« Return to search results
Case Information
Case Number:
CV2017-001200
Judge:
Coury, Christopher
File Date:
1/31/2017
Location:
Downtown
Case Type:
Civil
Party Information
Party Name
Relationship
Sex
Attorney
Party Name
Kenneth Fields
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Male
Attorney
Colin Campbell
Party Name
Gerald Porter
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Male
Attorney
Colin Campbell
Party Name
Elected Officials Retirement Plan, The
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Attorney
Bennett Cooper
Party Name
State Of Arizona
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Attorney
Charles Grube
Case Documents
Filing Date
Description
Docket Date
Filing Party
Filing Date
9/28/2020
Description
MAJ - Mot/Aff Entry Def Jud W/O Hear
Docket Date
9/30/2020
Filing Party
NOTE:
AFFIRMED
Filing Date
9/28/2020
Description
ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal
Docket Date
9/30/2020
Filing Party
Filing Date
6/7/2019
Description
CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt
Docket Date
6/10/2019
Filing Party
NOTE:
C2C TRANSMISSION RECEIPT
Filing Date
6/7/2019
Description
AIX - Appeals Index
Docket Date
6/10/2019
Filing Party
NOTE:
AMENDED
Filing Date
5/20/2019
Description
MEM - Memorandum
Docket Date
5/21/2019
Filing Party
Filing Date
10/2/2018
Description
CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt
Docket Date
10/3/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
C2C TRANSMISSION RECEIPT
Filing Date
10/2/2018
Description
AIX - Appeals Index
Docket Date
10/3/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
AMENDED ELECTRONIC INDEX OF RECORD
Filing Date
9/19/2018
Description
ANA - Amended Notice Of Appeal
Docket Date
9/20/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
Amended Notice of Appeal
Filing Date
9/18/2018
Description
JUD - Judgment
Docket Date
9/18/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
REVISED FINAL
Filing Date
9/14/2018
Description
OBJ - Objection/Opposition.
Docket Date
9/17/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
Plaintiffs' Objection to States Proposed Revised Final Judgment & Notice of Lodging Alternative Form of Judgment
Filing Date
9/13/2018
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
9/14/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Lodging of Proposed Revised Final Judgment
Filing Date
9/10/2018
Description
019 - ME: Ruling
Docket Date
9/10/2018
Filing Party
Filing Date
9/4/2018
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
9/6/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
State of Arizona's Reply in Support of Motion to Vacate Injunction Pursuant to Rule 60(b)
Filing Date
8/20/2018
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
8/22/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS’ RESPONSE TO STATE’S MOTION TO VACATE INJUNCTION PURSUANT TO RULE 60(b) AND CROSSMOTION FOR RELIEF UNDER RULE 60(b)
Filing Date
8/13/2018
Description
CAO - Court Of Appeals Order
Docket Date
8/15/2018
Filing Party
Filing Date
7/30/2018
Description
MVJ - Motion To Vacate Judgment
Docket Date
8/1/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
State of Arizona's Motion to Vacate Injunction Pursuant to Rule 60(b)
Filing Date
7/6/2018
Description
CAO - Court Of Appeals Order
Docket Date
7/9/2018
Filing Party
Filing Date
4/11/2018
Description
019 - ME: Ruling
Docket Date
4/11/2018
Filing Party
Filing Date
4/2/2018
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
4/4/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
State of Arizona's Motion for Stay of Judgment Pending Appellate Review
Filing Date
3/22/2018
Description
CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt
Docket Date
3/23/2018
Filing Party
Filing Date
3/15/2018
Description
CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt
Docket Date
3/16/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
C2C TRANSMISSION RECEIPT
Filing Date
3/15/2018
Description
AIX - Appeals Index
Docket Date
3/16/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
ELECTRONIC INDEX OF RECORD
Filing Date
2/27/2018
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
2/28/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
Plaintiffs' Notice of Transcript Ordering
Filing Date
2/23/2018
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
2/27/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
State of Arizona's Notice of Intention Not to Order Additional Transcripts Designated by Plaintiffs
Filing Date
2/21/2018
Description
NSC - Notice of Substitution of Counsel
Docket Date
2/22/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Substitution of Counsel Within Firm
Filing Date
2/21/2018
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
2/22/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
Plaintiffs' Designation of Additional Transcripts
Filing Date
2/16/2018
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
2/20/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
State of Arizona's Notice Regarding Transcript Order
Filing Date
2/9/2018
Description
NAP - Notice Of Appeal
Docket Date
2/12/2018
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Appeal / CO-CHG $94.00 R#26406436
Filing Date
1/11/2018
Description
005 - ME: Hearing
Docket Date
1/11/2018
Filing Party
Filing Date
12/21/2017
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
12/21/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Plaintiffs' Reply to Defendants' Responses to Plaintiffs' Motion for New Trial on Remedy
Filing Date
12/12/2017
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
12/12/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
State's Notice of Change of Address
Filing Date
12/8/2017
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
12/11/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of First Extension of Time to File Reply in Support of Motion for New Trial on Remedy
Filing Date
12/1/2017
Description
094 - ME: Oral Argument Set
Docket Date
12/1/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
11/27/2017
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
11/28/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Defendant Elected Officials' Retirement Plan's Response to Plaintiffs' Motion for New Trial on Remedy
Filing Date
11/27/2017
Description
OBJ - Objection/Opposition.
Docket Date
11/28/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
STATE'S OPPOSITION TO Plaintiffs' Motion for New Trial on Remedy
Filing Date
11/14/2017
Description
ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal
Docket Date
11/15/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
11/14/2017
Description
CAO - Court Of Appeals Order
Docket Date
11/15/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
11/6/2017
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
11/7/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Plaintiffs' Motion for New Trial on Remedy
Filing Date
10/25/2017
Description
049 - ME: Judgment Signed
Docket Date
10/25/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
10/24/2017
Description
JUD - Judgment
Docket Date
10/26/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties
Filing Date
10/21/2017
Description
OBJ - Objection/Opposition.
Docket Date
10/23/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
DEFENDANT ELECTED OFFICIALS’ RETIREMENT PLAN’S OBJECTION TO PLAINTIFFS’ PROPOSED FINAL DECLARATORY JUDGMENT AND INJUNCTION
Filing Date
10/20/2017
Description
OBJ - Objection/Opposition.
Docket Date
10/23/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
State's Objection to Proposed Judgment
Filing Date
10/17/2017
Description
016 - ME: Ext/Time/Filing Granted
Docket Date
10/17/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
10/16/2017
Description
CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt
Docket Date
10/17/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
10/13/2017
Description
023 - ME: Order Entered By Court
Docket Date
10/13/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
10/12/2017
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
10/13/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of First Extension of Time to File Objections to Plaintiffs' Proposed Final Declaratory Judgment and Injunction
Filing Date
10/11/2017
Description
NAR - Notice Of Appearance
Docket Date
10/12/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Appearance
Filing Date
10/5/2017
Description
NOF - Notice Of Filing
Docket Date
10/5/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Filing Proposed Final Declaratory Judgment and Injunction
Filing Date
9/28/2017
Description
019 - ME: Ruling
Docket Date
9/28/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
9/28/2017
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
9/28/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Reply in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion that Court Treat the State of Arizona's Notice of Appeal as a Nullity and Rule on the Pending Attorneys' Fee Motion and Enter Judgment
Filing Date
9/28/2017
Description
CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt
Docket Date
9/29/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
C2C TRANSMITTAL RECEIPT
Filing Date
9/28/2017
Description
AIX - Appeals Index
Docket Date
9/29/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
9/27/2017
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
9/28/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of State of ARizona's Request to Suspend Appeal
Filing Date
9/27/2017
Description
OBJ - Objection/Opposition.
Docket Date
9/27/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Opposition to Plaintiffs' Supplemental Application for Attorneys' Fees by State of Arizona
Filing Date
9/26/2017
Description
OBJ - Objection/Opposition.
Docket Date
9/26/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Opposition to Plaitiffs' Motion To Treat Notice of Appeal as a Nullity, Etc., by State of Arizona
Filing Date
9/22/2017
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
9/25/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Supplemental Brief Concerning Attorneys' Fees by State of Arizona
Filing Date
9/22/2017
Description
NOF - Notice Of Filing
Docket Date
9/25/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Filing of Trial Transcript by State of Arizona
Filing Date
9/22/2017
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
9/25/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Plaintiffs' Simultaneous Brief on the Availability of Attorneys' Fees
Filing Date
9/19/2017
Description
ORD - Order
Docket Date
9/22/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
RE BRIEFING OF ATTORNEY FEE ISSUE
Filing Date
9/14/2017
Description
STP - Stipulation
Docket Date
9/15/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Stipulation re Briefing of Attorney Fee Issue
Filing Date
9/13/2017
Description
023 - ME: Order Entered By Court
Docket Date
9/13/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
9/12/2017
Description
AAF - Application For Attorney Fees
Docket Date
9/13/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Supplement to Plaintiffs' Application for Attorneys' Fees and Costs for Time Incurred After August 1, 2017
Filing Date
9/7/2017
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
9/8/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Motion that Court Treat the State of Arizona's Notice of Appeal as a Nullity and Rule on the Pending Attorneys' Fees Motion and Enter Judgment
Filing Date
9/7/2017
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
9/11/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Transcript Order by State of Arizona
Filing Date
8/31/2017
Description
019 - ME: Ruling
Docket Date
8/31/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/31/2017
Description
NAR - Notice Of Appearance
Docket Date
9/1/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Appearance
Filing Date
8/28/2017
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
8/30/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Reply Supporting Motion for Clarification of Injunction by State of Arizona
Filing Date
8/25/2017
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
8/28/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Reply to EORP's Response to Plaintiffs' Response to State of Arizona's Motion to Clarify
Filing Date
8/23/2017
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
8/24/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Defendant Elected Officials' Retirement Plan's Response to Plaintiffs' Response to State of Arizona's Motion to Clarify
Filing Date
8/23/2017
Description
NAP - Notice Of Appeal
Docket Date
8/24/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Appeal by State of Arizona/COCHARGE
Filing Date
8/21/2017
Description
OBJ - Objection/Opposition.
Docket Date
8/23/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS’ APPLICATION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES BY STATE OF ARIZONA
Filing Date
8/16/2017
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
8/17/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Response to State of Arizona's Motion to Clarify
Filing Date
8/15/2017
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
8/16/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Motion for Clarification of Injunction by Sttae of Arizona
Filing Date
8/7/2017
Description
AAF - Application For Attorney Fees
Docket Date
8/7/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Plaintiffs' Application for Attorneys' Fees and Costs
Filing Date
8/7/2017
Description
EXW - Exhibits Work Sheet
Docket Date
8/11/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
7/24/2017
Description
926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling
Docket Date
7/24/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
7/19/2017
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
7/20/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law by State Of Arizona
Filing Date
7/12/2017
Description
020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement
Docket Date
7/12/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
7/11/2017
Description
DPR - Deposition Report
Docket Date
7/13/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
JARED SMOUT 05/26/17 BY KELLY SUE OBLESBY
Filing Date
7/11/2017
Description
DPR - Deposition Report
Docket Date
7/13/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
GABRIEL ROEDER SMITH & CO TESTIMONY OF JAMES ANDERS TELEPHONIC 06/26/2017 BY KELLY SUE OGESBY
Filing Date
7/10/2017
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
7/10/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
DEFENDANT ELECTED OFFICIALS’ RETIREMENT PLAN’S MOTION RE TIMING OF JARED SMOUT’S TRIAL TESTIMONY
Filing Date
7/6/2017
Description
STA - Statement
Docket Date
7/7/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Joint Pretrial Statement
Filing Date
7/3/2017
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
7/6/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Filing Trial Exhibits by State of Arizona
Filing Date
6/29/2017
Description
REQ - Request
Docket Date
6/30/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW AND PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW
Filing Date
6/29/2017
Description
MEM - Memorandum
Docket Date
6/30/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Plaintiffs' Trial Memorandum
Filing Date
6/29/2017
Description
NOF - Notice Of Filing
Docket Date
6/30/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Filing Proposed Final Declaratory Judgment and Injunction
Filing Date
6/29/2017
Description
STA - Statement
Docket Date
6/30/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Trial Brief by State of Arizona
Filing Date
6/1/2017
Description
ANS - Answer
Docket Date
6/5/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Answer of State of Arizona
Filing Date
5/22/2017
Description
020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement
Docket Date
5/22/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/17/2017
Description
019 - ME: Ruling
Docket Date
5/17/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/4/2017
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
5/6/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Supplemental Response to State of Arizona's Motion to Dismiss
Filing Date
5/4/2017
Description
STA - Statement
Docket Date
5/6/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Supplemental Brief Supporting Motion to Dismiss by State of Arizona
Filing Date
4/21/2017
Description
094 - ME: Oral Argument Set
Docket Date
4/21/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
4/21/2017
Description
019 - ME: Ruling
Docket Date
4/21/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
4/17/2017
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
4/19/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Reply Supporting Motion to Dismiss by State of Arizona
Filing Date
4/12/2017
Description
STP - Stipulation
Docket Date
4/13/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Stipulation re Class Allegations
Filing Date
4/5/2017
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
4/6/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Response to State of Arizona's Motion to Dismiss
Filing Date
3/17/2017
Description
ANS - Answer
Docket Date
3/20/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
ANSWER OF DEFENDANT ELECTED OFFICIALS’ RETIREMENT PLAN / CO-CHARGE R# 25812754
Filing Date
3/17/2017
Description
MTD - Motion To Dismiss
Docket Date
3/20/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Motion to Dismiss by State of Arizona
Filing Date
3/13/2017
Description
089 - ME: Trial Setting
Docket Date
3/13/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
3/9/2017
Description
NAR - Notice Of Appearance
Docket Date
3/10/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of Appearance for State of Arizona-CO CHG REC#25793906
Filing Date
2/22/2017
Description
OSC - Order To Show Cause
Docket Date
2/24/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/16/2017
Description
OSC - Order To Show Cause
Docket Date
2/22/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/15/2017
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
2/17/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION AND REQUEST TO CONSOLIDATE TRIAL ON THE MERITS WITH PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION HEARING
Filing Date
2/2/2017
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
2/7/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/2/2017
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
2/7/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/2/2017
Description
066 - ME: Case Reassigned
Docket Date
2/2/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/2/2017
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
2/6/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
NOTICE OF CLAIM OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY REGARDING LEGISLATIVE CHANGES TO A.R.S. § 38-810(C)
Filing Date
2/2/2017
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
2/8/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
THE ELECTED OFFICIALS RETIREMENT PLAN
Filing Date
2/2/2017
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
2/8/2017
Filing Party
NOTE:
STATE OF ARIZONA
Filing Date
1/31/2017
Description
COM - Complaint
Docket Date
2/1/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
1/31/2017
Description
CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject
Docket Date
2/1/2017
Filing Party
Filing Date
1/31/2017
Description
CSH - Coversheet
Docket Date
2/1/2017
Filing Party
Case Calendar
Date
Time
Event
Date
3/8/2017
Time
8:30
Event
Order To Show Cause
Date
3/10/2017
Time
8:30
Event
Order To Show Cause
Date
5/16/2017
Time
9:00
Event
Oral Argument
Date
7/11/2017
Time
9:00
Event
Trial
Date
1/8/2018
Time
15:00
Event
Oral Argument
Judgments
Date
(F)or / (A)gainst
Amount
Frequency
Type
Status
Date
9/18/2018
(F)or / (A)gainst
F:  Kenneth Fields, Gerald Porter
A: State Of Arizona
Amount
$1,899.00
Frequency
One Time
Type
Costs
Status
Date
9/18/2018
(F)or / (A)gainst
F:  Kenneth Fields, Gerald Porter
A: State Of Arizona
Amount
$46,088.80
Frequency
One Time
Type
Attorney Fee
Status
Date
9/18/2018
(F)or / (A)gainst
F:  Kenneth Fields, Gerald Porter
A: State Of Arizona
Amount
$1,899.00
Frequency
One Time
Type
Costs
Status
Date
9/18/2018
(F)or / (A)gainst
F:  Kenneth Fields, Gerald Porter
A: State Of Arizona
Amount
$46,088.80
Frequency
One Time
Type
Attorney Fee
Status
Date
10/24/2017
(F)or / (A)gainst
F:  Kenneth Fields, Gerald Porter
A: Elected Officials Retirement Plan, The
Amount
$1,899.00
Frequency
One Time
Type
Costs
Status
Date
10/24/2017
(F)or / (A)gainst
F:  Kenneth Fields, Gerald Porter
A: Elected Officials Retirement Plan, The
Amount
$43,628.00
Frequency
One Time
Type
Attorney Fee
Status