« Return to search results Civil Court Case Information - Case History
Case Information
Case Number: CV2011-021234 Judge: Thomason, Timothy
File Date: 11/30/2011 Location: Downtown
Case Type: Civil  
Party Information
Party Name Relationship Sex Attorney
Philip Hall   Plaintiff  Male  Ron Kilgard 
Jon W Thompson   Plaintiff  Male  Ron Kilgard 
Elected Officials Retirement Plan, The   Defendant    BENNETT COOPER 
Brian Tobin   Defendant  Male  BENNETT COOPER 
Richard J Petrenka   Defendant  Male  BENNETT COOPER 
Gregory Ferguson   Defendant  Male  BENNETT COOPER 
Lauren Kingry   Defendant  Female  BENNETT COOPER 
Jeff Allen McHenry   Defendant  Male  BENNETT COOPER 
Randie A Stein   Defendant  Unknown  BENNETT COOPER 
Arizona Attorney Generals Office   Defendant    Pro Per 
Speaker Of The Arizona House Of Representatives, The   Defendant    Pro Per 
State Of Arizona   Intervenor    Charles Grube 
Case Documents
Filing Date Description Docket Date Filing Party
6/28/2017  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  6/28/2017   
6/28/2017  JUD - Judgment  7/3/2017   
NOTE: Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties 
6/22/2017  NOT - Notice  6/23/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Lodging Stipulated Form of Judgment on Remand 
6/14/2017  NOT - Notice  6/16/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Lodging Form of Judgment on Remand 
6/9/2017  926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling  6/9/2017   
6/8/2017  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  6/8/2017   
6/1/2017  REL - Reply  6/5/2017   
NOTE: Reply to Responses to Motion for Entry of Judgment on Remand 
6/1/2017  REL - Reply  6/5/2017   
NOTE: Reply to Responses to Motion for Award of Prejudgment Interest 
6/1/2017  REL - Reply  6/5/2017   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Reply to Responses to Motion for Award of Attorney Fees 
5/10/2017  NOT - Notice  5/11/2017   
NOTE: Notice of First Extension of Time for Plaintiffs to File Replies to Defendants’ Responses to Plaintiffs’ Motions for: ? Entry of Judgment ? Prejudgment Interest ? Attorney Fees 
5/8/2017  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  5/9/2017   
NOTE: Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Entry of Judgment by State of Arizona 
5/8/2017  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  5/10/2017   
NOTE: OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ATTORNEYS’ FEES BY STATE OF ARIZONA 
5/8/2017  RES - Response  5/10/2017   
NOTE: EORP DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ON REMAND 
5/8/2017  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  5/10/2017   
NOTE: Opposition to Plaintiffs' Motion for Prejudgment Interest by State of Arizona 
5/8/2017  RES - Response  5/10/2017   
NOTE: EORP Defendants' Response to Plaintiffs' Motion for Award of Attorney Fees 
5/8/2017  RES - Response  5/10/2017   
NOTE: EORP DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR AWARD OF PREJUDGMENT INTEREST 
5/5/2017  NOT - Notice  5/9/2017   
NOTE: NOTICE OF THIRD EXTENSION OF TIME FOR DEFENDANTS TO FILE RESPONSES TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ON REMAND, PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR AWARD OF PREJUDGMENT INTEREST, AND PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR AWARD OF ATTORNEY FEES 
5/1/2017  NOT - Notice  5/3/2017   
NOTE: NOTICE OF SECOND EXTENSION OF TIME FOR DEFENDANTS TO FILE RESPONSES TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT ON REMAND, PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR AWARD OF PREJUDGMENT INTEREST, AND PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR AWARD OF ATTORNEY FEES 
4/24/2017  NOT - Notice  4/25/2017   
NOTE: Notice of First Extension of Time for Defendants to File Responses to Plaintiffs' Motion for Entry of Judgment on Remand, Plaintiffs' Motion for Award of Prejudgment Interest, and Plaintiffs' Motion for Award of Attorney Fees 
4/11/2017  066 - ME: Case Reassigned  4/11/2017   
4/11/2017  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  4/11/2017   
4/4/2017  MOT - Motion  4/5/2017   
NOTE: Motion for Entry of Judgment on Remand 
4/4/2017  MOT - Motion  4/6/2017   
NOTE: Motion for Award of Prejudgment Interest 
4/4/2017  MOT - Motion  4/6/2017   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Motion for Award of Attorney Fees 
3/30/2017  001 - ME: Disqualification  3/30/2017   
3/30/2017  NOT - Notice  3/31/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Related Case 
3/27/2017  MAN - Order Of Mandate  3/28/2017   
3/27/2017  LET - Letter  3/28/2017   
3/24/2017  MAN - Order Of Mandate  3/27/2017   
3/24/2017  LET - Letter  3/27/2017   
6/12/2015  ORD - Order  6/12/2015   
NOTE: FROM AZ SUPREME CT 
3/27/2015  LET - Letter  3/27/2015   
NOTE: FROM COA: APPELLANT'S FILING FEE DUE 
3/19/2015  NOT - Notice  3/19/2015   
NOTE: Notice of Transcript Order and Designation of Transcripts 
3/19/2015  CAO - Court Of Appeals Order  3/19/2015   
NOTE: AMENDED ORDER RE: REINSTATEMENT OF APPEAL (BACK TO DIV 1) 
3/19/2015  CAO - Court Of Appeals Order  3/19/2015   
NOTE: FROM COA, DIV 2: RETURNING CASE TO DIV 1 
3/16/2015  ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal  3/17/2015   
NOTE: FROM COA DIV 1: TRANSFERRING CASE TO COA, DIV 2 
3/16/2015  CAO - Court Of Appeals Order  3/17/2015   
NOTE: ORDER: TRANSFERRING CASE FROM COA DIV 1 TO COA DIV 2 
3/13/2015  CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt  3/13/2015   
NOTE: C2C TRANSMISSION RECEIPT 
3/13/2015  AIX - Appeals Index  3/13/2015   
2/25/2015  NAP - Notice Of Appeal  2/26/2015   
NOTE: State of Arizona's Notice of Appeal 
2/23/2015  NAP - Notice Of Appeal  2/24/2015   
NOTE: Notice of Appeal/Efile billing $92.00 
2/23/2015  NAP - Notice Of Appeal  2/24/2015   
NOTE: Notice of Cross-Appeal 
2/6/2015  NAP - Notice Of Appeal  2/9/2015   
NOTE: EORP Defendants' Notice of Appeal 
1/29/2015  049 - ME: Judgment Signed  1/29/2015   
1/27/2015  JUD - Judgment  1/29/2015   
NOTE: Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties 
1/27/2015  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  1/27/2015   
12/24/2014  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  12/24/2014   
12/22/2014  REL - Reply  12/22/2014   
NOTE: Reply to Responses to Motion for Entry of Judgment 
12/11/2014  ORD - Order  12/11/2014   
NOTE: ORDER ON STIPULATION TO EXTEND TIME FOR PLAINTIFFS TO REPLY TO THE RESPONSES TO THE MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT 
12/9/2014  STP - Stipulation  12/10/2014   
NOTE: Stipulation to Extend Time for Plaintiffs to Reply to the Responses to the Motion for Entry of Judgment 
12/2/2014  RES - Response  12/3/2014   
NOTE: STATE OF ARIZONA’S RESPONSE OPPOSING PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT 
12/2/2014  RES - Response  12/3/2014   
NOTE: EORP Defendants' Response to Plaintiffs' Motion for Entry of Judgment 
11/26/2014  ORD - Order  11/26/2014   
NOTE: Order ON STIPULATION TO EXTEND TIME FOR DEFENDANTS TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT 
11/24/2014  STP - Stipulation  11/24/2014   
NOTE: STIPULATION TO EXTEND TIME FOR DEFENDANTS TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT 
11/17/2014  STP - Stipulation  11/18/2014   
NOTE: STIPULATION TO EXTEND TIME FOR DEFENDANTS TO RESPOND TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT 
11/3/2014  MOT - Motion  11/4/2014   
NOTE: Motion for Entry of Judgment 
10/6/2014  005 - ME: Hearing  10/6/2014   
10/1/2014  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  10/1/2014   
9/19/2014  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  9/19/2014   
9/18/2014  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  9/18/2014   
8/26/2014  028 - ME: Status Conference Set  8/26/2014   
6/30/2014  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  6/30/2014   
6/9/2014  REL - Reply  6/9/2014   
NOTE: Reply to Response to Motion for Reconsideration in Light of Recent Court of Appeals Decision 
6/2/2014  RES - Response  6/3/2014   
NOTE: EORP DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION IN LIGHT OF RECENT COURT OF APPEALS DECISION 
6/2/2014  RES - Response  6/3/2014   
NOTE: State of Arizona's Response Opposing Plaintiffs' Motion for Reconsideration Re Eligibility for Attorney Fees 
5/30/2014  088 - ME: Case Transferred  5/30/2014   
5/22/2014  NOT - Notice  5/22/2014   
NOTE: NOTICE OF FIRST EXTENSION OF TIME TO FILE RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION IN LIGHT OF RECENT COURT OF APPEALS DECISION 
5/12/2014  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  5/12/2014   
5/6/2014  MFR - Motion For Reconsideration  5/6/2014   
NOTE: Motion for Reconsideration in Light of Recent Court of Appeals Decision 
4/15/2014  926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling  4/15/2014   
4/10/2014  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  4/10/2014   
3/31/2014  REL - Reply  3/31/2014   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Reply in Support of Their Motion re Eligibility for Attorney Fees Under A.R.S. Sec. 12-341.01(A) 
3/28/2014  ORD - Order  3/28/2014   
NOTE: Order re Time for Plaintiffs and Proposed Class to File Reply re Motion re Eligibility for Attorney Fees Under A.R.S. § 12-341.01(A) 
3/25/2014  STP - Stipulation  3/25/2014   
NOTE: Stipulation to Amend Time for Plaintiffs and Proposed Class to File Reply re Motion re Eligibility for Attorney Fees Under A.R.S. § 12-341.01(A) 
3/24/2014  RES - Response  3/25/2014   
NOTE: State of Arizona's Response Opposing Plaintiff's Motion Re Eligibility for Attorney Fees 
3/24/2014  RES - Response  3/25/2014   
NOTE: EORP Defendants' Response to Plaintiffs' Motion re Eligibility for Attorney Fees Under A.R.S. 12-341.01(A) 
3/17/2014  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  3/17/2014   
3/12/2014  MOT - Motion  3/12/2014   
NOTE: Motion re Eligibility for Attorney Fees Under A.R.S. Sec. 12-341.01(A) 
3/5/2014  NOT - Notice  3/5/2014   
NOTE: Proposed Agenda for Telephonic Status Conference: Friday March 7, 2014 10:00 a.m. 
3/3/2014  028 - ME: Status Conference Set  3/3/2014   
2/25/2014  NOT - Notice  2/25/2014   
NOTE: Notification of Decision in Fields -and- Request for Telephonic Status Conference 
8/29/2013  928 – ME: Stay of Proceedings  8/29/2013   
8/21/2013  ORD - Order  8/26/2013   
NOTE: STAYING THIS ACTION PENDING DECISION OF ARIZONA SUPREME COURT 
8/14/2013  MOT - Motion  8/14/2013   
NOTE: Unopposed Motion for Stay Pending Decision of Arizona Supreme Court 
7/30/2013  926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling  7/30/2013   
7/17/2013  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  7/17/2013   
7/5/2013  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  7/5/2013   
5/29/2013  ORD - Order  5/29/2013   
NOTE: Order Amending Scheduling Order for Motions for Reconsideration 
5/28/2013  REL - Reply  5/28/2013   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Reply to the State's and the Plan's Responses to the Motions for Reconsideration 
5/21/2013  MOT - Motion  5/22/2013   
NOTE: Stipulated Motion to Amend Scheduling Order for Motions for Reconsideration 
5/16/2013  022 - ME: Order Signed  5/16/2013   
5/14/2013  ORD - Order  5/20/2013   
NOTE: MODIFYING SCHEDULING ORDER RE OTIONS FOR RECONSIDERATION 
5/10/2013  RES - Response  5/13/2013   
NOTE: State of Arizona's Response Opposing Plaintiffs' Motions for Reconsideration 
5/10/2013  RES - Response  5/13/2013   
NOTE: EORP Defendants' Response to Plaintiff's Motion for Reconsideration re Validity of 2000 EORP Vesting Statute & Motion for Reconsideration on Effect of Judicial Salary Clause on Increased Contribution Rate 
5/3/2013  MTA - Motion To Amend  5/6/2013   
NOTE: Stipulated Motion to Amend Scheduling Order for Motions for Reconsideration 
4/19/2013  MFR - Motion For Reconsideration  4/19/2013   
NOTE: Motion for Reconsideration re Validity of 2000 EORP Vesting Statute 
4/12/2013  022 - ME: Order Signed  4/12/2013   
4/4/2013  ORD - Order  4/5/2013   
NOTE: SCHEDULING/RE MOTIONS FOR RECONDISDERATION 
4/2/2013  MOT - Motion  4/3/2013   
NOTE: Motion for Scheduling Order re Motions for Reconsideration and Motion to Expedite 
3/29/2013  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  3/29/2013   
3/25/2013  MFR - Motion For Reconsideration  3/25/2013   
NOTE: Motion for Reconsideration on Effect of Judicial Salary Clause on Increased Contribution Rate 
3/21/2013  926 - ME: Under Advisement Ruling  3/21/2013   
2/19/2013  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  2/19/2013   
2/11/2013  NOF - Notice Of Filing  2/12/2013   
NOTE: Notice of Filing Exhibits to Joint Statement of Facts 
2/11/2013  NOF - Notice Of Filing  2/12/2013   
NOTE: Notice of Filing Exhibits to Joint Statement of Facts 
2/7/2013  REL - Reply  2/8/2013   
NOTE: EORP DEFENDANTS’ REPLY IN SUPPORT OF THEIR CROSS-MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 
2/7/2013  REL - Reply  2/8/2013   
NOTE: State's Joinder in Reply Brief 
1/23/2013  022 - ME: Order Signed  1/23/2013   
1/18/2013  ORD - Order  1/25/2013   
NOTE: EXPANDING PAGE LIMITS 
12/31/2012  RES - Response  1/2/2013   
NOTE: PLAINTIFFS’ RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS’ CROSS-MOTIONS FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT -AND- REPLY TO DEFENDANTS’ RESPONSES TO PLAINTIFFS’ MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 
12/31/2012  MOT - Motion  1/2/2013   
NOTE: Motion to Expand Page Limits 
11/15/2012  ORD - Order  11/15/2012   
NOTE: Order re Schedule 
11/13/2012  STP - Stipulation  11/13/2012   
NOTE: Stipulation re Schedule 
11/8/2012  RES - Response  11/8/2012   
NOTE: EORP Defendants' Response to Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment and Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment 
11/8/2012  NOT - Notice  11/8/2012   
NOTE: Notice of Errata re EORP Defendants' Response to Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment and Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment 
11/7/2012  RES - Response  11/8/2012   
NOTE: State of Arizona's Response Opposing Plaintiff's Motion for Summary Judgment And Cross-Motion for Summary Judgment 
11/7/2012  SOF - Statement Of Facts  11/8/2012   
NOTE: EORP Defendants' Separate Statement of Facts in Support of Their Response to Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment and Cross-Moton for Summary Judgment 
9/21/2012  MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment  9/21/2012   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Motion for Summary Judgment 
9/21/2012  NOT - Notice  9/21/2012   
NOTE: Notice re Intervention of State of Arizona 
9/17/2012  CAN - Credit Memo Appearance Fee Paid  9/17/2012   
9/14/2012  NAR - Notice Of Appearance  9/17/2012   
NOTE: Notice of Appearance / Co-Chg Rcpt # 22456420 
9/14/2012  SOF - Statement Of Facts  9/17/2012   
NOTE: Joint Statement of Facts 
8/17/2012  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  8/17/2012   
8/15/2012  ORD - Order  8/23/2012   
NOTE: RE BRIEFING PROCEDURE AND SCHEDULE 
8/14/2012  029 - ME: Status Conference  8/14/2012   
8/10/2012  STP - Stipulation  8/10/2012   
NOTE: Stipulation re Briefing Procedure 
8/7/2012  REQ - Request  8/7/2012   
NOTE: Plaintiffs' Request for Immediate Telephonic Status Conference 
7/23/2012  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  7/23/2012   
7/17/2012  STP - Stipulation  7/18/2012   
NOTE: Stipulation re Briefing Schedule 
6/21/2012  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  6/21/2012   
5/29/2012  STP - Stipulation  5/29/2012   
NOTE: Stipulation re Status Conference 
5/2/2012  311 - ME: 150 Day Minute Entry  5/2/2012   
3/29/2012  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  3/29/2012   
3/15/2012  STP - Stipulation  3/15/2012   
NOTE: Stipulation to Transfer 
2/3/2012  ANS - Answer  2/6/2012   
NOTE: Answer to Verified Complaint / CO CHG Receipt #21935107 
1/12/2012  WSS - Waiver Of Service Of Summons  1/13/2012   
NOTE: Notice of Waiver of Issuance and Service of Process 
12/5/2011  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/14/2011   
NOTE: AZ ATTORNEY GENERALS OFFICE 12/01/2011 
12/5/2011  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/14/2011   
12/5/2011  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  12/14/2011   
NOTE: THE SPEAKER OF THE ARIZONA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES SERVED 12/1/11 
12/1/2011  NOT - Notice  12/1/2011   
NOTE: Notice of Claim of Unconstitutionality 
11/30/2011  COM - Complaint  12/1/2011   
11/30/2011  CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject  12/1/2011   
Case Calendar
Date Time Event
6/15/2012  11:00  Status Conference 
8/9/2012  8:30  Status Conference 
11/19/2012  14:00  Oral Argument 
12/17/2012  14:00  Oral Argument 
2/11/2013  15:00  Oral Argument 
7/12/2013  15:30  Oral Argument 
3/7/2014  10:00  Status Conference 
4/4/2014  14:30  Oral Argument 
8/22/2014  8:30  Oral Argument 
9/26/2014  8:45  Status Conference 
9/29/2014  8:30  Status Conference 
10/3/2014  14:00  Oral Argument 
10/30/2014  9:30  Status Conference 
1/23/2015  8:30  Oral Argument 
6/6/2017  14:00  Oral Argument 
Judgments
Date (F)or / (A)gainst Amount Frequency Type Status
6/28/2017  F:Philip Hall  $200,759.12  One Time  Attorney Fee   
  F:Jon W Thompson         
  A: Elected Officials Retirement Plan, The         
  A: State Of Arizona         
1/27/2015  A:     One Time  Judgment Only   
click here for Law Library Resource Center