« Return to search results
Case Information
Case Number:
CV2020-055465
Judge:
Gordon, Michael
File Date:
10/15/2020
Location:
Downtown
Case Type:
Civil
Party Information
Party Name
Relationship
Sex
Attorney
Party Name
Ron Macdonald
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Male
Attorney
Pro Per
Party Name
Marianne Macdonald
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Female
Attorney
Pro Per
Party Name
Ronald Tovella
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Male
Attorney
Mary Dowling
Party Name
Rita Tovella
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Female
Attorney
Mary Dowling
Party Name
Tovella Holdings I, L L C
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Attorney
Mary Dowling
Party Name
Gerald Case
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Male
Attorney
Pro Per
Case Documents
Filing Date
Description
Docket Date
Filing Party
Filing Date
10/6/2025
Description
047 - ME: Judgment Of Dismissal
Docket Date
10/6/2025
Filing Party
Filing Date
6/17/2025
Description
375 - Case on Dismissal Calendar
Docket Date
6/17/2025
Filing Party
Filing Date
6/2/2025
Description
RNM - Returned Mail
Docket Date
6/2/2025
Filing Party
NOTE:
Filing Date
5/14/2025
Description
RNM - Returned Mail
Docket Date
5/14/2025
Filing Party
NOTE:
Filing Date
4/18/2025
Description
OCW - Order for Withdrawal of Counsel
Docket Date
4/18/2025
Filing Party
NOTE:
ORDER GRANTING MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR FOR DEFENDANT BELSITO PLUMBING
Filing Date
4/11/2025
Description
RNM - Returned Mail
Docket Date
4/11/2025
Filing Party
NOTE:
Filing Date
3/31/2025
Description
085 - ME: Conference
Docket Date
3/31/2025
Filing Party
Filing Date
3/20/2025
Description
MFW - Motion For Withdraw of counsel
Docket Date
3/20/2025
Filing Party
NOTE:
MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR DEFENDANT BELSITO PLUMBING, LLC
Filing Date
2/24/2025
Description
083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont
Docket Date
2/24/2025
Filing Party
Filing Date
1/7/2025
Description
MFW - Motion For Withdraw of counsel
Docket Date
1/8/2025
Filing Party
NOTE:
MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD FOR DEFENDANT BELSITO PLUMBING, LLC
Filing Date
1/6/2025
Description
026 - ME: Pretrial Conference Set
Docket Date
1/6/2025
Filing Party
Filing Date
12/24/2024
Description
ODI - Order Of Dismissal
Docket Date
12/24/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
ORDER GRANTING VOLUNTARY DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE OF CROSS-CLAIMS
Filing Date
12/23/2024
Description
OCW - Order for Withdrawal of Counsel
Docket Date
12/23/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
ORDER ON MOTION TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL AND MOTION TO CONTINUE THE PRE-TRIAL CONFERENCE
Filing Date
12/23/2024
Description
JUD - Judgment
Docket Date
12/23/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
JUDGMENT
Filing Date
12/12/2024
Description
NDI - Notice Of Dismissal
Docket Date
12/13/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
NOTICE OF VOLUNTARY DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICEOF CROSS-CLAIMS AGAINST BELSITO PLUMBING, LLC AND MIGUEL BAHARA
Filing Date
12/12/2024
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
12/13/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ RENEWED MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO RULE 54(b)
Filing Date
10/28/2024
Description
094 - ME: Oral Argument Set
Docket Date
10/28/2024
Filing Party
Filing Date
10/22/2024
Description
MCO - Motion To Continue
Docket Date
10/22/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
Motion to Continue Pre Trial Conference
Filing Date
10/22/2024
Description
MFW - Motion For Withdraw of counsel
Docket Date
10/22/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
Motion to Withdraw as Counsel
Filing Date
9/26/2024
Description
083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont
Docket Date
9/26/2024
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/31/2024
Description
OCW - Order for Withdrawal of Counsel
Docket Date
5/31/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
ORDER TO WITHDRAW AS COUNSEL OF RECORD WITHOUT CONSENT
Filing Date
5/6/2024
Description
MFW - Motion For Withdraw of counsel
Docket Date
5/6/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
Motion to Withdraw as Attorney of Record
Filing Date
2/13/2024
Description
019 - ME: Ruling
Docket Date
2/13/2024
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/6/2024
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
2/7/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR AWARD OF ATTORNEYS’ FEES
Filing Date
1/30/2024
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
2/1/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO RULE 54(B)
Filing Date
1/25/2024
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
1/29/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
Response to Motion for Attorney's Fees
Filing Date
1/18/2024
Description
OBJ - Objection/Opposition
Docket Date
1/22/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS’ OBJECTION TO FORM OF PROPOSED JUDGMENT LODGED BY DEFENDANTS TOVELLA
Filing Date
1/17/2024
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
1/22/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS’ RESPONSE AND OBJECTIONS TO STATEMENT OF FACTS BY DEFENDANTS TOVELLA
Filing Date
1/10/2024
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
1/16/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO RULE 54(B) -ANDMOTION FOR AWARD OF ATTORNEYS’ FEES AND TAXABLE COSTS
Filing Date
1/10/2024
Description
SOC - Statement Of Costs
Docket Date
1/16/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
STATEMENT OF COSTS AND NOTICE OF TAXATION OF COSTS
Filing Date
1/10/2024
Description
ASR - Affidavit in Support of Attorney Fees
Docket Date
1/16/2024
Filing Party
NOTE:
Affidavit of Attorneys' Fees
Filing Date
12/22/2023
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
12/28/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
NOTICE OF CHANGE OF ADDRESS FOR COUNSEL FOR DEFENDANT BELSITO PLUMBING
Filing Date
12/5/2023
Description
926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling
Docket Date
12/5/2023
Filing Party
Filing Date
10/19/2023
Description
020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement
Docket Date
10/19/2023
Filing Party
Filing Date
10/6/2023
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
10/6/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ SUPPLEMENTAL STATEMENT OF FACTS
Filing Date
10/6/2023
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
10/6/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
REVISED TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ SUPPLEMENTAL STATEMENT OF FACTS
Filing Date
10/4/2023
Description
SOF - Statement Of Facts
Docket Date
10/4/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS’ SUPPLEMENTAL SEPARATE STATEMENT OF FACTS IN RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT BY DEFENDANTS TOVELLA
Filing Date
8/29/2023
Description
094 - ME: Oral Argument Set
Docket Date
8/29/2023
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/23/2023
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
8/24/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO STRIKE
Filing Date
8/16/2023
Description
ORD - Order
Docket Date
8/16/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
ORDER GRANTING TOVELLA DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO EXCEED PAGE LIMITATION FOR THEIR REPLY IN SUPPORT OF SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Filing Date
8/11/2023
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
8/11/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION TO STRIKE DECLARATION OF RONALD TOVELLA
Filing Date
8/11/2023
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
8/14/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO EXCEED PAGE LIMITATION FOR THEIR REPLY IN SUPPORT OF SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Filing Date
8/11/2023
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
8/14/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
Tovella Defendants' Reply in Support of their Motion for Summary Judgment
Filing Date
8/10/2023
Description
095 - ME: Oral Argument Reset
Docket Date
8/10/2023
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/7/2023
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
8/9/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ NOTICE OF FIRST EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Filing Date
7/21/2023
Description
095 - ME: Oral Argument Reset
Docket Date
7/21/2023
Filing Party
Filing Date
7/18/2023
Description
NOF - Notice Of Filing
Docket Date
7/18/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Filing Exhibit A
Filing Date
7/18/2023
Description
OBJ - Objection/Opposition
Docket Date
7/18/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
Plaintiffs Response and Objections to Statement of Facts
Filing Date
7/17/2023
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
7/17/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT BY DEFENDANTS TOVELLA
Filing Date
7/17/2023
Description
SOF - Statement Of Facts
Docket Date
7/17/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS’ SEPARATE STATEMENT OF FACTS IN RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT BY DEFENDANTS TOVELLA
Filing Date
7/5/2023
Description
094 - ME: Oral Argument Set
Docket Date
7/5/2023
Filing Party
Filing Date
6/26/2023
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
6/26/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS’ REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR 26.2 RELIEF
Filing Date
6/20/2023
Description
MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment
Docket Date
6/20/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Filing Date
6/20/2023
Description
SOF - Statement Of Facts
Docket Date
6/20/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ SEPARATE STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
Filing Date
6/19/2023
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
6/20/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR 26.2 RELIEF
Filing Date
5/31/2023
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
5/31/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR 26.2 RELIEF ORAL ARGUMENT REQUESTED
Filing Date
5/17/2023
Description
029 - ME: Status Conference
Docket Date
5/17/2023
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/11/2023
Description
028 - ME: Status Conference Set
Docket Date
5/11/2023
Filing Party
Filing Date
4/21/2023
Description
STA - Statement
Docket Date
4/21/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
Joint Statement of Discovery Dispute
Filing Date
2/21/2023
Description
NSC - Notice of Substitution of Counsel
Docket Date
2/24/2023
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Substitution of Counsel Within Firm
Filing Date
12/14/2022
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
12/20/2022
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/8/2022
Description
SCO – Scheduling Order
Docket Date
8/8/2022
Filing Party
NOTE:
Order
Filing Date
7/25/2022
Description
JSR – Joint Scheduling Report
Docket Date
7/28/2022
Filing Party
NOTE:
Joint Report
Filing Date
6/16/2022
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
6/20/2022
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Association of Counsel
Filing Date
3/22/2022
Description
ANS - Answer
Docket Date
3/26/2022
Filing Party
NOTE:
DEFENDANTS’ ANSWER TO COMPLAINT
Filing Date
3/8/2022
Description
926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling
Docket Date
3/8/2022
Filing Party
Filing Date
1/20/2022
Description
020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement
Docket Date
1/20/2022
Filing Party
Filing Date
12/16/2021
Description
094 - ME: Oral Argument Set
Docket Date
12/16/2021
Filing Party
Filing Date
11/4/2021
Description
WSS - Waiver Of Service Of Summons
Docket Date
11/8/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
WAIVER OF SERVICE RE: CROSSCLAIMS AGAINST CROSSDEFENDANT BELSITO PLUMBING LLC
Filing Date
10/15/2021
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
10/15/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS’ RESPONSE TO MOTION TO DISMISS BY DEFENDANTS TOVELLA
Filing Date
9/15/2021
Description
023 - ME: Order Entered By Court
Docket Date
9/15/2021
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/25/2021
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
8/31/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
NOTICE OF STIPULATION REGARDING RESPONSE TO MOTION TO DIMISS
Filing Date
8/16/2021
Description
CAN - Credit Memo Appearance Fee Paid
Docket Date
8/16/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
Credit Memo/Appearance Fee Paid
Filing Date
8/2/2021
Description
MTD - Motion To Dismiss
Docket Date
8/4/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ MOTION TO DISMISS PLAINTIFFS’ COMPLAINT
Filing Date
8/2/2021
Description
CLM - Claim
Docket Date
8/4/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA DEFENDANTS’ CROSSCLAIMS AGAINST CROSSDEFENDANTS PLUMBING LLC AND MIGUEL BAHERA FOR: 1.) EQUITABLE INDEMNITY 2.) CONTRIBUTION 3.) NEGLIGENCE 4.) DECLARATORY RELIEF 5.) IMPLIED INDEMNITY 6.) EXPRESS INDEMNITY 7.) BREACH OF CONTRACT
Filing Date
5/5/2021
Description
023 - ME: Order Entered By Court
Docket Date
5/5/2021
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/5/2021
Description
ANS - Answer
Docket Date
5/6/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
Answer / EFILE BILLING $245.00
Filing Date
4/30/2021
Description
AAE - Application/Affidavit And Entry Of Default
Docket Date
5/3/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
Affidavit on Default AS TO BELSITO PLUMBING LLC
Filing Date
4/30/2021
Description
AAE - Application/Affidavit And Entry Of Default
Docket Date
5/3/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
Application for Entry of Default AS TO Belsito Plumbing LLC
Filing Date
4/30/2021
Description
AAE - Application/Affidavit And Entry Of Default
Docket Date
5/3/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
APPLICATION FOR ENTRY OF DEFAULT AS TO MIGUEL BAHERA AKA MIGUEL BAHENA
Filing Date
4/30/2021
Description
AAE - Application/Affidavit And Entry Of Default
Docket Date
5/3/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
Affidavit on Default AS TO MIGUEL BAHERA
Filing Date
1/20/2021
Description
AFM - Affidavit of Service Registered/Certified Mail
Docket Date
1/25/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
BELSITO PLUMBING LLC
Filing Date
1/13/2021
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
1/19/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
BELSITO PLUMBING LLC
Filing Date
1/12/2021
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
1/14/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
RONALD TOVELLA
Filing Date
1/12/2021
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
1/14/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOVELLA HOLDING I LLC
Filing Date
1/12/2021
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
1/14/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
MIGUEL BAHERA
Filing Date
1/12/2021
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
1/14/2021
Filing Party
NOTE:
RITA TOVELLA
Filing Date
10/27/2020
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
10/29/2020
Filing Party
NOTE:
GERALD CASE
Filing Date
10/15/2020
Description
COM - Complaint
Docket Date
10/15/2020
Filing Party
NOTE:
Complaint
Filing Date
10/15/2020
Description
CSH - Coversheet
Docket Date
10/15/2020
Filing Party
NOTE:
Civil Cover Sheet
Filing Date
10/15/2020
Description
CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject
Docket Date
10/15/2020
Filing Party
NOTE:
Certificate Of Compulsory Arbitration - Is Not Subject To
Filing Date
10/15/2020
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
10/15/2020
Filing Party
NOTE:
Summons
Filing Date
10/15/2020
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
10/15/2020
Filing Party
NOTE:
Summons
Filing Date
10/15/2020
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
10/15/2020
Filing Party
NOTE:
Summons
Filing Date
10/15/2020
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
10/15/2020
Filing Party
NOTE:
Summons
Filing Date
10/15/2020
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
10/15/2020
Filing Party
NOTE:
Summons
Filing Date
10/15/2020
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
10/15/2020
Filing Party
NOTE:
Summons
Case Calendar
Date
Time
Event
Date
1/18/2022
Time
9:00
Event
Oral Argument
Date
5/16/2023
Time
8:45
Event
Status Conference
Date
7/21/2023
Time
13:30
Event
Oral Argument
Date
8/4/2023
Time
13:30
Event
Oral Argument
Date
8/24/2023
Time
14:00
Event
Oral Argument
Date
10/4/2023
Time
8:30
Event
Pre-Trial Conference
Date
10/6/2023
Time
11:00
Event
Oral Argument
Date
10/6/2023
Time
11:00
Event
Pre-Trial Conference
Date
10/24/2024
Time
11:00
Event
Pre-Trial Conference
Date
10/25/2024
Time
9:00
Event
Pre-Trial Conference
Date
12/16/2024
Time
9:30
Event
Trial
Date
12/17/2024
Time
9:30
Event
Trial
Date
12/18/2024
Time
9:30
Event
Trial
Date
12/19/2024
Time
9:30
Event
Trial
Date
12/20/2024
Time
9:00
Event
Oral Argument
Date
12/20/2024
Time
9:00
Event
Status Conference
Date
2/20/2025
Time
8:30
Event
Pre-Trial Conference
Date
3/20/2025
Time
8:30
Event
Pre-Trial Conference
Judgments
Date
(F)or / (A)gainst
Amount
Frequency
Type
Status
Date
12/23/2024
(F)or / (A)gainst
F:  Ronald Tovella, Rita Tovella, Tovella Holdings I, L L C
A: Ron Macdonald
Amount
$532.29
Frequency
One Time
Type
Costs
Status
Date
12/23/2024
(F)or / (A)gainst
F:  Ronald Tovella, Rita Tovella, Tovella Holdings I, L L C
A: Ron Macdonald
Amount
$85,000.00
Frequency
One Time
Type
Attorney Fee
Status