Civil Court Case Information - Case History

« Return to search results

Case Information

Case Number:

CV2013-011699

Judge:

Pineda, Susanna

File Date:

9/12/2013

Location:

Downtown

Case Type:

Civil

Party Information

Party Name

Relationship

Sex

Attorney

Party Name

Andy Biggs

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Andy Tobin

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Nancy Barto

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Female

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Judy Burges

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Female

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Chester Crandell

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Gail Griffin

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Female

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Al Melvin

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Kelli Ward

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Female

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Steve Yarbrough

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Kimberly Yee

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Female

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

John Allen

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Brenda Barton

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Female

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Sonny Borrelli

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Paul Boyer

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Karen Fann

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Female

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Eddie Farnsworth

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Thomas Forese

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

David Gowan

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Rick Gray

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

John Kavanagh

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Adam Kwasman

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Debbie Lesko

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Female

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

David Livingston

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Phil Lovas

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

J D Mesnard

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Unknown

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Darin Mitchell

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Steve Montenegro

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Justin Olson

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Warren Petersen

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Justin Pierce

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Carl Seel

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Steve Smith

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

David Stevens

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Bob Thorpe

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Kelly Townsend

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Female

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Michelle Ugenti

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Female

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Jeanette Dubreil

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Female

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Katie Miller

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Female

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Tom Jenney

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Christina Sandefur

Party Name

Thomas J Betlach

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

Male

Attorney

DOUGLAS NORTHUP

Party Name

Kory Langhoffer

Relationship

Endorsement Case

Sex

Male

Attorney

Kory Langhofer

Party Name

Edmundo Macias

Relationship

Intervenor

Sex

Male

Attorney

Ellen Katz

Party Name

Gary Gorham

Relationship

Intervenor

Sex

Male

Attorney

Ellen Katz

Party Name

Daniel McCormick

Relationship

Intervenor

Sex

Male

Attorney

Ellen Katz

Party Name

Tim Ferrell

Relationship

Intervenor

Sex

Male

Attorney

TIMOTHY HOGAN

Case Documents

Filing Date

Description

Docket Date

Filing Party

Filing Date

12/8/2017

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

12/11/2017

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/12/2017

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

9/13/2017

Filing Party

NOTE:

SUPREME COURT ORDER

Filing Date

5/16/2016

Description

CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt

Docket Date

5/17/2016

Filing Party

NOTE:

C2C TRANSMISSION RECEIPT

Filing Date

5/16/2016

Description

AIX - Appeals Index

Docket Date

5/17/2016

Filing Party

NOTE:

AMENDED

Filing Date

5/3/2016

Description

MEM - Memorandum

Docket Date

5/4/2016

Filing Party

Filing Date

11/18/2015

Description

RTM - Returned Mail or Returned/ReMailed Mail

Docket Date

11/19/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

11/18/2015

Description

LET - Letter

Docket Date

11/19/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

COA/NO APPELLANT FILING

Filing Date

11/12/2015

Description

CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt

Docket Date

11/13/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

C2C TRANSMISSION RECEIPT

Filing Date

11/12/2015

Description

AIX - Appeals Index

Docket Date

11/13/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

10/29/2015

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

10/29/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

NOTICE OF TRANSCRIPT ORDER FOR APPEAL

Filing Date

10/13/2015

Description

NAP - Notice Of Appeal

Docket Date

10/13/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Notice of Appeal/eFile Billing $92.00

Filing Date

10/2/2015

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

10/2/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Notice of Change of Address and Law Firm

Filing Date

9/22/2015

Description

049 - ME: Judgment Signed

Docket Date

9/22/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/15/2015

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

9/15/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

INTERVENOR-DEFENDANTS’ WITHDRAWAL OF THEIR REQUEST FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES

Filing Date

9/4/2015

Description

023 - ME: Order Entered By Court

Docket Date

9/4/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/3/2015

Description

028 - ME: Status Conference Set

Docket Date

9/3/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

8/31/2015

Description

020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement

Docket Date

8/31/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

8/27/2015

Description

926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling

Docket Date

8/27/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

7/23/2015

Description

095 - ME: Oral Argument Reset

Docket Date

7/23/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

7/22/2015

Description

066 - ME: Case Reassigned

Docket Date

7/22/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

7/20/2015

Description

REQ - Request

Docket Date

7/20/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Request for Court Reporter

Filing Date

6/19/2015

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

6/19/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Plaintiffs' Reply in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment

Filing Date

6/19/2015

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

6/19/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

PLAINTIFFS’ CONTROVERTING STATEMENT OF FACTS IN RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT’S SEPARATE STATEMENT OF FACTS IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

6/19/2015

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

6/19/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Reply in Support of Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment

Filing Date

6/19/2015

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

6/19/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs' Supplemental Statement of Facts

Filing Date

6/19/2015

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

6/19/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Intervenor-Defendants' Response to Plaintiffs' Supplemental Statement of Facts

Filing Date

6/19/2015

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

6/19/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

INTERVENOR-DEFENDANTS’ REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

6/8/2015

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

6/8/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Plaintiffs' Response to Brief of Amici Curiae

Filing Date

6/5/2015

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

6/5/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

INTERVENOR-DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

6/5/2015

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

6/5/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Intervenor-Defendants' Response to Plaintiffs' Statement of Facts

Filing Date

6/5/2015

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

6/5/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment

Filing Date

6/5/2015

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

6/5/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendant's Response to Plaintiffs' Statement and Defendant's Separate Statement of Facts in Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment

Filing Date

6/5/2015

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

6/8/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

PLAINTIFFS’ COMBINED RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT’S AND INTERVENORS’ MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

6/5/2015

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

6/8/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

PLAINTIFFS’ CONTROVERTING STATEMENT OF FACTS IN RESPONSE TO INTERVENORS’ STATEMENT OF FACTS, AND PLAINTIFFS’ SUPPLEMENTAL STATEMENT OF FACTS

Filing Date

6/5/2015

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

6/8/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

PLAINTIFFS’ CONTROVERTING STATEMENT OF FACTS IN RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT’S STATEMENT OF FACTS, AND PLAINTIFFS’ SUPPLEMENTAL STATEMENT OF FACTS

Filing Date

5/22/2015

Description

STA - Statement

Docket Date

5/27/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Brief of Amici Curiae health Care Providers Concerning the Cross-Motions for Summary Judgment

Filing Date

5/21/2015

Description

019 - ME: Ruling

Docket Date

5/21/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

5/19/2015

Description

095 - ME: Oral Argument Reset

Docket Date

5/19/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

5/15/2015

Description

MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment

Docket Date

5/18/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendant's Motion for Summary Judgment

Filing Date

5/15/2015

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

5/18/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendant's Statement of Facts

Filing Date

5/15/2015

Description

MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment

Docket Date

5/18/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Intervenor-Defendants' Motion for Summary Judgment AND MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT

Filing Date

5/15/2015

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

5/18/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Unopposed Motion for Leave to File Brief of Amici Curiae Concerning the Parties' Cross-Motions for Summary Judgment

Filing Date

5/14/2015

Description

MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment

Docket Date

5/15/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment

Filing Date

5/6/2015

Description

ANS - Answer

Docket Date

5/7/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

ANSWER OF INTERVENOR-DEFENDANTS

Filing Date

5/4/2015

Description

019 - ME: Ruling

Docket Date

5/4/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

4/30/2015

Description

ANS - Answer

Docket Date

5/1/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

PROPOSED ANSWER OF INTERVENOR-DEFENDANTS

Filing Date

4/30/2015

Description

ANS - Answer

Docket Date

5/1/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendant's Answer

Filing Date

4/24/2015

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

4/24/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Reply to Plaintiffs' Response to Motion to Intervene

Filing Date

4/21/2015

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

4/22/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Plaintiffs' Response to Motion to Intervene

Filing Date

4/21/2015

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

4/22/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Reply to Defendant Betlach's Response to Motion to Intervene

Filing Date

4/9/2015

Description

CME - Credit Memo

Docket Date

4/10/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Credit Memo

Filing Date

4/9/2015

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

4/15/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendant's Response to Motion to Intervene

Filing Date

4/7/2015

Description

MTI – Motion to Intervene

Docket Date

4/8/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

MOTION TO INTERVENE AS DEFENDANTS AND MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT

Filing Date

3/4/2015

Description

094 - ME: Oral Argument Set

Docket Date

3/4/2015

Filing Party

Filing Date

3/2/2015

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

3/6/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

THE PARTIES WILL FILE SIMULTANEOUS MOTIONS UNDER ARIZ R CIV P 56 ON THE SUPERMAJORITY VOTE ISSUE ON MAY 15 2015

Filing Date

2/23/2015

Description

STP - Stipulation

Docket Date

2/23/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Stipulation

Filing Date

2/2/2015

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

2/2/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

ORDER GRANTING EXTENSION OF TIME TO ANSWER COMPLAINT

Filing Date

1/29/2015

Description

STP - Stipulation

Docket Date

1/29/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

Stipulation for Extension of Time to Answer Complaint

Filing Date

1/26/2015

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

1/30/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

SUPREME COURT OF THE STATE OF ARIZONA OPINION

Filing Date

1/26/2015

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

1/30/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

MANDATE REMANDING TO THE SUPERIOR COURT

Filing Date

1/22/2015

Description

MAN - Order Of Mandate

Docket Date

1/22/2015

Filing Party

NOTE:

FROM SUPREME COURT OF ARIZONA

Filing Date

6/3/2014

Description

ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal

Docket Date

6/9/2014

Filing Party

Filing Date

6/3/2014

Description

CAO - Court Of Appeals Order

Docket Date

6/9/2014

Filing Party

NOTE:

DISMISSING THIS APPEAL

Filing Date

4/24/2014

Description

CAO - Court Of Appeals Order

Docket Date

4/25/2014

Filing Party

NOTE:

DISMISSING APPEAL

Filing Date

4/8/2014

Description

LET - Letter

Docket Date

4/15/2014

Filing Party

Filing Date

4/1/2014

Description

AIX - Appeals Index

Docket Date

4/7/2014

Filing Party

Filing Date

4/1/2014

Description

CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt

Docket Date

4/7/2014

Filing Party

NOTE:

C2C TRANSMISSION RECEIPT/ACCEPT

Filing Date

2/20/2014

Description

CAS - Civil Appeals Docketing Statement

Docket Date

2/20/2014

Filing Party

NOTE:

Civil Appeal Docketing Statement

Filing Date

2/18/2014

Description

NDC - Notice Of Deposit With Court

Docket Date

2/21/2014

Filing Party

NOTE:

$500.00/DEPOSIT FOR ANDY BIGGS ET AL/APPEAL BOND/COST BOND

Filing Date

2/11/2014

Description

NAP - Notice Of Appeal

Docket Date

2/11/2014

Filing Party

NOTE:

Notice of Appeal / E-FILE BILLING $619

Filing Date

2/10/2014

Description

926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling

Docket Date

2/10/2014

Filing Party

Filing Date

1/15/2014

Description

339 - ME: 100 Day Notice

Docket Date

1/15/2014

Filing Party

Filing Date

12/18/2013

Description

020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement

Docket Date

12/18/2013

Filing Party

Filing Date

12/9/2013

Description

REQ - Request

Docket Date

12/9/2013

Filing Party

NOTE:

Request for Court Reporter

Filing Date

11/15/2013

Description

095 - ME: Oral Argument Reset

Docket Date

11/15/2013

Filing Party

Filing Date

11/13/2013

Description

094 - ME: Oral Argument Set

Docket Date

11/13/2013

Filing Party

Filing Date

10/28/2013

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

10/28/2013

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendants' Reply in Support of Their Motion to Dismiss

Filing Date

10/22/2013

Description

STA - Statement

Docket Date

10/22/2013

Filing Party

NOTE:

Brief of Amici Curiae Concerning the Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

Filing Date

10/16/2013

Description

023 - ME: Order Entered By Court

Docket Date

10/16/2013

Filing Party

Filing Date

10/16/2013

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

10/17/2013

Filing Party

NOTE:

Plaintiffs' Response to Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

Filing Date

10/8/2013

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

10/9/2013

Filing Party

NOTE:

Unopposed Motion for Leave to File Brief of Amici Curiae Concerning the Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

Filing Date

10/2/2013

Description

MTD - Motion To Dismiss

Docket Date

10/2/2013

Filing Party

NOTE:

Defendants' Motion to Dismiss

Filing Date

10/2/2013

Description

CAN - Credit Memo Appearance Fee Paid

Docket Date

10/2/2013

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/17/2013

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

9/19/2013

Filing Party

NOTE:

THOMAS J BETLACH

Filing Date

9/17/2013

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

9/19/2013

Filing Party

NOTE:

JANICE K BREWER

Filing Date

9/17/2013

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

9/19/2013

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/17/2013

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

9/19/2013

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/12/2013

Description

COM - Complaint

Docket Date

9/13/2013

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/12/2013

Description

CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject

Docket Date

9/13/2013

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/12/2013

Description

CSH - Coversheet

Docket Date

9/13/2013

Filing Party

Case Calendar

Date

Time

Event

Date

12/9/2013

Time