIX’S SEPARATE STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AGAINST PLAINTIFF BALLEZ / CO-CHG REC# 30272708

Filing Date

5/1/2025

Description

MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment

Docket Date

5/2/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANT CITY OF PHOENIX’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AGAINST PLAINTIFF BALLEZ

Filing Date

4/24/2025

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

4/25/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANT’S NOTICE OF CHANGE OF LAW FIRM NAME AND ADDRESS

Filing Date

4/24/2025

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

5/1/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

STATE OF ARIZONA

Filing Date

4/17/2025

Description

CCA - Cert Compulsory Arbitration

Docket Date

4/17/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Certificate of Compulsory Arbitration

Filing Date

4/17/2025

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

4/22/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

CITY OF PHOENIX

Filing Date

4/10/2025

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

4/10/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

ORDER RE FIRST AMENDED COMPLAINT

Filing Date

4/8/2025

Description

MTA - Motion To Amend

Docket Date

4/9/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Stipulated Motion for Leave to File First Amended Complaint

Filing Date

4/1/2025

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

4/1/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

ORDER ALLOWING DEFENDANT/CROSS-CLAIMANT OMAR HERRERA TO FILE AMENDED ANSWER, CROSS-CLAIM, AND THIRD-PARTY COMPLAINT

Filing Date

4/1/2025

Description

SCM - Subsequent Complaint

Docket Date

4/2/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

AMENDED ANSWER, CROSS-CLAIM, and THIRD-PARTY COMPLAINT

Filing Date

4/1/2025

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

4/7/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

CITY OF PHOENIX

Filing Date

3/28/2025

Description

STP - Stipulation

Docket Date

3/31/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

STIPULATION TO FILE AMENDED ANSWER, CROSS-CLAIM, AND THIRD-PARTY COMPLAINT

Filing Date

3/21/2025

Description

CCA - Cert Compulsory Arbitration

Docket Date

3/21/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Certificate of Compulsory Arbitration

Filing Date

3/10/2025

Description

ANS - Answer

Docket Date

3/11/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Answer and Cross-Claim / EFILE BILLING $263

Filing Date

3/4/2025

Description

ACS - Acceptance Of Service

Docket Date

3/4/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE OF DEFENDANT OMAR TORRES HERRERA AND JANE DOE HERRERA

Filing Date

3/3/2025

Description

NDI - Notice Of Dismissal

Docket Date

3/3/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

PLAINTIFF’S NOTICE OF VOLUNTARY DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE OF DEFENDANTS AUDON AGUILAR TORRES AND JANE DOE TORREZ (ONLY)

Filing Date

2/18/2025

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

2/20/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

CITY OF PHOENIX

Filing Date

2/4/2025

Description

COM - Complaint

Docket Date

2/5/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Complaint

Filing Date

2/4/2025

Description

CSH - Coversheet

Docket Date

2/5/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Civil Cover Sheet

Filing Date

2/4/2025

Description

CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject

Docket Date

2/5/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Certificate Of Compulsory Arbitration - Is Not Subject To

Filing Date

2/4/2025

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

2/5/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Summons

Filing Date

2/4/2025

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

2/5/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Summons

Filing Date

2/4/2025

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

2/5/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Summons

Filing Date

2/4/2025

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

2/5/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Summons

Filing Date

2/4/2025

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

2/5/2025

Filing Party

NOTE:

Summons

Case Calendar

Date

Time

Event

Date

6/3/2025

Time

8:45

Event

Status Conference

Date

10/1/2025

Time

10:30

Event

Oral Argument

Judgments

Date

(F)or / (A)gainst

Amount

Frequency

Type

Status

No records found.