« Return to search results Civil Court Case Information - Case History
Case Information
Case Number: CV2017-001200 Judge: Thomason, Timothy
File Date: 1/31/2017 Location: Downtown
Case Type: Civil  
Party Information
Party Name Relationship Sex Attorney
Kenneth Fields   Plaintiff  Male  Colin Campbell 
Gerald Porter   Plaintiff  Male  Colin Campbell 
Elected Officials Retirement Plan, The   Defendant    BENNETT COOPER 
State Of Arizona   Defendant    Charles Grube 
Case Documents
Filing Date Description Docket Date Filing Party
11/14/2017  ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal  11/15/2017   
11/14/2017  CAO - Court Of Appeals Order  11/15/2017   
11/6/2017  MOT - Motion  11/7/2017   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Motion for New Trial on Remedy 
10/25/2017  049 - ME: Judgment Signed  10/25/2017   
10/24/2017  JUD - Judgment  10/26/2017   
NOTE: Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties 
10/21/2017  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  10/23/2017   
NOTE: DEFENDANT ELECTED OFFICIALS’ RETIREMENT PLAN’S OBJECTION TO PLAINTIFFS’ PROPOSED FINAL DECLARATORY JUDGMENT AND INJUNCTION 
10/20/2017  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  10/23/2017   
NOTE: State's Objection to Proposed Judgment 
10/17/2017  016 - ME: Ext/Time/Filing Granted  10/17/2017   
10/16/2017  CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt  10/17/2017   
10/13/2017  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  10/13/2017   
10/12/2017  NOT - Notice  10/13/2017   
NOTE: Notice of First Extension of Time to File Objections to Plaintiffs' Proposed Final Declaratory Judgment and Injunction 
10/11/2017  NAR - Notice Of Appearance  10/12/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Appearance 
10/5/2017  NOF - Notice Of Filing  10/5/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Filing Proposed Final Declaratory Judgment and Injunction 
9/28/2017  019 - ME: Ruling  9/28/2017   
9/28/2017  REL - Reply  9/28/2017   
NOTE: Reply in Support of Plaintiffs' Motion that Court Treat the State of Arizona's Notice of Appeal as a Nullity and Rule on the Pending Attorneys' Fee Motion and Enter Judgment 
9/28/2017  CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt  9/29/2017   
NOTE: C2C TRANSMITTAL RECEIPT 
9/28/2017  AIX - Appeals Index  9/29/2017   
9/27/2017  NOT - Notice  9/28/2017   
NOTE: Notice of State of ARizona's Request to Suspend Appeal 
9/27/2017  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  9/27/2017   
NOTE: Opposition to Plaintiffs' Supplemental Application for Attorneys' Fees by State of Arizona 
9/26/2017  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  9/26/2017   
NOTE: Opposition to Plaitiffs' Motion To Treat Notice of Appeal as a Nullity, Etc., by State of Arizona 
9/22/2017  NOT - Notice  9/25/2017   
NOTE: Supplemental Brief Concerning Attorneys' Fees by State of Arizona 
9/22/2017  NOF - Notice Of Filing  9/25/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Filing of Trial Transcript by State of Arizona 
9/22/2017  NOT - Notice  9/25/2017   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Simultaneous Brief on the Availability of Attorneys' Fees 
9/19/2017  ORD - Order  9/22/2017   
NOTE: RE BRIEFING OF ATTORNEY FEE ISSUE 
9/14/2017  STP - Stipulation  9/15/2017   
NOTE: Stipulation re Briefing of Attorney Fee Issue 
9/13/2017  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  9/13/2017   
9/12/2017  AAF - Application For Attorney Fees  9/13/2017   
NOTE: Supplement to Plaintiffs' Application for Attorneys' Fees and Costs for Time Incurred After August 1, 2017 
9/7/2017  MOT - Motion  9/8/2017   
NOTE: Motion that Court Treat the State of Arizona's Notice of Appeal as a Nullity and Rule on the Pending Attorneys' Fees Motion and Enter Judgment 
9/7/2017  NOT - Notice  9/11/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Transcript Order by State of Arizona 
8/31/2017  019 - ME: Ruling  8/31/2017   
8/31/2017  NAR - Notice Of Appearance  9/1/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Appearance 
8/28/2017  REL - Reply  8/30/2017   
NOTE: Reply Supporting Motion for Clarification of Injunction by State of Arizona 
8/25/2017  REL - Reply  8/28/2017   
NOTE: Reply to EORP's Response to Plaintiffs' Response to State of Arizona's Motion to Clarify 
8/23/2017  RES - Response  8/24/2017   
NOTE: Defendant Elected Officials' Retirement Plan's Response to Plaintiffs' Response to State of Arizona's Motion to Clarify 
8/23/2017  NAP - Notice Of Appeal  8/24/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Appeal by State of Arizona/COCHARGE 
8/21/2017  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  8/23/2017   
NOTE: OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS’ APPLICATION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES BY STATE OF ARIZONA 
8/16/2017  RES - Response  8/17/2017   
NOTE: Response to State of Arizona's Motion to Clarify 
8/15/2017  MOT - Motion  8/16/2017   
NOTE: Motion for Clarification of Injunction by Sttae of Arizona 
8/7/2017  AAF - Application For Attorney Fees  8/7/2017   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Application for Attorneys' Fees and Costs 
8/7/2017  EXW - Exhibits Work Sheet  8/11/2017   
7/24/2017  926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling  7/24/2017   
7/19/2017  NOT - Notice  7/20/2017   
NOTE: Proposed Findings of Fact and Conclusions of Law by State Of Arizona 
7/12/2017  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  7/12/2017   
7/11/2017  DPR - Deposition Report  7/13/2017   
NOTE: JARED SMOUT 05/26/17 BY KELLY SUE OBLESBY 
7/11/2017  DPR - Deposition Report  7/13/2017   
NOTE: GABRIEL ROEDER SMITH & CO TESTIMONY OF JAMES ANDERS TELEPHONIC 06/26/2017 BY KELLY SUE OGESBY 
7/10/2017  MOT - Motion  7/10/2017   
NOTE: DEFENDANT ELECTED OFFICIALS’ RETIREMENT PLAN’S MOTION RE TIMING OF JARED SMOUT’S TRIAL TESTIMONY 
7/6/2017  STA - Statement  7/7/2017   
NOTE: Joint Pretrial Statement 
7/3/2017  NOT - Notice  7/6/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Filing Trial Exhibits by State of Arizona 
6/29/2017  REQ - Request  6/30/2017   
NOTE: PLAINTIFFS REQUEST FOR FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW AND PROPOSED FINDINGS OF FACT AND CONCLUSIONS OF LAW 
6/29/2017  MEM - Memorandum  6/30/2017   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Trial Memorandum 
6/29/2017  NOF - Notice Of Filing  6/30/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Filing Proposed Final Declaratory Judgment and Injunction 
6/29/2017  STA - Statement  6/30/2017   
NOTE: Trial Brief by State of Arizona 
6/1/2017  ANS - Answer  6/5/2017   
NOTE: Answer of State of Arizona 
5/22/2017  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  5/22/2017   
5/17/2017  019 - ME: Ruling  5/17/2017   
5/4/2017  RES - Response  5/6/2017   
NOTE: Supplemental Response to State of Arizona's Motion to Dismiss 
5/4/2017  STA - Statement  5/6/2017   
NOTE: Supplemental Brief Supporting Motion to Dismiss by State of Arizona 
4/21/2017  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  4/21/2017   
4/21/2017  019 - ME: Ruling  4/21/2017   
4/17/2017  REL - Reply  4/19/2017   
NOTE: Reply Supporting Motion to Dismiss by State of Arizona 
4/12/2017  STP - Stipulation  4/13/2017   
NOTE: Stipulation re Class Allegations 
4/5/2017  RES - Response  4/6/2017   
NOTE: Response to State of Arizona's Motion to Dismiss 
3/17/2017  ANS - Answer  3/20/2017   
NOTE: ANSWER OF DEFENDANT ELECTED OFFICIALS’ RETIREMENT PLAN / CO-CHARGE R# 25812754 
3/17/2017  MTD - Motion To Dismiss  3/20/2017   
NOTE: Motion to Dismiss by State of Arizona 
3/13/2017  089 - ME: Trial Setting  3/13/2017   
3/9/2017  NAR - Notice Of Appearance  3/10/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Appearance for State of Arizona-CO CHG REC#25793906 
2/22/2017  OSC - Order To Show Cause  2/24/2017   
2/16/2017  OSC - Order To Show Cause  2/22/2017   
2/15/2017  MOT - Motion  2/17/2017   
NOTE: MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION AND REQUEST TO CONSOLIDATE TRIAL ON THE MERITS WITH PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION HEARING 
2/2/2017  SUM - Summons  2/7/2017   
2/2/2017  SUM - Summons  2/7/2017   
2/2/2017  066 - ME: Case Reassigned  2/2/2017   
2/2/2017  NOT - Notice  2/6/2017   
NOTE: NOTICE OF CLAIM OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY REGARDING LEGISLATIVE CHANGES TO A.R.S. § 38-810(C) 
2/2/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  2/8/2017   
NOTE: THE ELECTED OFFICIALS RETIREMENT PLAN 
2/2/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  2/8/2017   
NOTE: STATE OF ARIZONA 
1/31/2017  COM - Complaint  2/1/2017   
1/31/2017  CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject  2/1/2017   
1/31/2017  CSH - Coversheet  2/1/2017   
Case Calendar
Date Time Event
3/8/2017  8:30  Order To Show Cause 
3/10/2017  8:30  Order To Show Cause 
5/16/2017  9:00  Oral Argument 
7/11/2017  9:00  Trial 
Judgments
Date (F)or / (A)gainst Amount Frequency Type Status
10/24/2017  F:Kenneth Fields  $1,899.00  One Time  Costs   
  F:Gerald Porter         
  A: Elected Officials Retirement Plan, The         
  A: State Of Arizona         
10/24/2017  F:Kenneth Fields  $43,628.00  One Time  Attorney Fee   
  F:Gerald Porter         
  A: Elected Officials Retirement Plan, The         
  A: State Of Arizona         
click here for Law Library Resource Center