« Return to search results
Case Information
Case Number:
CV2007-002986
Judge:
Pineda, Susanna
File Date:
2/20/2007
Location:
Downtown
Case Type:
Civil
Party Information
Party Name
Relationship
Sex
Attorney
Party Name
Virgel Cain
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Male
Attorney
Donald Peters
Party Name
Sandy Bahr
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Female
Attorney
Donald Peters
Party Name
Scott Holcomb
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Male
Attorney
Donald Peters
Party Name
Arizona Association Of School Business Officials
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Attorney
Donald Peters
Party Name
Arizona Education Association
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Attorney
Donald Peters
Party Name
Arizona Federation Of Teacher Unions
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Attorney
Donald Peters
Party Name
Arizona Parent Teacher Association
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Attorney
Donald Peters
Party Name
Arizona Rural School Administrators Inc
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Attorney
Donald Peters
Party Name
Arizona School Boards Association
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Attorney
Donald Peters
Party Name
American Civil Liberties Union Of Arizona
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Attorney
Donald Peters
Party Name
People For The American Way
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Attorney
Donald Peters
Party Name
Tom Horne
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Male
Attorney
William Richards
Party Name
Jessica Geroux
Relationship
Intervenor
Sex
Female
Attorney
Timothy Keller
Party Name
Andrea Weck
Relationship
Intervenor
Sex
Female
Attorney
Timothy Keller
Party Name
Kristinia Peterson
Relationship
Intervenor
Sex
Female
Attorney
Timothy Keller
Party Name
Kimberly Wuestenberg
Relationship
Intervenor
Sex
Female
Attorney
Timothy Keller
Party Name
Edwin Rivera
Relationship
Intervenor
Sex
Male
Attorney
Timothy Keller
Party Name
Mike Okamura
Relationship
Intervenor
Sex
Male
Attorney
Timothy Keller
Party Name
Shirley Okamura
Relationship
Intervenor
Sex
Female
Attorney
Timothy Keller
Case Documents
Filing Date
Description
Docket Date
Filing Party
Filing Date
6/26/2009
Description
JUD - Judgment
Docket Date
7/6/2009
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties
Filing Date
6/24/2009
Description
NRD - Notice Of Release Of Deposit
Docket Date
6/29/2009
Filing Party
NOTE:
$1,000.00 FOR MILLER LASOTA & PETERS
Filing Date
6/17/2009
Description
029 - ME: Status Conference
Docket Date
6/17/2009
Filing Party
Filing Date
6/12/2009
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
6/17/2009
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF LODGING PROPOSED JUDGMENT ON MANDATE
Filing Date
6/12/2009
Description
MEB - Motion to Release/Exonerate Bond
Docket Date
6/16/2009
Filing Party
NOTE:
FOR COSTS ON APPEAL
Filing Date
6/10/2009
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
6/16/2009
Filing Party
NOTE:
JOINT / OF STATEMENT OF THE CASE
Filing Date
6/9/2009
Description
ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal
Docket Date
6/9/2009
Filing Party
NOTE:
SUPREME COURT/
Filing Date
6/9/2009
Description
MAN - Order Of Mandate
Docket Date
6/9/2009
Filing Party
NOTE:
SUPREME COURT/REMANDING TO THE SUPERIOR COURT
Filing Date
4/17/2009
Description
028 - ME: Status Conference Set
Docket Date
4/17/2009
Filing Party
Filing Date
6/23/2008
Description
002 - ME: Hearing Vacated
Docket Date
6/23/2008
Filing Party
Filing Date
6/11/2008
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
6/13/2008
Filing Party
NOTE:
JOINT OF STATEMENT OF THE CASE
Filing Date
6/6/2008
Description
028 - ME: Status Conference Set
Docket Date
6/6/2008
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/21/2008
Description
CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt
Docket Date
2/21/2008
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/7/2008
Description
LET - Letter
Docket Date
2/8/2008
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/5/2008
Description
CAO - Court Of Appeals Order
Docket Date
2/7/2008
Filing Party
Filing Date
10/16/2007
Description
ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal
Docket Date
10/17/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
9/19/2007
Description
REC - Receipt
Docket Date
9/19/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
COURT OF APPEAL
Filing Date
9/17/2007
Description
LET - Letter
Docket Date
9/17/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
FROM COURT OF APPEALS / FILING FEE IS DUE
Filing Date
9/7/2007
Description
LET - Letter
Docket Date
9/10/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
CERTIFICATION LETTER
Filing Date
9/7/2007
Description
AIX - Appeals Index
Docket Date
9/10/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/15/2007
Description
CAS - Civil Appeals Docketing Statement
Docket Date
8/16/2007
Filing Party
Plaintiff(1)
Filing Date
8/13/2007
Description
NAP - Notice Of Appeal
Docket Date
8/16/2007
Filing Party
Plaintiff(1)
Filing Date
8/13/2007
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
8/17/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
BOND FOR COSTS ON APPEAL
Filing Date
8/13/2007
Description
NDC - Notice Of Deposit With Court
Docket Date
8/20/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
$500.00 APPEAL BOND FOR PLAINTIFF
Filing Date
7/27/2007
Description
JDI - Judgment Of Dismissal
Docket Date
8/2/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
WITH PREJUDICE
Filing Date
6/26/2007
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
6/28/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF LODGING PROPOSED FORM OF JUDGMENT
Filing Date
6/14/2007
Description
019 - ME: Ruling
Docket Date
6/14/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
6/7/2007
Description
020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement
Docket Date
6/7/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/18/2007
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
5/21/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS
Filing Date
5/18/2007
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
5/22/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
INTERVENOR PARENTS' TO PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE TO MOTION TO DISMISS AND REPLY TO PLAINTIFFS' RESPONSE TO RULE 56(F) APPLICATION
Filing Date
5/18/2007
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
5/22/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
INTERVENOR PARENTS' OF PROVIDING COPIES OF OUT-OF-STATE CASES TO JUDGE HICKS
Filing Date
5/8/2007
Description
PHO - Pro Hac Vice Order
Docket Date
5/15/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
WILLIAM H MELLORS
Filing Date
5/8/2007
Description
PHO - Pro Hac Vice Order
Docket Date
5/15/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
RICHARD D KOMERS
Filing Date
5/8/2007
Description
PHO - Pro Hac Vice Order
Docket Date
5/15/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
CLARK M NEILY III
Filing Date
5/4/2007
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
5/7/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS RESPONSE TO INTERVENORS MOTION TO DISMISS AND RESPONSE TO RULE 56(F) APPLICATIONS
Filing Date
4/19/2007
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
4/24/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO ASSOCIATE WILLIAM H MELLOR PRO HAC VICE
Filing Date
4/19/2007
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
4/23/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO ASSOCIATE WILLIAM H MELLOR PRO HAC VICE
Filing Date
4/19/2007
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
4/23/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO ASSOCIATE CLARK M NEILY III PRO HAC VICE
Filing Date
4/19/2007
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
4/23/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO ASSOCIATE RICHARD D KOMER POR HAC VICE
Filing Date
4/18/2007
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
4/24/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
AND OBJECTION TO PLAINTIFFS STATEMENT OF FACTS AND CONTROVERTING STATEMENT
Filing Date
4/18/2007
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
4/19/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO PLAINTIFFS STATEMENT OF FACTS
Filing Date
4/18/2007
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
4/19/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND RULE 56(F) APPLICATION FOR ADDITIONAL TIME TO CONDUCT DISCOVERY
Filing Date
4/18/2007
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
4/20/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
DEFENDANTS' FOR JUDGMENT ON THE PLEADINGS OBJECTION TO PLAINTIFFS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND IN THE ALTERNATIVE REQUEST FOR RELIEF UNDER ARIZ R CIV P 56(F)
Filing Date
4/2/2007
Description
SOF - Statement Of Facts
Docket Date
4/4/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS'
Filing Date
4/2/2007
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
4/4/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO DEFENDANT'S RESPONSE TO APPLICATION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
Filing Date
4/2/2007
Description
MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment
Docket Date
4/4/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
3/29/2007
Description
BON - Bond
Docket Date
4/2/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
PURSUANT TO ARS 35-213(B0
Filing Date
3/29/2007
Description
NDC - Notice Of Deposit With Court
Docket Date
4/4/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
$500.00 FOR BOND BY DONALD PETERS
Filing Date
3/27/2007
Description
094 - ME: Oral Argument Set
Docket Date
3/27/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
3/26/2007
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
3/27/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE HEARING ON APPLICATION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION WITH TRIAL ON MERITS
Filing Date
3/26/2007
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
3/27/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS APPLICATION FOR A PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
Filing Date
3/26/2007
Description
MTD - Motion To Dismiss
Docket Date
3/28/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
AND MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS
Filing Date
3/22/2007
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
3/26/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF CAPTION ERROR
Filing Date
3/21/2007
Description
ORD - Order
Docket Date
3/23/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
DIRECTING CLERK TO ACCEPT BOND FOR FILING
Filing Date
3/21/2007
Description
LET - Letter
Docket Date
3/26/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
3/21/2007
Description
ORD - Order
Docket Date
3/23/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
CONFIRMING THAT THE ONLY DEFENDANT NAMED IN THIS ACTION IS TOM HORNE IN HIS OFFICIAL CAPACITY AS ARIZONA SUPERINTENDENT OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTION AND INSTRUCTING THE COURT CLERK TO REMOVE TERRY GODDARD, TIM BEE AND JIM WEIERS AS NAMED DEFENDANTS FROM THE COURT DOCKET
Filing Date
3/19/2007
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
3/20/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE TO UNOPPOSED MOTION TO INTERVENE
Filing Date
3/15/2007
Description
REL - Reply
Docket Date
3/19/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE HEARING ON APPLICATION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION WITH TRIAL ON THE MERITS
Filing Date
3/14/2007
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
3/16/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO UNOPPOSED MOTION TO INTERVENE
Filing Date
3/13/2007
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
3/16/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
APLICANTS PROPOSED/ IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO CONSOLIDATE HEARING ON APPLICATION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION WITH TRIAL ON MERITS
Filing Date
3/13/2007
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
3/16/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
APPLICANTS PROPOSED/ IN OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS APPLICATION FOR A PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION
Filing Date
3/13/2007
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
3/15/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
DEFENDANT'S TO PLAINTIFF'S APPLICATION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION AND OBJECTION TO MOTION TO CONSOIDATE HEARING ON APPLICATION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION WITH TRIAL ON THE MERITS
Filing Date
3/13/2007
Description
ANS - Answer
Docket Date
3/14/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
CO-CHG
Filing Date
3/13/2007
Description
MTD - Motion To Dismiss
Docket Date
3/15/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
PROPOSED/ AND MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS
Filing Date
3/13/2007
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
5/30/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
UNOPPOSED/ TO INTERVENE AS DEFENDANTS AND MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO INTERVENE/ PAID
Filing Date
3/9/2007
Description
019 - ME: Ruling
Docket Date
3/9/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
3/7/2007
Description
OSC - Order To Show Cause
Docket Date
3/9/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
3/7/2007
Description
ORD - Order
Docket Date
3/13/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
GRANTING EXTENSION OF TIME FOR DEFENDANT TO RESPOND TO APPLICATION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION AND APPLICATION FOR ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Filing Date
3/6/2007
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
3/9/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
FOR ORDER DIRECTING CLERK TO ACCEPT BOND FOR FILING
Filing Date
3/6/2007
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
3/9/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
STIPULATED REGARDING CORRECTION OF NAMED DEFENDANTS
Filing Date
2/28/2007
Description
STP - Stipulation
Docket Date
3/6/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
FOR EXTENSION OF TIME FOR DEFENDANT TO RESPOND TO APPLICATION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION AND APPLICATION FOR ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Filing Date
2/28/2007
Description
066 - ME: Case Reassigned
Docket Date
2/28/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/26/2007
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
2/28/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TOM HORNE SERVED 02/21/2007
Filing Date
2/26/2007
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
2/28/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TERRY GODDARD SERVED 02/21/07
Filing Date
2/26/2007
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
2/28/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TIM BEE SERVED 02/21/2007
Filing Date
2/26/2007
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
2/28/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
JIM WEIERS SERVED 02/21/2007
Filing Date
2/26/2007
Description
066 - ME: Case Reassigned
Docket Date
2/26/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/20/2007
Description
NJR - Notice of change of Judge for right
Docket Date
2/26/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/20/2007
Description
COM - Complaint
Docket Date
2/23/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/20/2007
Description
CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject
Docket Date
2/23/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/20/2007
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
2/23/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
FOR LEAVE TO EXCEED PAGE LIMITS
Filing Date
2/20/2007
Description
APL - Application
Docket Date
2/23/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
FOR ORDER TO SHOW CAUSE
Filing Date
2/20/2007
Description
MOT - Motion
Docket Date
2/23/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO CONSOLIDATE HEARING ON APPLICATION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION WITH TRIAL ON THE MERITS
Filing Date
2/20/2007
Description
APL - Application
Docket Date
2/23/2007
Filing Party
NOTE:
FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTIN
Case Calendar
Date
Time
Event
Date
3/21/2007
Time
16:15
Event
Order To Show Cause
Date
6/4/2007
Time
13:30
Event
Oral Argument
Date
6/20/2008
Time
10:15
Event
Status Conference
Date
6/15/2009
Time
9:45
Event
Status Conference
Judgments
Date
(F)or / (A)gainst
Amount
Frequency
Type
Status
Date
6/26/2009
(F)or / (A)gainst
F:  Sandy Bahr, Scott Holcomb, Arizona Association Of School Business Officials, Arizona Education Association, Arizona Federation Of Teacher Unions, Arizona Parent Teacher Association, Arizona Rural School Administrators Inc, Arizona School Boards Association, American Civil Liberties Union Of Arizona, People For The American Way
A: Tom Horne
Amount
$2,457.00
Frequency
One Time
Type
Attorney Fee
Status
Date
6/26/2009
(F)or / (A)gainst
F:  Sandy Bahr, Scott Holcomb, Arizona Association Of School Business Officials, Arizona Education Association, Arizona Federation Of Teacher Unions, Arizona Parent Teacher Association, Arizona Rural School Administrators Inc, Arizona School Boards Association, American Civil Liberties Union Of Arizona, People For The American Way
A: Tom Horne
Amount
$256,462.91
Frequency
One Time
Type
Attorney Fee
Status