Civil Court Case Information - Case History


« Return to search results
Case Information
Case Number: CV2007-004793 Judge: Hannah, John
File Date: 3/16/2007 Location: Downtown
Case Type: Civil  
Party Information
Party Name Relationship Sex Attorney
City Of Phoenix   Plaintiff    Charles Ayers 
Elizabeth O Garretson   Defendant  Female  Pro Per 
John E Garretson   Defendant  Male  Dale Zeitlin 
Maricopa County   Defendant    Steven Palmer 
Maricopa County Creditor   In The Matter Of (IMO)    Pro Per 
Case Documents
Filing Date Description Docket Date Filing Party
6/15/2018  019 - ME: Ruling  6/15/2018   
5/22/2018  REL - Reply  5/24/2018   
NOTE: City's Reply Re Summation 
5/18/2018  RES - Response  5/22/2018   
NOTE: RESPONSE TO CITY’S REPORT AND SUMMATION 
5/11/2018  REP - Report  5/14/2018   
NOTE: City's Report and Summation 
12/22/2017  ORD - Order  12/22/2017   
NOTE: ORDER RE: POST-TRIAL DISCOVERY 
12/8/2017  REL - Reply  12/8/2017   
NOTE: CITY’S REPLY RE: MOTION TO COMPEL DISCOVERY 
12/1/2017  019 - ME: Ruling  12/1/2017   
11/28/2017  RQH - Request For Hearing  11/29/2017   
NOTE: Response to City's Motion to Compel Discovery and Request for Expedited Hearing 
11/17/2017  MTC - Motion To Compel  11/17/2017   
NOTE: City's Motion to Compel Discovery and Request for Expedited Ruling 
9/29/2017  JSR – Joint Scheduling Report  9/29/2017   
NOTE: Joint Status Report Re: Post-Judgment Discovery 
9/21/2017  019 - ME: Ruling  9/21/2017   
9/20/2017  RES - Response  9/21/2017   
NOTE: City's Response to Motion to Strike 
9/15/2017  MOT - Motion  9/18/2017   
NOTE: Motion to Strike City's Motion to Compel Discovery and Request for Expedited Ruling 
9/13/2017  MTC - Motion To Compel  9/15/2017   
NOTE: City's Motion to Compel Discovery and Request for Expedited Ruling 
8/4/2017  019 - ME: Ruling  8/4/2017   
7/20/2017  RES - Response  7/24/2017   
NOTE: Response to City's Supplemental Memorandum 
7/18/2017  MEM - Memorandum  7/19/2017   
NOTE: City's Supplemental Memorandum and Request for Oral Argument 
7/11/2017  NOF - Notice Of Filing  7/12/2017   
NOTE: Notice of Filing Declaration of Riley Schwenn 
6/28/2017  REL - Reply  6/29/2017   
NOTE: City's Reply to Defendant Garretson's Response to Motion for Relief From Final Judgment 
6/16/2017  RES - Response  6/19/2017   
NOTE: RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR RELIEF FROM FINAL JUDGMENT 
6/6/2017  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  6/7/2017   
5/26/2017  MOT - Motion  5/30/2017   
NOTE: Motion for Relief From Final Judgment 
3/13/2017  SJU - Satisfaction Of Judgment  3/14/2017   
NOTE: Satisfaction of Judgment 
1/3/2017  OVJ - Order Vacating Judgment  1/6/2017   
NOTE: FOR JURY FEES 
12/9/2016  ORD - Order  12/9/2016   
NOTE: IT IS HEREBY ORDERED vacating the Judgment for Jury Fees entered on or about October 26, 2016. 
12/1/2016  STJ - Stipulated Judgment  12/1/2016   
NOTE: STIPULATED JUDGMENT 
12/1/2016  MSA - Motion To Set Aside Judgment  12/2/2016   
NOTE: Motion to Set Aside Judgment for Jury Fees 
11/14/2016  NOT - Notice  11/15/2016   
NOTE: NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF PROPOSED JUDGMENT 
11/3/2016  EXW - Exhibits Work Sheet  11/7/2016   
11/2/2016  NOT - Notice  11/3/2016   
NOTE: Notice of Lodging Judgment 
11/2/2016  SOC - Statement Of Costs  11/3/2016   
NOTE: defendants Statement of Costs 
10/28/2016  012 - ME: Trial  10/28/2016   
10/27/2016  012 - ME: Trial  10/27/2016   
10/26/2016  VER - Verdict  11/2/2016   
10/26/2016  VER - Verdict  11/2/2016   
10/26/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
NOTE: RESPONSE TO / 
10/26/2016  JUL - Jury List - Restricted if Filed after 1/1/2008  11/10/2016   
10/26/2016  JUL - Jury List - Restricted if Filed after 1/1/2008  11/10/2016   
10/26/2016  JJF - Judgment For Jury Fees  11/14/2016   
NOTE: Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties 
10/26/2016  012 - ME: Trial  10/26/2016   
10/26/2016  012 - ME: Trial  10/26/2016   
10/26/2016  012 - ME: Trial  10/26/2016   
10/26/2016  012 - ME: Trial  10/26/2016   
10/26/2016  WSH - Worksheet  11/2/2016   
NOTE: TRIAL/HEARING / 
10/25/2016  JIN - Jury Instructions  11/2/2016   
NOTE: FINAL / 
10/25/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/25/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/25/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/24/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/24/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/24/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/24/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/24/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/24/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/24/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/24/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/24/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/24/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/24/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/21/2016  REQ - Request  10/24/2016   
NOTE: Request for Jury Instruction RE:TCE 
10/20/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/20/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/20/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/20/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/19/2016  012 - ME: Trial  10/19/2016   
10/18/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/18/2016  JQU - Jury Question  11/2/2016   
10/17/2016  JIN - Jury Instructions  11/2/2016   
NOTE: PRELIMINARY 
10/13/2016  MEM - Memorandum  10/14/2016   
NOTE: Plaintiff's Trial Memorandum to the Court Re Motions in Limine; Exhibit 18 (Collision Report); Witness Ralston; and Additional Objections to Specific Exhibits 
10/10/2016  331 - ME: Settlement Conference  10/10/2016   
10/3/2016  070 - ME: Settlement Conference Set  10/3/2016   
9/20/2016  027 - ME: Pretrial Conference  9/20/2016   
9/15/2016  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  9/16/2016   
NOTE: Garretson's Objection to City's Supplemental Jury Instructions Re Determining Damages 
9/13/2016  PJI - Proposed Jury Instructions  9/14/2016   
NOTE: City's Proposed Supplemental Jury Instruction 
9/12/2016  NOT - Notice  9/13/2016   
NOTE: Citys Proposed Voir Dire Questions for the Court (Corrected) 
9/9/2016  PJI - Proposed Jury Instructions  9/12/2016   
NOTE: DEFENDANT’S PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND FORM OF VERDICT 
9/9/2016  NOT - Notice  9/12/2016   
NOTE: City's Proposed Voir Dire Questions 
9/9/2016  PJI - Proposed Jury Instructions  9/12/2016   
NOTE: City's Proposed RAJI and Non-RAJI Instructions and Defendant's Objections 
9/9/2016  STA - Statement  9/12/2016   
NOTE: JOINT PRETRIAL STATEMENT 
9/9/2016  NOT - Notice  9/12/2016   
NOTE: Defendant's Proposed Voir Dire 
9/2/2016  NOT - Notice  9/2/2016   
NOTE: Withdrawal of Request for Pretrial Ruling and Expedited Hearing 
9/1/2016  REQ - Request  9/2/2016   
NOTE: Request for Pretrial Ruling and Expedited Hearing 
8/16/2016  NOT - Notice  8/16/2016   
NOTE: Notice of Attorney Substitution Within the Firm 
8/3/2016  NOT - Notice  8/4/2016   
NOTE: NOTICE OF CHANGE OF FIRM ADDRESS 
7/12/2016  025 - ME: Case Status Minute Entry  7/12/2016   
3/8/2016  ORD - Order  3/8/2016   
NOTE: ORDER RE: MOTION TO PERMIT REBUTTAL EVIDENCE, TESTIMONY, EXHIBITS AND MOTIONS REGARDING DEFENDANT’S “VIDEO DEMONSTRATION”; IN THE ALTERNATIVE MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL DATE 
2/26/2016  064 - ME: Trial Continued/Reset  2/26/2016   
2/23/2016  REL - Reply  2/23/2016   
NOTE: REPLY RE: MOTION TO PERMIT REBUTTAL EVIDENCE, TESTIMONY, EXHIBITS AND MOTIONS REGARDING DEFENDANT’S “VIDEO DEMONSTRATION”; IN THE ALTERNATIVE MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL DATE 
2/23/2016  NOF - Notice Of Filing  2/23/2016   
NOTE: Notice of Filing Proposed Order Continuing Trial Date and Pretrial Deadlines 
2/19/2016  RES - Response  2/19/2016   
NOTE: Response ro Plaintiff's Motion to Permit Rebuttal Evidence, Testimony, Exhibits and Motions Regarding Defendant's "Video Demonstration"; in the Alternative Motion to Continue Trial  
2/4/2016  MOT - Motion  2/4/2016   
NOTE: MOTION TO PERMIT REBUTTAL EVIDENCE, TESTIMONY, EXHIBITS AND MOTIONS REGARDING DEFENDANT’S “VIDEO DEMONSTRATION”; IN THE ALTERNATIVE MOTION TO CONTINUE TRIAL DATE 
1/5/2016  ORD - Order  1/5/2016   
NOTE: ORDER RE: MOTION TO PERMIT GARRETSON TO PRODUCE DEMONSTRATIVE VIDEO OF ACCESS 
12/29/2015  RES - Response  12/30/2015   
NOTE: Response to Plaintiff's Supplement to Response to Motion to Permit Demonstrative Video; Request for Sanctions 
12/18/2015  RES - Response  12/18/2015   
NOTE: Supplement to Response to Motion to Permit Demonstrative Video; Request for Sanctions 
12/17/2015  REL - Reply  12/17/2015   
NOTE: Reply in Support of Motion to Permit Garretson to Produce Demonstrative Video of Access 
12/11/2015  RES - Response  12/11/2015   
NOTE: Response to Motion to Permit Demonstrative Video 
12/3/2015  089 - ME: Trial Setting  12/3/2015   
11/20/2015  MOT - Motion  11/23/2015   
NOTE: Motion to Permit Garretson to Produce Demonstrative Video of Access 
10/26/2015  PDO - Proposed Order Denied  10/26/2015   
NOTE: PROPOSED ORDER DENIED 
10/9/2015  ORD - Order  10/9/2015   
NOTE: ORDERED that the parties, their counsel and all witnesses shall refrain from discussing or referring to the appellate proceedings in this case or the decisions of either the Arizona Court of Appeals or Supreme Court in any way, either directly or indirectly. 
9/18/2015  RES - Response  9/21/2015   
NOTE: Garretson's Response to City of Phoenix's Motion in Limine: Untimely Produced Traffic Studies and Other Evidence 
9/9/2015  MIL - Motion In Limine  9/10/2015   
NOTE: City of Phoenix's Motion in Limine Re: Untimely Produced Traffic Studies and Other Evidence 
8/28/2015  MIL - Motion In Limine  8/28/2015   
NOTE: City of Phoenix's Motion in Limine Re: References to Appellate Decisions 
7/1/2015  ORD - Order  7/1/2015   
NOTE: ORDER RE: CITY OF PHOENIX’S MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF THE CITY’S ACQUISITION OF THE WOODWARD PARCEL 
6/25/2015  ORD - Order  6/25/2015   
NOTE: Order RE: City of Phoenix's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence of Defendant's "Conceptual Development Plans" 
6/19/2015  RES - Response  6/19/2015   
NOTE: Response to Motion to Strike Motion in Limine 
6/8/2015  RES - Response  6/8/2015   
NOTE: Garretsons' Response in Opposition to City of Phoenix's Motion in limine to Exclude Evidence of the City's Acquistion of the Woodward Parcel and Motion to Strike the Motion in limine for not complying with Rule 7.2 ARCP 
6/8/2015  RES - Response  6/9/2015   
NOTE: Garretsons' response in opposition to city of phoenix's motion in limine to exclude evidence of the city's acquisition of the woodward parcel and motion to strike the motion in limine for not complying with rule 7.2 arcp 
5/20/2015  MIL - Motion In Limine  5/20/2015   
NOTE: City of Phoenix's Motion in Limine to Exclude Evidence of Defendant's "Conceptual Development Plans" 
5/20/2015  MIL - Motion In Limine  5/20/2015   
NOTE: City of Phoenix's Motion in Limine To Exclude Evidence of The City's Acquisition of the Woodward Parcel 
5/12/2015  ORD - Order  5/12/2015   
NOTE: ORDER RE: MOTION TO COMPEL RE: REQUEST FOR ENTRY UPON LAND FOR INSPECTING, TESTING AND SAMPLING 
5/8/2015  ORD - Order  5/8/2015   
NOTE: ORDER RE: CITY OF PHOENIX’S MOTION IN LIMINE TO EXCLUDE CITY’S PRE-FILING OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPORTING APPRAISALS 
5/6/2015  REL - Reply  5/6/2015   
NOTE: Reply Re: Motion to Compel Re: Request for Entry Upon Land for Inspecting, Testing and Sampling 
4/29/2015  RES - Response  4/29/2015   
NOTE: Garretsons' Response in Opposition to Plaintiff's Motion to Compel Re: Request for Entry Upon Land for Inspecting and Sampling 
4/16/2015  MTC - Motion To Compel  4/17/2015   
NOTE: Motion to Compel Re: Request for Entry Upon Land for Inspecting, Testing and Sampling 
4/3/2015  RES - Response  4/6/2015   
NOTE: Garretson's Response to City's Motion in Limine to Exclude Offers to Purchase and Supporting Appraisals 
3/17/2015  MIL - Motion In Limine  3/18/2015   
NOTE: City of Phoenix's Motion in Limine to Exclude City's Pre-Filing Offers to Purchase and Supporting Appraisals 
2/27/2015  REQ - Request  3/2/2015   
NOTE: Request for Entry Upon Land for Inspecting, Testing and Sampling 
10/2/2014  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  10/2/2014   
10/1/2014  SCO – Scheduling Order  10/1/2014   
NOTE: SCHEDULING ORDER 
9/30/2014  ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal  10/2/2014   
9/30/2014  CAO - Court Of Appeals Order  10/2/2014   
NOTE: FEES 
9/11/2014  JSR – Joint Scheduling Report  9/12/2014   
NOTE: Joint Report 
8/22/2014  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  8/22/2014   
8/19/2014  028 - ME: Status Conference Set  8/19/2014   
5/7/2014  TSP - Transcript of Proceedings  5/9/2014   
NOTE: SALLY STEARMAN/AUGUST 18 2009 
5/7/2014  ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal  5/19/2014   
NOTE: SUPREME COURT 
5/7/2014  MAN - Order Of Mandate  5/19/2014   
NOTE: SUPREME COURT/APPEAL IS VACATED AND CASE IS REMANDED TO THE SUPERIOR COURT FOR FURTHER PROCEEDINGS 
11/26/2013  LET - Letter  11/27/2013   
3/31/2011  CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt  4/4/2011   
3/25/2011  LET - Letter  3/25/2011   
3/14/2011  CAO - Court Of Appeals Order  3/14/2011   
NOTE: SHALL TRANSMIT THE RECORD ON APPEAL TO CLERK OF COURT OF APPEALS BEFORE MARCH 25, 2011 
10/12/2010  MOT - Motion  10/13/2010   
NOTE: FOR EXTENSION OF TIME FOR FILING OPENING BRIEF 
10/7/2010  AIX - Appeals Index  10/8/2010   
NOTE: SUPPLEMENTAL #1 
9/27/2010  CAS - Civil Appeals Docketing Statement  9/30/2010   
9/17/2010  CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt  9/17/2010   
9/17/2010  LET - Letter  9/17/2010   
NOTE: COA/FILING FEE DUE 
9/7/2010  LET - Letter  9/7/2010   
NOTE: CERTIFICATION 
9/7/2010  AIX - Appeals Index  9/7/2010   
8/26/2010  SJU - Satisfaction Of Judgment  9/1/2010   
NOTE: AND RECEIPT 
7/30/2010  NDC - Notice Of Deposit With Court  8/6/2010   
NOTE: $500.00 FOR APPEAL BOND FOR JOHN E GARRETSON 
7/28/2010  NAP - Notice Of Appeal  7/30/2010   
7/16/2010  STJ - Stipulated Judgment  7/23/2010   
NOTE: Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties 
7/9/2010  STP - Stipulation  7/15/2010   
NOTE: TO AMEND CAPTION AND TO ENTRY OF FINAL JUDGMENT AND REQUEST TO VACATE TRIAL SETTING CONFERENCE 
5/3/2010  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  5/3/2010   
4/29/2010  ORD - Order  5/6/2010   
NOTE: CONTINUING PRETRIAL DEADLINES 
4/14/2010  STP - Stipulation  4/16/2010   
NOTE: FOR ENTRY OF ORDER CONTINUING PRETRIAL DEADLINES 
3/29/2010  019 - ME: Ruling  3/29/2010   
3/3/2010  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  3/3/2010   
3/2/2010  ORD - Order  3/9/2010   
NOTE: TO EXTEND DISCOVERY DEADLINES 
2/25/2010  STP - Stipulation  2/25/2010   
NOTE: to Extend Discovery Deadlines 
1/12/2010  028 - ME: Status Conference Set  1/12/2010   
1/11/2010  ORD - Order  1/14/2010   
NOTE: CONTINUING PRETRIAL DEADLINES 
1/7/2010  STP - Stipulation  1/12/2010   
NOTE: TO VACATE ORAL ARGUMENT ON REMAINING PENDING MOTIONS AND FORENTRY OF ORDER CONTINUING PRETRIAL DEADLINES 
1/6/2010  019 - ME: Ruling  1/6/2010   
12/11/2009  REL - Reply  12/16/2009   
NOTE: CITY'S IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION TO STRIKE DEFENDANTS NOTICE OF FILING PHOTOGRAPHS SHOWING ACCESS TO SUBJECT PROPERTY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION RE ACCESS 
12/8/2009  RES - Response  12/11/2009   
NOTE: GARRESTON'S TO THE CITY'S MOTION TO STRIKE DEFENDANTS' NOTICE OF FILING PHOTOGRAPHS SHOWING ACCESS TO SUBJECT PROPERTY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION RE ACCESS 
12/4/2009  NOF - Notice Of Filing  12/9/2009   
NOTE: ORIGINAL AFFIDAVIT OF SHEILA RALSTON IN SUPPORT OF CITY'S MOTION TO STRIKE DEFENDANTS' NOTICE OF FILING PHOTOGRAPHS SHOWING ACCESS TO SUBJECT PROPERTY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION RE ACCESS 
12/2/2009  MOT - Motion  12/7/2009   
NOTE: CITY'S TO STRIKE DEFENDANTS' NOTICE OF FILING PHOTOGRAPHS SHOWING ACCESS TO SUBJECT PROPERTY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR RECONSIDEARTION RE ACCESS 
11/27/2009  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  11/27/2009   
11/25/2009  NOF - Notice Of Filing  12/1/2009   
NOTE: PHOTOGRAPHS SHOWING ACCESS TO SUBJECT PROPERTY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION RE ACCESS 
11/23/2009  REQ - Request  11/30/2009   
NOTE: CITY'S FOR ENTRY OF ORDER CONTINUING PRETRIAL DEADLINES 
11/2/2009  RES - Response  11/6/2009   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS' OPPOSITION TO CITY'S STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT REGARDING DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT 
11/2/2009  RES - Response  11/6/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S TO DEFENDANTS' OPPOSITION TO CITY'S STATEMENT OF ITS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON LEGAL INADMISSABILTY OF CITY'S PRE FILING OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPORTING APPRAISALS 
11/2/2009  REL - Reply  11/6/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON LEGAL INADMISSIBILITY OF CITY'S PRE FILING OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPRTING APPRAISALS 
11/2/2009  REL - Reply  11/6/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S COMBINED/IN SUPPORT OF CITY'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT REGARDING DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT AND RESPONSE TO DEFNDANTS CROSS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT THAT THE DEFENDANTS ARE ENTITLED TO DAMAGES DURING THE THREE YEAR PERIOD OF THE IRREVOCABLE RIGHT OF ENTRY AGREEMENT 
11/2/2009  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  11/9/2009   
NOTE: TO COMBINED STATEMENT OF FACTS 
10/16/2009  RES - Response  10/26/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S TO GARRETSONS' MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION 
10/14/2009  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  10/14/2009   
10/13/2009  NOF - Notice Of Filing  10/20/2009   
NOTE: MARK M GRUMLEY DECLARATION 
10/13/2009  RES - Response  10/20/2009   
NOTE: TO MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT REGARDING DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT AND CROSS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT THAT DEFENDANTS ARE ENTITLED TO DAMAGES DURING THREE YEAR PERIOD OF THE IRREVOCABLE RIGHT OF ENTRY AGREEMENT 
10/13/2009  NOF - Notice Of Filing  10/20/2009   
NOTE: JOHN GARRETSON DECLARATION 
10/13/2009  RES - Response  10/20/2009   
NOTE: TO MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON LEGAL INADMISSIBILITY OF PREFILNG OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPORTING APPRAISALS 
10/13/2009  SOF - Statement Of Facts  10/20/2009   
NOTE: GARRETSONS' COMBINED/IN OPPOSITION TO 1 CITY'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON LEGAL INADMISSIBILITY OF CITY'S PRE FILING OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPORTING APPRAISALS AND 2 THE CITY'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT REGARDING DADMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRUCITON EASEMENT 
10/13/2009  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  10/20/2009   
NOTE: TO CITY OF PHOENIX'S STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JDUGMENT REGARDING DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRCUTION EASEMENT 
10/13/2009  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  10/20/2009   
NOTE: TO CITY OF PHOENIX'S STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON LEGAL INADMISSIABILITY OF CITY'S PRE FILING OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPORTING APPRAISALS 
10/9/2009  NOF - Notice Of Filing  10/19/2009   
NOTE: SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY IN SUPPORT OF GARRETSONS MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION 
10/6/2009  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  10/6/2009   
9/24/2009  MFR - Motion For Reconsideration  9/29/2009   
9/9/2009  MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment  9/14/2009   
NOTE: PARTIAL/REGARDING DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT 
9/9/2009  MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment  9/14/2009   
NOTE: PARTIAL/ON LEGAL INADMISSIBILITY OF CITY'S PRE FILING OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPORTING APPRAISALS 
9/9/2009  SOF - Statement Of Facts  9/14/2009   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT REGARDING DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT 
8/28/2009  019 - ME: Ruling  8/28/2009   
8/20/2009  RES - Response  8/25/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S/TO GARRETSON'S SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORITY ON LOSS OF ACCESS DAMAGES 
8/19/2009  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  8/19/2009   
8/19/2009  ORD - Order  8/25/2009   
NOTE: EXTENDING ORAL ARGUMENT SCHEDULED FOR 8/17/09 
8/6/2009  REQ - Request  8/13/2009   
NOTE: JOINT/FOR EXTENDED ORAL ARGUMENT 
7/13/2009  021 - ME: Nunc Pro Tunc Order  7/13/2009   
7/1/2009  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  7/1/2009   
6/16/2009  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  6/16/2009   
6/12/2009  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  6/12/2009   
6/12/2009  REQ - Request  6/16/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S FOR COURT REPORTER 
6/8/2009  RES - Response  6/12/2009   
NOTE: TO GARRETSONS MOTION TO STRIKE THE CITYS REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF 1.CITYS ACQUISITIONOF THE WOODWARD PARCEL AND 2.DEFENDANTS CONCEPTUAL DEVELOPMENT PLANS AND CITYS REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF THE CITY PREFIL 
6/1/2009  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  6/1/2009   
5/27/2009  RES - Response  6/2/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX TO DEFENDANTS' SEPARATE STATEMENT OF FACTS 
5/27/2009  REL - Reply  6/2/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON SERVERANCE DAMAGES 
5/21/2009  MOT - Motion  5/28/2009   
NOTE: GARRETSONS' TO STRIKE CITY OF PHOENIX'S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF I CITY'S ACQUISITION OF THE WOODWARD PARCEL AND II DEFENDANTS' CONCEPTUAL DEVELOPMENT PLANS AND CITY OF PHOENIX'S REPLY IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF CITY'S PREFILING OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPORTING APPRAISALS 
5/20/2009  REL - Reply  5/22/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF CITY'S PRE-FILING OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPORTING APPRAISALS 
5/19/2009  REL - Reply  5/22/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF I CITY'S ACQUISITION OF THE WOODWARD PARCEL AND II DEFENDANTS CONCEPTUAL DEVELOPMENT PLANS 
5/18/2009  REL - Reply  5/21/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHONENIX'S IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR LEGAL RULING REGARDING DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT 
5/8/2009  ORD - Order  5/13/2009   
NOTE: RE EXTENSION OF TIME FOR DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE TO THE FOLLWOING MOTIONS FILED BY THE CITY CITY OF PHOENIX'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JDUGMENT ON SEVERANCE DAMAGES CITY OF PHOENIX'S MOTION TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF CITY'S PRE FILING OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPORTING APPRAISALS CITY OF PHOENIX'S MOTION FOR LEGAL RULING REGARDING DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT AND CITY OF PHOENIX'S MOTION TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF I CITY'S ACQUISITION OF THE WOODWARD PARCEL AND II DEFENDANTS' CONCEPTUAL DEVELOPMENT PLANS 
5/7/2009  RES - Response  5/12/2009   
NOTE: GARRETSONS' IN OPPOSITION TO CITY OF PHOENIX'S MOTION IN LIMINE TO ESCLUDE EVIDENCE OF I CITY'S ACQUISITION OF THE WOODWARD PARCEL AND II DEFENDANTS' CONCEPTUAL DEVLEOPMENT PLANS 
5/7/2009  NOF - Notice Of Filing  5/12/2009   
NOTE: OF THE JOHN GARRETSON DECLARATION 
5/7/2009  RES - Response  5/12/2009   
NOTE: DEFENDANTS' TO CITY OF PHOENIX'S MOTION FOR LEGAL RULING REGARDING DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT AND CROSS MOTION FOR LEGAL RULING THAT THE DEFENDANTS ARE ENTITLED TO DAMAGES DURING THE THREE YEAR PERIOD OF THE IRREVOCABLE RIGHT 
5/7/2009  RES - Response  5/12/2009   
NOTE: GARRETSONS' TO CITY OF PHOENIX'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON SERVERANCE 
5/7/2009  RES - Response  5/12/2009   
NOTE: GARRETSONS' TO CITY OF PHOENIX'S MOTION TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF CITY'S PRE-FILING OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPORTING APPRAISALS 
5/7/2009  RES - Response  5/12/2009   
NOTE: DEFENDANTS' TO CITY OF PHOENIX'S STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON SEVERANCE DAMAGES AND DEFENDANTS' SEPARATE STATEMENT OF FACTS WHICH ESTANBLISH A GENUINE ISSUE OF MATERIAL FACT AND PRECLUDE SUMMARY JUDGMENT IN 
5/6/2009  RES - Response  5/11/2009   
NOTE: TO CITY OF PHOENIXS MOTION FOR LEGAL RULING REGARDING DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT AND CROSS-MOTION FOR LEGAL RULING THAT THE DEFENDANTS ARE ENTITLED TO DAMAGES DURING THE THREE YEAR PERIOD OF THE IRREVOCABLE RIGHT OF ENTRY AGRE 
5/6/2009  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  5/6/2009   
5/4/2009  MOT - Motion  5/6/2009   
NOTE: JOINT / AND STIPULATION TO EXTEND TIME FOR DEFENDANTS RESPONSE TO THE FOLLOWING MOTIONS FILED BY THE CITY / FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON SEVERANCE / TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF CITYS PREFILING OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPORTING APPRAISALS / FOR LEGAL RULING REGARDING DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT AND / TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF CITYS ACQUISITION OF THE WOODWARD PARCEL AND CONCEPTUAL DEVELOPMENT PLANS 
4/15/2009  MOT - Motion  4/21/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF 1 CITY'S ACQUISTION OF THE WOODWARD PARCEL AND II DEFENDANTS' CONCEPTUAL DEVELOPMENT PLANS 
3/31/2009  MOT - Motion  4/3/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S FOR LEGAL RULING REGARDING DAMAGES RECOVERABLE FOR TEMPORARY CONSTRUCTION EASEMENT 
3/23/2009  MOT - Motion  3/26/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENXI'S TO EXCLUDE EVIDENCE OF CITY'S PRE-FILING OFFERS TO PURCHASE AND SUPPORTING APPRAISALS 
3/13/2009  MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment  3/18/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S PARTIAL ON SEVERANCE DAMAGES 
3/13/2009  SOF - Statement Of Facts  3/19/2009   
NOTE: CITY OF PHOENIX'S IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON SEVERANCE DAMAGES 
12/22/2008  ORD - Order  12/29/2008   
NOTE: CONTINUING PRETRIAL DEADLINES 
12/9/2008  REL - Reply  12/15/2008   
NOTE: CITY'S RE MOTION TO CONTINUE PRETRIAL DEADLINES AND RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR RULE 16 PRETRIAL CONFERENCE AND CITY'S MOTION IN LIMINE REGARDING 1 PAUL BASHA B OPIONIONS BY MARK GRUMLEY AND C DISCOVERY RELATED TO WOODWARD ACQUISITION 
11/26/2008  RES - Response  12/3/2008   
NOTE: DEFENDANT'S TO MOTION TO CONTINUE PRETRIAL DEADLINES AND MOTION FOR RULE 16 PRETRIAL CONFERENCE 
11/12/2008  MCO - Motion To Continue  11/17/2008   
NOTE: PRETRIAL DEADLINES 
8/13/2008  ORD - Order  8/14/2008   
NOTE: AUTHORIZING SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL 
8/7/2008  APL - Application  8/13/2008   
NOTE: FOR ORDER AUTHORIZING SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL 
7/17/2008  ORD - Order  7/23/2008   
NOTE: CONTINUING TELEPHONIC TRIAL SETTING CONFERENCE AND PRETRIAL DEADLINES 
7/14/2008  MCO - Motion To Continue  7/17/2008   
NOTE: STIPULATED/TELEPHONIC TRIAL SETTING CONFERENCE AND PRETRIAL DEADLINES 
6/4/2008  ORD - Order  6/10/2008   
NOTE: REGARDING CONFIDENTIALITY OF INFORMATION DISCLOSED OR PRODUCED IN LITIGATION 
5/29/2008  ORD - Order  6/5/2008   
NOTE: STIPULATED/REGARDING CONFIDENTIALITY OF INFORMATION DISCLOSED OR PRODUCED IN LITIGATION 
2/27/2008  027 - ME: Pretrial Conference  2/27/2008   
2/20/2008  STA - Statement  2/22/2008   
NOTE: DISCLAIMER OF INTEREST OF MARICOPA COUNTY 
2/14/2008  MEM - Memorandum  2/20/2008   
NOTE: JOINT COMPREHENSIVE PRETRIAL 
1/4/2008  026 - ME: Pretrial Conference Set  1/4/2008   
1/4/2008  MOT - Motion  1/9/2008   
NOTE: FOR RULE 16 SCHEDULING CONFERENCE 
12/19/2007  MSE - Motion To Set & Cert/Readiness  12/26/2007   
8/22/2007  311 - ME: 150 Day Minute Entry  8/22/2007   
8/2/2007  NSC - Notice of Substitution of Counsel  8/6/2007   
NOTE: WITHIN FIRM 
5/21/2007  ANS - Answer  5/23/2007   
5/21/2007  CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject  5/22/2007   
5/21/2007  NJT - Not Demand For Jury Trials  5/22/2007   
5/8/2007  ANS - Answer  5/10/2007   
NOTE: ACCEPTANCE OF SERVICE/ PAID 
4/11/2007  ANS - Answer  4/13/2007   
NOTE: CO-CHG 
4/11/2007  CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject  4/16/2007   
4/2/2007  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  4/4/2007   
NOTE: COUNTY OF MARICOPA SERVED 3/20/07 
4/2/2007  SUM - Summons  4/4/2007   
3/16/2007  COM - Complaint  3/20/2007   
3/16/2007  CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject  3/20/2007   
3/16/2007  NOT - Notice  3/20/2007   
NOTE: OF LIS PENDENS 
Case Calendar
Date Time Event
2/25/2008  13:30  Pre-Trial Conference 
9/2/2008  9:00  Status Conference 
2/19/2009  9:00  Status Conference 
6/25/2009  8:45  Status Conference 
6/26/2009  13:30  Status Conference 
6/29/2009  9:00  Status Conference 
8/17/2009  14:00  Oral Argument 
8/18/2009  10:00  Oral Argument 
11/24/2009  16:30  Status Conference 
1/8/2010  15:00  Oral Argument 
5/28/2010  9:00  Status Conference 
7/29/2010  8:30  Status Conference 
9/30/2010  8:30  Status Conference 
8/20/2014  13:30  Status Conference 
12/1/2015  8:45  Pre-Trial Conference 
3/4/2016  10:15  Status Conference 
5/20/2016  10:00  Pre-Trial Conference 
6/6/2016  8:45  Trial 
6/13/2016  8:45  Trial 
9/16/2016  10:00  Pre-Trial Conference 
10/7/2016  13:30  Settlement Conference 
10/17/2016  8:45  Trial 
10/24/2016  8:45  Trial 
Judgments
Date (F)or / (A)gainst Amount Frequency Type Status
12/1/2016  F:John E Garretson  $5,394.99  One Time  Costs  Satisfied 
  A: City Of Phoenix         
12/1/2016  F:John E Garretson  $2,869,360.00  One Time  Principal  Satisfied 
  A: City Of Phoenix         
10/26/2016  F:Maricopa County Creditor  $1,809.28  One Time  Judgment for Jury Fees  Vacated 
  A: City Of Phoenix         
7/16/2010  F:John E Garretson  $7,134.00  One Time  Principal  Satisfied 
  A: City Of Phoenix