Civil Court Case Information - Case History

« Return to search results
Case Information
Case Number: CV2017-001742 Judge: Moskowitz, Frank
File Date: 3/1/2017 Location: Downtown
Case Type: Civil  
Party Information
Party Name Relationship Sex Attorney
Mat Englehorn   Plaintiff  Male  Jonathan Riches 
Hopelessly Urban L L C   Plaintiff    Jonathan Riches 
Flying E, L L C   Plaintiff    Jonathan Riches 
Bramley Paulin   Plaintiff  Male  Jonathan Riches 
Culver Park-1129 North First Street L L C   Plaintiff    Jonathan Riches 
Austin Shea Arizona-7th Street And Van Buren L L C   Plaintiff    Jonathan Riches 
Sal Diciccio   Defendant  Male  Kristin Windtberg 
Michael Nowakowski   Defendant  Male  Kristin Windtberg 
Kate Gallego   Defendant  Female  Kristin Windtberg 
City Of Phoenix   Defendant    Kristin Windtberg 
Case Documents
Filing Date Description Docket Date Filing Party
9/21/2020  019 - ME: Ruling  9/21/2020   
9/4/2020  REL - Reply  9/9/2020   
NOTE: DEFENDANT CITY OF PHOENIX’S REPLY SUPPORTING MOTION TO PARTIALLY AMEND FINDINGS AND JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO RULES 52 AND 59 AND RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ CROSS-MOTION TO PARTIALLY AMEND FINAL JUDGMENT 
8/25/2020  RES - Response  8/25/2020   
NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ RESPONSE TO CITY’S MOTION TO PARTIALLY AMEND FINDINGS AND JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO RULES 52 AND 59 and CROSS-MOTION TO PARTIALLY AMEND FINAL JUDGMENT 
8/18/2020  049 - ME: Judgment Signed  8/18/2020   
8/17/2020  JUD - Judgment  8/19/2020   
NOTE: Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties 
8/12/2020  REL - Reply  8/13/2020   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Reply in Support of Motion for an Award of Attorney Fees and Costs 
8/11/2020  NWA - Notice Withdrawal Of Attorney  8/12/2020   
NOTE: Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel 
8/7/2020  MTA - Motion To Amend  8/7/2020   
NOTE: DEFENDANT CITY OF PHOENIX’S MOTION TO PARTIALLY AMEND FINDINGS AND JUDGMENT PURSUANT TO RULES 52 AND 59 
7/31/2020  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  7/31/2020   
NOTE: DEFENDANT CITY OF PHOENIXS Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for an Award of Attorney Fees and Costs 
7/13/2020  EXW - Exhibits Work Sheet  7/16/2020   
7/10/2020  AAF - Application For Attorney Fees  7/10/2020   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Motion for an Award of Attorney Fees and Costs 
7/10/2020  ASR - Affidavit in Support of Attorney Fees  7/13/2020   
NOTE: Declaration of Jonathan Riches in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for Award of Attorneys' Fees and Costs 
7/10/2020  NOT - Notice  7/13/2020   
NOTE: Notice of Lodging Proposed Form of Judgment 
6/24/2020  WSH - Worksheet  7/7/2020   
NOTE: EXHIBIT 
6/19/2020  926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling  6/19/2020   
6/11/2020  012 - ME: Trial  6/11/2020   
6/11/2020  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  6/11/2020   
6/10/2020  WSH - Worksheet  6/11/2020   
NOTE: TRIAL/HEARING 
6/10/2020  NOT - Notice  6/11/2020   
6/10/2020  NOT - Notice  6/11/2020   
6/10/2020  EXH - Exhibit  6/15/2020   
6/10/2020  NOT - Notice  6/22/2020   
NOTE: INTRODUCTION 
6/9/2020  012 - ME: Trial  6/9/2020   
6/9/2020  012 - ME: Trial  6/9/2020   
6/9/2020  012 - ME: Trial  6/9/2020   
6/9/2020  REQ - Request  6/9/2020   
NOTE: Defendant City of Phoenix's Request for Judicial Notice 
6/8/2020  DPR - Deposition Report  6/25/2020   
NOTE: ROBERT DAVID LOZIER 
6/8/2020  DPR - Deposition Report  6/25/2020   
NOTE: CHRISTINE MACKAY 
6/8/2020  DPR - Deposition Report  6/25/2020   
NOTE: ALAN STEPHENSON 
6/8/2020  DPR - Deposition Report  6/25/2020   
NOTE: BRYCE COOK 
6/8/2020  DPR - Deposition Report  6/25/2020   
NOTE: ALAN STEPHENSON 
6/8/2020  DPR - Deposition Report  6/25/2020   
NOTE: KEVIN JAMES MCCARTHY 
6/2/2020  012 - ME: Trial  6/2/2020   
5/21/2020  ORD - Order  5/22/2020   
NOTE: RE: PLAINTIFFS AND DEFENDANTS DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS 
5/19/2020  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  5/19/2020   
5/15/2020  NOT - Notice  5/15/2020   
NOTE: Notice of Lodging Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law 
5/14/2020  048 - ME: Informal Conference  5/14/2020   
5/13/2020  REQ - Request  5/13/2020   
NOTE: Defendant City of Phoenix's Request for Court Reporter 
5/8/2020  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  5/8/2020   
5/8/2020  NOT - Notice  5/11/2020   
NOTE: Notice of Lodging [Proposed] Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law 
4/24/2020  026 - ME: Pretrial Conference Set  4/24/2020   
4/21/2020  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  4/21/2020   
4/16/2020  STA - Statement  4/17/2020   
NOTE: Amended Joint Pretrial Statement 
4/13/2020  MEM - Memorandum  4/15/2020   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Trial Memorandum 
4/13/2020  STA - Statement  4/16/2020   
NOTE: Joint Pretrial Statement 
4/13/2020  MEM - Memorandum  4/16/2020   
NOTE: Defendant City of Phoenix's Trial Memorandum 
4/10/2020  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  4/10/2020   
4/10/2020  019 - ME: Ruling  4/10/2020   
4/6/2020  RES - Response  4/8/2020   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 2 re: Evidence of the Systemic Effects of GPLET on Property Tax Rolls 
4/6/2020  RES - Response  4/8/2020   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendants' Motion in Limine No. 1 re: Evidence of the "Stewart Project" 
4/2/2020  025 - ME: Case Status Minute Entry  4/2/2020   
3/20/2020  MIL - Motion In Limine  3/23/2020   
NOTE: Motion in Limine No. 2 re Evidence of Systemic Effects of GPLET on Property Tax Rolls 
3/20/2020  MIL - Motion In Limine  3/23/2020   
NOTE: DEFENDANT’S MOTION IN LIMINE NO. 1 RE: EVIDENCE OF THE “STEWART PROJECT" 
3/2/2020  002 - ME: Hearing Vacated  3/2/2020   
3/2/2020  005 - ME: Hearing  3/2/2020   
2/27/2020  028 - ME: Status Conference Set  2/27/2020   
2/12/2020  025 - ME: Case Status Minute Entry  2/12/2020   
2/6/2020  NOT - Notice  2/10/2020   
NOTE: Notice of Withdrawal of Motion to Exclude Opinions of Michael Scott Powell Under Rule 702 
2/5/2020  ORD - Order  2/5/2020   
NOTE: EXTENDING THE DEADLINES FOR PARTIES TO SUBMIT SETTLEMENT CONFERENCE MEMORANDA FROM 02/06/2020-02/24/2020 
2/5/2020  NOT - Notice  2/7/2020   
NOTE: Notice of Withdrawal of Expert Witness 
2/4/2020  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  2/4/2020   
1/31/2020  STP - Stipulation  2/4/2020   
NOTE: Stipulation to Extend Time to Submit Settlement Conference Memoranda 
1/30/2020  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  1/30/2020   
1/27/2020  REL - Reply  1/30/2020   
NOTE: Defendant City's Reply in Support of its Motion for Trial by the Court AND Response to Motion for Advisory Jury in the Alternative 
1/17/2020  095 - ME: Oral Argument Reset  1/17/2020   
1/15/2020  MOT - Motion  1/21/2020   
NOTE: Defendant's Motion to Exclude Opinions of Michael Scott Powell Under Rule 702 
1/15/2020  ORD - Order  1/15/2020   
NOTE: Order 
1/10/2020  NOT - Notice  1/13/2020   
NOTE: Notice of First Extension of Time to File Reply in Support of Motion for Trial by the Court 
1/10/2020  MOT - Motion  1/14/2020   
NOTE: Defendant's Unopposed Motion for Leave to File Motion to Exclude Opinions of Michael Scott Powell Under Rule 702 
12/30/2019  RES - Response  12/31/2019   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant City's Motion for Trial by the Court and Motion for Advisory Jury in the Alternative 
12/11/2019  070 - ME: Settlement Conference Set  12/11/2019   
12/9/2019  ORD - Order  12/9/2019   
NOTE: RESETTING ORAL ARGUMENT 
12/4/2019  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  12/4/2019   
12/3/2019  MOT - Motion  12/6/2019   
NOTE: Unopposed Motion to Reset Oral Argument 
12/3/2019  NOT - Notice  12/6/2019   
NOTE: Notice of First Extension of Time to File Response to Motion for Trial by the Court 
11/21/2019  070 - ME: Settlement Conference Set  11/21/2019   
11/20/2019  MOT - Motion  11/22/2019   
NOTE: Motion for Trial by the Court 
11/15/2019  029 - ME: Status Conference  11/15/2019   
11/8/2019  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  11/8/2019   
11/7/2019  ORD - Order  11/7/2019   
NOTE: extending the deadline for the parties to conduct the settlement conference until February 28, 2020; and / referring this matter to the Court’s Alternative Dispute Resolution Office for conducting the settlement conference contemplated herein and under the Court’s October 1, 2019 Minute Entry 
11/4/2019  MOT - Motion  11/5/2019   
NOTE: Joint Motion to Extend Deadline to Conduct Settlement Conference and to Refer Case for Settlement Conference 
10/18/2019  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  10/18/2019   
10/10/2019  089 - ME: Trial Setting  10/10/2019   
10/10/2019  REQ - Request  10/11/2019   
NOTE: Request for Telephonic Status Conference 
9/20/2019  NAR - Notice Of Appearance  9/25/2019   
NOTE: Notice of Appearance 
9/18/2019  003 - ME: Hearing Reset  9/18/2019   
8/30/2019  926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling  8/30/2019   
8/29/2019  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  8/29/2019   
7/2/2019  019 - ME: Ruling  7/2/2019   
6/27/2019  RES - Response  6/28/2019   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Motion to Strike 
6/21/2019  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  6/21/2019   
6/20/2019  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  6/20/2019   
6/18/2019  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  6/20/2019   
NOTE: Defendant's Objections to Plaintiffs' Additional Supplemental Statement of Facts Filed With Their Reply 
6/18/2019  MOT - Motion  6/19/2019   
NOTE: DEFENDANT’S MOTION TO STRIKE PLAINTIFFS’ ADDITIONAL SUPPLEMENTAL STATEMENT OF FACTS FILED WITH THEIR REPLY 
6/7/2019  REL - Reply  6/10/2019   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Reply in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment 
6/7/2019  SOF - Statement Of Facts  6/10/2019   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendants' Statement of Additional Facts and Plaintiffs' Additional Supplemental Statement of Facts 
6/7/2019  REL - Reply  6/11/2019   
NOTE: Defendant's Reply in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment No. 4 (All Counts: Lack of Standing) 
6/7/2019  REL - Reply  6/11/2019   
NOTE: Defendant's Reply in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment No. 1 (Count One: Gift Clause) 
6/7/2019  REL - Reply  6/11/2019   
NOTE: Defendant's Reply in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment No. 3 (Count Six: Slum Blight Designation) 
6/7/2019  REL - Reply  6/11/2019   
NOTE: Defendant's Reply in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment No. 2 (Count Four: Conveyance to Evade Taxation) 
5/17/2019  RES - Response  5/21/2019   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Omnibus Separate Statement of Facts and Plaintiffs' Supplemental Statement of Facts 
5/17/2019  RES - Response  5/21/2019   
NOTE: Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment 
5/17/2019  SOF - Statement Of Facts  5/21/2019   
NOTE: Defendant's Controverting Statement of Facts and Additional Facts 
5/17/2019  RES - Response  5/21/2019   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment No. 4 (Taxpayer Standing) 
5/17/2019  RES - Response  5/21/2019   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant City's Motion for Summary Judgment No. 1 (Count One: Gift Clause) 
5/17/2019  RES - Response  5/21/2019   
NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT CITY’S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT NO. 3 (COUNT SIX: SLUM/BLIGHT DESIGNATION) 
5/17/2019  RES - Response  5/21/2019   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant City's Motion for Summary Judgment No. 2 (Count Four: Conveyance to Evade Taxation)Count 
5/15/2019  ORD - Order  5/15/2019   
NOTE: expanding the page limit of the Citys response to Plaintiffs Motion for Summary Judgment to 20 pages, and expanding the page limit of Plaintiffs reply to 14 pages 
5/13/2019  MOT - Motion  5/14/2019   
NOTE: JOINT MOTION TO EXPAND PAGE LIMITS OF REMAINING BRIEFS FOR PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 
4/12/2019  MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment  4/15/2019   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment 
4/12/2019  SOF - Statement Of Facts  4/15/2019   
NOTE: Statement of Facts in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment 
4/12/2019  MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment  4/15/2019   
NOTE: Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment No. 3 (Count Six Slum/Blight Designation) 
4/12/2019  MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment  4/15/2019   
NOTE: Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment No. 2 (Count Four Conveyance to Evade Taxation) 
4/12/2019  MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment  4/15/2019   
NOTE: Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment No. 1 (Count One Gift Clause) 
4/12/2019  MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment  4/15/2019   
NOTE: Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment No. 4 (All Counts Lack of Standing) 
4/12/2019  SOF - Statement Of Facts  4/15/2019   
NOTE: Defendant's Omnibus Separate Statement of Facts in Support of Motions for Summary Judgment 
3/22/2019  ORD - Order  3/22/2019   
NOTE: modifying the current deadline for dipositive motions. The deadline for filing dispositive motions is hereby extended to April 12, 2019. The deadlines for filing responses remains May 17, 2019 and the deadline for filing replies remains June 7, 2019 
3/20/2019  MOT - Motion  3/21/2019   
NOTE: Joint Motion for Extension of Dispositive Motion Deadline 
3/19/2019  ORD - Order  3/19/2019   
NOTE: modifying the current deadline for responses and replies to dispositive motions / continuing the telephonic Trial Setting Conference 
3/13/2019  MOT - Motion  3/15/2019   
NOTE: Joint Motion for Extension of Time 
2/21/2019  SCO – Scheduling Order  2/21/2019   
NOTE: SECOND AMENDED 
2/18/2019  MOT - Motion  2/19/2019   
NOTE: Joint Motion for Extension of Time 
10/10/2018  SCO – Scheduling Order  10/10/2018   
NOTE: AMENDING 
10/8/2018  MTA - Motion To Amend  10/9/2018   
NOTE: Joint Motion to Amend Scheduling Order 
9/14/2018  019 - ME: Ruling  9/14/2018   
8/17/2018  REL - Reply  8/20/2018   
NOTE: DEFENDANT’S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS NO. 7 (COUNT SIX: BLIGHT DESIGNATION) 
8/6/2018  ORD - Order  8/6/2018   
NOTE: GRANTING STIPULATION 
7/31/2018  STP - Stipulation  8/2/2018   
NOTE: Stipulation to Extend Deadline for Defendant City of Phoenix's Reply in Support of its Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 7 (Count Six: Blight Designation) 
7/26/2018  RES - Response  7/27/2018   
NOTE: Taxpayers' Response to Defendants' Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 7 (Count Six - Blight Designation) 
7/2/2018  ORD - Order  7/2/2018   
NOTE: Order that Plaintiffs’ Motion deadline to respond to Defendants’ Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 7 (Count Six: Blight Designation) is extended to July 27, 2018 
6/27/2018  MOT - Motion  6/28/2018   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Unopposed Motion for Extension of Time 
6/22/2018  MOT - Motion  6/26/2018   
NOTE: Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 7 (Count Six: Blight Designation) 
5/17/2018  SCO – Scheduling Order  5/17/2018   
NOTE: REVISED 
5/14/2018  JSR – Joint Scheduling Report  5/15/2018   
NOTE: Parties' Revised Joint Report 
5/10/2018  019 - ME: Ruling  5/10/2018   
5/8/2018  NOT - Notice  5/10/2018   
4/17/2018  NSC - Notice of Substitution of Counsel  4/19/2018   
NOTE: Notice of Substitution of Counsel Within Same Firm 
2/1/2018  MOT - Motion  2/2/2018   
NOTE: Notice of Withdrawal of Counsel 
1/10/2018  ODI - Order Of Dismissal  1/10/2018   
NOTE: ORDER OF DISMISSAL WITHOUT PREJUDICE 
12/19/2017  SFD - Stipulation For Dismissal  12/20/2017   
NOTE: Stipulation for Dismissal of Plaintiff Culver Park - 120 East Willetta, LLC 
11/15/2017  005 - ME: Hearing  11/15/2017   
11/3/2017  RES - Response  11/6/2017   
NOTE: Defendants Reply in Support of Motion for Judgment on Pleadings No. 6 Count 6 Blight Designation 
11/3/2017  RES - Response  11/6/2017   
NOTE: DEFENDANT’S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS NO. 1 (COUNT ONE: GIFT CLAUSE) 
11/3/2017  RES - Response  11/6/2017   
NOTE: Defendants Reply in Support of ITS Motion for Judgment on THE Pleadings No. 4 (Count FOUR: Conveyance to Evade Taxation) 
11/3/2017  REL - Reply  11/6/2017   
NOTE: DEFENDANT’S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS NO. 5 
11/3/2017  REL - Reply  11/6/2017   
NOTE: DEFENDANT’S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS NO. 3 (COUNT THREE: SPECIAL LAWS CLAUSE) 
11/3/2017  RES - Response  11/6/2017   
NOTE: DEFENDANT’S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS NO. 2 (COUNT TWO: UNIFORMITY CLAUSE) 
10/24/2017  REQ - Request  10/24/2017   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX’S REQUEST FOR COURT REPORTER FOR NOVEMBER 8, 2017 ORAL ARGUMENT 
10/20/2017  RES - Response  10/23/2017   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 2 (Count Two: Uniformity Clause) 
10/20/2017  RES - Response  10/23/2017   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 3 (Count Three: Special Laws Clause) 
10/20/2017  RES - Response  10/23/2017   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 4 (Count Four: Conveyance to Evade Taxation) 
10/20/2017  RES - Response  10/23/2017   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 6 (Count 6 - Blight Designation) 
10/20/2017  RES - Response  10/23/2017   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 1 (Count One: Gift Clause) 
10/20/2017  RES - Response  10/23/2017   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Response to Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 5 (Count Five: Competitive Bidding) 
10/19/2017  025 - ME: Case Status Minute Entry  10/19/2017   
10/13/2017  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  10/13/2017   
10/10/2017  028 - ME: Status Conference Set  10/10/2017   
10/4/2017  MOT - Motion  10/4/2017   
NOTE: Joint Motion to Stay Case Deadlines 
10/2/2017  MOT - Motion  10/3/2017   
NOTE: Joint Motion to Update Case Caption 
9/26/2017  MOT - Motion  9/26/2017   
NOTE: Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 6 (Count Six: Blight Designation) 
9/20/2017  MOT - Motion  9/21/2017   
NOTE: Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 3 (Count Three: Special Laws Clause) 
9/20/2017  MOT - Motion  9/21/2017   
NOTE: Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 4 (Count Four: Conveyance to Evade Taxation) 
9/20/2017  MOT - Motion  9/21/2017   
NOTE: Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 5 (Count Five: Competitive Bidding) 
9/20/2017  MOT - Motion  9/21/2017   
NOTE: Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 2 (Count Two: Uniformity Clause) 
9/20/2017  MOT - Motion  9/25/2017   
NOTE: Defendant's Motion for Judgment on the Pleadings No. 1  
7/11/2017  SCO – Scheduling Order  7/11/2017   
NOTE: Order 
6/22/2017  ODI - Order Of Dismissal  6/22/2017   
NOTE: Greg Stanton, Thelda Williams, Jim Waring, Debra Stark, Laura Pastor, Daniel Valenzuela, Sal DiCiccio, Michael Nowakowski, and Kate Gallego 
6/15/2017  SFD - Stipulation For Dismissal  6/16/2017   
NOTE: Stipulation for Dismissal of Defendants Stanton, Williams, Waring, Stark, Pastor, Valenzuela, DiCiccio, Nowakowski, and Gallego 
6/14/2017  JSR – Joint Scheduling Report  6/15/2017   
NOTE: Joint Report 
4/27/2017  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  4/27/2017   
4/20/2017  ANS - Answer  4/21/2017   
NOTE: Defendants' Amended Answer to Complaint 
4/18/2017  ANS - Answer  4/20/2017   
NOTE: DEFENDANTS’ ANSWER TO COMPLAINT 
4/18/2017  NOT - Notice  4/20/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Errata of Defendants' Amended Answer To Complaint 
3/28/2017  ANS - Answer  3/29/2017   
NOTE: Defendants' Answer to Complaint - Co-chg $237.00 Receipt # 25836550 
3/13/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  3/17/2017   
NOTE: COUNCILMEMBER SAL DICICCIO 
3/13/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  3/17/2017   
NOTE: GREG STANTON 
3/13/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  3/17/2017   
NOTE: COUNCILMEMBER VICE MAYOR KATE GALLEGO 
3/13/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  3/17/2017   
NOTE: COUNCILMEMBER DEBRA STARK 
3/13/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  3/17/2017   
NOTE: COUNCILMEMEBER MICHAEL NOWAKOWSKI 
3/13/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  3/17/2017   
NOTE: COUNCILMEMBER JIM WARING 
3/13/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  3/17/2017   
NOTE: COUNCIL MEMBER THELDA WILLIAMS 
3/13/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  3/17/2017   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX 
3/13/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  3/17/2017   
NOTE: COUNCILMEMBER DANIEL VALENZUELA 
3/13/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  3/17/2017   
NOTE: COUNCILMEMBER LAURA PASTOR 
3/13/2017  SUM - Summons  3/15/2017   
3/13/2017  SUM - Summons  3/15/2017   
3/13/2017  SUM - Summons  3/15/2017   
3/13/2017  SUM - Summons  3/15/2017   
3/13/2017  SUM - Summons  3/15/2017   
3/13/2017  SUM - Summons  3/15/2017   
3/13/2017  SUM - Summons  3/15/2017   
3/13/2017  SUM - Summons  3/15/2017   
3/13/2017  SUM - Summons  3/15/2017   
3/13/2017  SUM - Summons  3/15/2017   
3/1/2017  CSH - Coversheet  3/2/2017   
3/1/2017  CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject  3/2/2017   
3/1/2017  COM - Complaint  3/2/2017   
Case Calendar
Date Time Event
10/10/2017  10:30  Status Conference 
11/8/2017  14:00  Oral Argument 
4/13/2018  9:15  Pre-Trial Conference 
2/8/2019  9:15  Pre-Trial Conference 
4/3/2019  9:00  Pre-Trial Conference 
4/25/2019  9:00  Pre-Trial Conference 
6/18/2019  9:15  Pre-Trial Conference 
8/27/2019  13:30  Oral Argument 
9/26/2019  9:00  Pre-Trial Conference 
10/1/2019  9:15  Pre-Trial Conference 
11/13/2019  9:15  Status Conference 
2/7/2020  9:00  Oral Argument 
2/19/2020  9:00  Oral Argument 
2/20/2020  9:00  Settlement Conference 
2/27/2020  8:30  Status Conference 
2/27/2020  10:00  Oral Argument 
3/9/2020  9:00  Settlement Conference 
4/20/2020  9:00  Pre-Trial Conference 
4/21/2020  9:00  Pre-Trial Conference 
5/21/2020  13:30  Status Conference 
6/1/2020  9:30  Trial 
6/2/2020  9:30  Trial 
6/3/2020  9:30  Trial 
6/4/2020  13:15  Trial 
6/8/2020  9:30  Trial 
6/9/2020  9:30  Trial 
6/10/2020  9:30  Trial 
6/11/2020  9:30  Trial 
Judgments
Date (F)or / (A)gainst Amount Frequency Type Status
8/17/2020  F:Mat Englehorn  $3,574.46  One Time  Costs   
  F:Hopelessly Urban L L C         
  F:Flying E, L L C         
  F:Bramley Paulin         
  F:Culver Park-1129 North First Street L L C         
  F:Austin Shea Arizona-7th Street And Van Buren L L C         
  A: Sal Diciccio         
  A: Michael Nowakowski         
  A: Kate Gallego         
  A: City Of Phoenix         
8/17/2020  F:Mat Englehorn  $50,000.00  One Time  Attorney Fee   
  F:Hopelessly Urban L L C         
  F:Flying E, L L C         
  F:Bramley Paulin         
  F:Culver Park-1129 North First Street L L C         
  F:Austin Shea Arizona-7th Street And Van Buren L L C         
  A: Sal Diciccio         
  A: Michael Nowakowski         
  A: Kate Gallego         
  A: City Of Phoenix