Civil Court Case Information - Case History


« Return to search results
Case Information
Case Number: CV2022-095403 Judge: Thompson, Peter
File Date: 12/9/2022 Location: Southeast
Case Type: Civil  
Party Information
Party Name Relationship Sex Attorney
Kari Lake   Plaintiff  Female  Bryan Blehm 
Stephen Richer   Defendant  Male  Thomas Liddy 
Bill Gates   Defendant  Male  Thomas Liddy 
Clint Hickman   Defendant  Male  Thomas Liddy 
Jack Sellers   Defendant  Male  Thomas Liddy 
Thomas Galvin   Defendant  Male  Thomas Liddy 
Steve Gallardo   Defendant  Male  Thomas Liddy 
Scott Jarrett   Defendant  Male  Thomas Liddy 
Maricopa County Board Of Supervisors   Defendant    Thomas Liddy 
Paul Andrew Mitchell   Intervenor  Male  Pro Per 
Adrian Fontes   Defendant  Male  Pro Per 
Case Documents
Filing Date Description Docket Date Filing Party
2/1/2023  PHA - Pro Hac Vice Application  2/1/2023   
NOTE: MOTION TO ASSOCIATE COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE 
2/1/2023  PHA - Pro Hac Vice Application  2/1/2023   
NOTE: Motion to Associate Counsel Pro Hac Vice 
1/31/2023  MEM - Memorandum  2/1/2023   
1/26/2023  ORD - Order  1/27/2023   
NOTE: SUPREME COURT ORDER 
1/17/2023  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  1/17/2023   
1/11/2023  NOT - Notice  1/11/2023   
NOTE: RULE 11(c)(3) NOTICE 
1/10/2023  NWA - Notice Withdrawal Of Attorney  1/10/2023   
NOTE: Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel Within Firm 
1/4/2023  ORD - Order  1/5/2023   
NOTE: SUPREME COURT 
1/3/2023  ORD - Order  1/12/2023   
NOTE: GRANTING EX PARTE APPLICATION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL WITH CLIENT CONSENT 
1/3/2023  NOT - Notice  1/3/2023   
NOTE: Notice of Automatic Substitution of Public Officer 
1/3/2023  CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt  1/4/2023   
12/30/2022  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  12/30/2022   
12/30/2022  CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt  1/3/2023   
12/30/2022  AIX - Appeals Index  1/3/2023   
NOTE: ELECTRONIC INDEX OF RECORD 
12/30/2022  NOT - Notice  1/3/2023   
NOTE: COURT OF APPEALS APPELLATE CLERK NOTICE 
12/28/2022  EXW - Exhibits Work Sheet  12/28/2022   
12/28/2022  MFW - Motion For Withdraw of counsel  12/28/2022   
NOTE: EX PARTE APPLICATION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL WITH CLIENT CONSENT 
12/27/2022  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  12/27/2022   
12/27/2022  019 - ME: Ruling  12/27/2022   
12/27/2022  NAP - Notice Of Appeal  12/27/2022   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF KARI LAKE’S NOTICE OF APPEAL 
12/26/2022  MOT - Motion  12/26/2022   
NOTE: GOVERNOR-ELECT KATIE HOBBS’S MOTION FOR SANCTIONS AND JOINDER IN MARICOPA COUNTY DEFENDANTS’ MEMORANDUM AND POINTS OF AUTHORITY 
12/26/2022  AAF - Application For Attorney Fees  12/26/2022   
NOTE: Governor-Elect Katie Hobbs' Partial Attorney Fee Application 
12/26/2022  MOT - Motion  12/26/2022   
NOTE: Motion for Sanctions and Application for Attorneys' Fees 
12/26/2022  ASR - Affidavit in Support of Attorney Fees  12/26/2022   
NOTE: Alexis Danneman Declaration in Support of Fee Application 
12/26/2022  ASR - Affidavit in Support of Attorney Fees  12/26/2022   
NOTE: Abha Khanna Declaration in Support of Partial Fee Application 
12/26/2022  MOT - Motion  12/26/2022   
NOTE: ARIZONA SECRETARY OF STATE KATIE HOBBS’ JOINDER IN MARICOPA COUNTY DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR SANCTIONS 
12/26/2022  AAF - Application For Attorney Fees  12/26/2022   
NOTE: Arizona Secretary of State Katie Hobbs' Application for Attorneys' Fees and Expenses 
12/26/2022  RES - Response  12/26/2022   
NOTE: Plaintiff Kari Lake's Response to Defendant's Motions to for Sanctions and Application for Attorney's Fees 
12/26/2022  RES - Response  12/26/2022   
NOTE: Plaintiff Kari Lake's Corrected Response to Defendants' Motions for Sanctions and Application for Attorneys' Fees 
12/26/2022  APL - Application  12/29/2022  Intervenor(11)  
NOTE: FOR LEAVE TO INTERVENE 
12/24/2022  926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling  12/24/2022   
12/23/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/29/2022   
12/22/2022  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  12/22/2022   
12/22/2022  LET - Letter  12/27/2022   
12/22/2022  005 - ME: Hearing  12/22/2022   
12/21/2022  RES - Response  12/21/2022   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO EXCLUDE EXPERT WITNESS RICHARD BARIS 
12/21/2022  RES - Response  12/21/2022   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION IN LIMINE UNDER RULE 807 
12/21/2022  RES - Response  12/21/2022   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO EXCLUDE EXPET WITNESS CLAY PARIKH  
12/20/2022  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  12/20/2022   
12/20/2022  019 - ME: Ruling  12/20/2022   
12/20/2022  NOT - Notice  12/20/2022   
NOTE: Notice of Withdrawal of Subpoena to Appear 
12/20/2022  MIL - Motion In Limine  12/20/2022   
NOTE: Motion in Limine Regarding Lake's Rule 807 Notice 
12/20/2022  MOT - Motion  12/20/2022   
NOTE: Contestee Katie Hobb's Motion to Exclude Plaintiffs Experts Clay Parikh and Richard Baris and Strike Expert Reports 
12/20/2022  NOT - Notice  12/20/2022   
NOTE: Katie Hobbs Joinder to County and Secretary Motion Regarding Lakes 807 Notice 
12/20/2022  NOT - Notice  12/20/2022   
NOTE: ARIZONA SECRETARY OF STATE’S AND MARICOPA COUNTY DEFENDANTS’ NOTICE OF JOINDER IN CONTESTEE KATIE HOBBS’ MOTION TO EXCLUDE PLAINTIFF’S EXPERTS CLAY PARIKH AND RICHARD BARIS AND STRIKE EXPERT REPORTS 
12/20/2022  NOT - Notice  12/20/2022   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S Rule 807 Notice 
12/19/2022  MOT - Motion  12/19/2022   
NOTE: PLAINTIFFS EXPEDITED MOTION TO SEQUESTER BALLOTS EXAMINED BY PLAINTIFF'S EXPERT 
12/19/2022  MTQ - Motion To Quash  12/19/2022   
NOTE: CONTESTEE KATIE HOBBS'S JOINDER IN MOTION TO QUASH SUBPOENA FOR APPEARANCE AT HEARING 
12/19/2022  REQ - Request  12/19/2022   
NOTE: CONTESTEE KATIE HOBBS'S REQUEST FOR COURT REPORTER 
12/19/2022  PHA - Pro Hac Vice Application  12/19/2022   
NOTE: Motion to Associate Counsel  
12/19/2022  PHA - Pro Hac Vice Application  12/19/2022   
NOTE: Motion to Associate Counsel  
12/19/2022  PHA - Pro Hac Vice Application  12/19/2022   
NOTE: Motion to Associate Counsel 
12/19/2022  PHA - Pro Hac Vice Application  12/19/2022   
NOTE: Motion to Associate Counsel 
12/19/2022  PHO - Pro Hac Vice Order  12/19/2022   
12/19/2022  PHO - Pro Hac Vice Order  12/19/2022   
12/19/2022  PHO - Pro Hac Vice Order  12/19/2022   
12/19/2022  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  12/19/2022   
12/19/2022  926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling  12/19/2022   
12/19/2022  019 - ME: Ruling  12/19/2022   
12/19/2022  MFR - Motion For Reconsideration  12/20/2022   
NOTE: Arizona Secretary of State Katie Hobbs' Emergency Motion for Reconsideration of Order Denying Motion TO QUASH 
12/18/2022  REL - Reply  12/18/2022   
NOTE: Contestee Katie Hobbs's Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss 
12/18/2022  REL - Reply  12/18/2022   
NOTE: Arizona Secretary of State's Reply in Support of Motion to Dismiss Complaint in Special Action and Verified Statement of Election Contest 
12/18/2022  REL - Reply  12/18/2022   
NOTE: Maricopa County Defendants' Reply In Support of Their Motion to Dismiss 
12/18/2022  NOT - Notice  12/18/2022   
NOTE: Plaintiffs Designation and Disclosure of Witnesses 
12/18/2022  RES - Response  12/19/2022   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT STEPHEN RICHER'S MOTION TO QUASH 
12/18/2022  RES - Response  12/19/2022   
NOTE: Plaintiff Kari Lake’s Response to Defendant Secretary of State Katie Hobbs’ Motion to Quash Subpoena for Appearance at Hearing 
12/18/2022  NOT - Notice  12/19/2022   
NOTE: Plaintiff’s Supplemental Designation and Disclosure of Witnesses  
12/17/2022  RES - Response  12/17/2022   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF KARI LAKE’S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS’ MOTIONS TO DISMISS1 
12/17/2022  MOT - Motion  12/17/2022   
NOTE: Motion for Leave to Exceed the Page Limits 
12/17/2022  ORD - Order  12/17/2022   
NOTE: ORDER GRANTING MOTION FOR LEAVE TO EXCEED PAGE LIMITS 
12/17/2022  ORD - Order  12/17/2022   
NOTE: GRANTING MOTION TO FILE AMICUS BRIEF 
12/17/2022  MOT - Motion  12/18/2022   
NOTE: Motion to Quash Subpoena for Appearance at Hearing 
12/16/2022  PHA - Pro Hac Vice Application  12/16/2022   
NOTE: Motion for Admission Pro Hac Vice 
12/16/2022  MTD - Motion To Dismiss  12/16/2022   
NOTE: CONTESTEE KATIE HOBBS’S MOTION TO DISMISS 
12/16/2022  MOT - Motion  12/16/2022   
NOTE: Motion for Expedited Discovery 
12/16/2022  RES - Response  12/16/2022   
NOTE: CONTESTEE KATIE HOBBS’S RESPONSE TO PETITION TO INSPECT BALLOTS 
12/16/2022  PHA - Pro Hac Vice Application  12/16/2022   
NOTE: AMENDED MOTION TO ASSOCIATE COUNSEL 
12/16/2022  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  12/16/2022   
12/16/2022  RES - Response  12/16/2022   
NOTE: Maricopa County Defendants' Response to Plaintiff's Motion to Clarify Order to Inspect Ballots 
12/16/2022  NDC - Notice Of Deposit With Court  12/16/2022   
NOTE: $300.00 / KARI LAKE 
12/16/2022  NOT - Notice  12/16/2022   
NOTE: Maricopa County Defendants' Notice Regarding the Inspectors of the Ballots 
12/16/2022  NOT - Notice  12/16/2022   
NOTE: NOTICE OF PAYMENT OF BOND AND DESIGNATION OF PLAINTIFF’S REPRESENTATIVE FOR BALLOT INSPECTION 
12/16/2022  NOT - Notice  12/16/2022   
NOTE: ARIZONA SECRETARY OF STATE’S NOTICE OF PARTIAL JOINDER IN MARICOPA COUNTY DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO CLARIFY ORDER TO INSPECT BALLOTS 
12/16/2022  REL - Reply  12/16/2022   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF’S REPLY TO MARICOPA COUNTY’S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO CLARIFY ORDER TO INSPECT BALLOTS 
12/16/2022  REL - Reply  12/16/2022   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF’S REPLY TO MARICOPA COUNTY’S RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO CLARIFY ORDER TO INSPECT BALLOTS 
12/16/2022  RES - Response  12/16/2022   
NOTE: Maricopa County Defendants' Response in Opposition to Motion to Expedite Discovery 
12/16/2022  019 - ME: Ruling  12/16/2022   
12/16/2022  RES - Response  12/16/2022   
NOTE: CONTESTEE KATIE HOBBS’S RESPONSE TO MOTION TO CLARIFY 
12/16/2022  REL - Reply  12/16/2022   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF’S REPLY TO MARICOPA COUNTY’S OPPISTION TO PLAINTIFF’S MOTION TO EXPEDITE DISCOVERY 
12/16/2022  NOT - Notice  12/16/2022   
NOTE: CONTESTEE KATIE HOBBS’S NOTICE REGARDING THE INSPECTORS OF THE BALLOTS 
12/16/2022  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  12/16/2022   
NOTE: CONTESTEE KATIE HOBBS’S OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO EXPEDITE DISCOVERY 
12/16/2022  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  12/16/2022   
12/16/2022  MTQ - Motion To Quash  12/17/2022   
NOTE: Motion to Quash Subpoena of Stephen Richer 
12/16/2022  022 - ME: Order Signed  12/16/2022   
12/16/2022  019 - ME: Ruling  12/16/2022   
12/16/2022  MOT - Motion  12/16/2022   
NOTE: MOTION TO CLARIFY REQUEST IN VERIFIED AMENDED PETITION TO INSPECT BALLOTS 
12/16/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/21/2022   
12/16/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/21/2022   
12/16/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/21/2022   
12/16/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/21/2022   
12/15/2022  ORD - Order  12/22/2022   
NOTE: GRANTING MOTION FOR LEAVE TO EXTEED PAGE LIMITS 
12/15/2022  PHA - Pro Hac Vice Application  12/16/2022   
NOTE: Amended Motion to Associate Counsel 
12/15/2022  PHA - Pro Hac Vice Application  12/15/2022   
NOTE: Motion to Associate Counsel Pro Hac Vice - Abha Khanna 
12/15/2022  PHA - Pro Hac Vice Application  12/15/2022   
NOTE: Motion to Associate Pro Hac Vice - Lalitha D. Madduri 
12/15/2022  MTD - Motion To Dismiss  12/15/2022   
NOTE: Maricopa County Defendants' Motion to Dismiss 
12/15/2022  MOT - Motion  12/15/2022   
NOTE: Motion for Leave to Exceed Page Limits 
12/15/2022  CER - Certificate  12/15/2022   
NOTE: Certification of Counsel Pursuant to Rule 7.1(h) Ariz. R. Civ. P. 
12/15/2022  CER - Certificate  12/15/2022   
NOTE: Maricopa County's Defendants' Rule 7.1(h) Good Faith Consultation Certificate 
12/15/2022  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  12/15/2022   
NOTE: Arizona Secretary of State's Objection to Verified Amended Petition to Inspect Ballots 
12/15/2022  MTD - Motion To Dismiss  12/15/2022   
NOTE: ARIZONA SECRETARY OF STATE'S MOTION TO DISMISS COMPLAINT IN SPECIAL ACTION AND VERIFIED STATEMENT OF ELECTION CONTEST 
12/14/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/16/2022   
NOTE: STEPHEN RICHER 
12/14/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/16/2022   
NOTE: KATIE HOBBS 
12/14/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/16/2022   
NOTE: SCOTT JARRETT 
12/14/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/16/2022   
NOTE: BILL GATES 
12/14/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/16/2022   
NOTE: CLINT HICKMAN 
12/14/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/16/2022   
NOTE: JACK SELLERS 
12/14/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/16/2022   
NOTE: MARICOPA COUNTY 
12/14/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/16/2022   
NOTE: THOMAS GALVIN 
12/14/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/16/2022   
NOTE: STEVE GALLARDO 
12/14/2022  RES - Response  12/14/2022   
NOTE: MARICOPA COUNTY’S RESPONSE TO PETITIONER’S VERIFIED PETITION TO INSPECT BALLOTS PURSUANT TO A.R.S. § 16-677 
12/14/2022  PTT - Petition  12/14/2022   
NOTE: VERIFIED AMENDED PETITION TO INSPECT BALLOTS PURSUANT TO A.R.S. § 16-677 
12/14/2022  RES - Response  12/15/2022   
NOTE: Maricopa County's Response to Petitioner's Amended Verified Petition to Inspect Ballots 
12/14/2022  REL - Reply  12/15/2022   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF’S REPLY TO MARICOPA COUNTY’S OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFF’S VERIFIED AMENDED PETITION TO INSPECT BALLOTS PURSUANT TO A.R.S. § 16-677 
12/14/2022  MOT - Motion  12/15/2022   
NOTE: HELEN PURCELL'S AND TAMMY PATRICK’'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMICI CURIAE BRIEF 
12/14/2022  MOT - Motion  12/15/2022   
NOTE: HELEN PURCELL'S AND TAMMY PATRICK'S MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMICI CURIAE BRIEF 
12/14/2022  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  12/14/2022   
12/14/2022  019 - ME: Ruling  12/14/2022   
12/13/2022  MOT - Motion  12/14/2022   
NOTE: VERIFIED PETITION TO INSPECT BALLOTS PURSUANT TO A.R.S. 16-677 
12/13/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/15/2022   
NOTE: STEPHEN RICHER 
12/13/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/15/2022   
NOTE: BILL GATES 
12/13/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/15/2022   
NOTE: CLINT HICKMAN 
12/13/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/15/2022   
NOTE: JACK SELLERS 
12/13/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/15/2022   
NOTE: STEVE GALLARDO 
12/13/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/15/2022   
NOTE: MARICOPA COUNTY 
12/13/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/15/2022   
NOTE: SCOTT JARRETT 
12/13/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/15/2022   
NOTE: KATIE HOBBS 
12/13/2022  022 - ME: Order Signed  12/13/2022   
12/13/2022  056 - ME: Hearing Set  12/13/2022   
12/13/2022  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/16/2022   
NOTE: THOMAS GALVIN 
12/13/2022  NAR - Notice Of Appearance  12/13/2022   
NOTE: Maricopa County Defendants' Notice of Appearance 
12/12/2022  EXH - Exhibit  12/12/2022   
NOTE: EXHIBITS TO MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT ATTACHMENTS A AND C OF CONTESTANT/PLAINTIFFS COMPLAINT 
12/12/2022  MOT - Motion  12/19/2022   
NOTE: TO SUPPLEMENT ATTACHMNETS A AN DC OF CONTESTANT/PLNTIFFS COMLAIT IN SPECIAL ACTION AD VERIFIED STATEMENT OF ELECTION CONTEST PURSUANT TO ARS 16-672 
12/12/2022  NAR - Notice Of Appearance  12/13/2022   
NOTE: NOTICE OF APPEARANCE 
12/12/2022  ORD - Order  12/12/2022   
NOTE: GRANTING CONTESTANT-PLAINTIFFS EXPEDITED EX PARTE MOTION TO STRIKE AND SUBSTITUTE ATTACHMENT C 
12/12/2022  MOT - Motion  12/12/2022   
NOTE: EXPEDITED EX PARTE / TO STRIKE AND SUBSTITUTE ATTACHMENT C TO CONTESTANT / PLAINTIFFS COMPLAINT IN SPECIAL ACTION AND VERIFIED STATEMENT OF ELECTION CONTEST 
12/12/2022  EXH - Exhibit  12/12/2022   
12/12/2022  ORD - Order  12/12/2022   
NOTE: ORDER TO APPEAR RETURN HEARING 
12/12/2022  NAR - Notice Of Appearance  12/12/2022   
NOTE: Notice of Appearance 
12/12/2022  ORD - Order  12/14/2022   
NOTE: GRANTING CONTESTANT-PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO SUPPLEMENT ATTACHMENTS A AND C OF CONTESTANT/PLAINTIFFS COMPLAINT IN SPECIAL ACTION AND VERIFIED STATEMENT OF ELECTION CONTEST PURSUANT TO ARS 16-672 
12/9/2022  CSH - Coversheet  12/9/2022   
12/9/2022  COM - Complaint  12/9/2022   
Case Calendar
Date Time Event
12/13/2022  11:00  Order To Show Cause 
12/19/2022  9:00  Oral Argument 
12/21/2022  9:00  Evidentiary Hearing 
12/22/2022  9:00  Evidentiary Hearing 
Judgments
There are no judgments on file