« Return to search results
Case Information
Case Number:
CV2003-008738
Judge:
Como, Greg
File Date:
5/6/2003
Location:
Downtown
Case Type:
Civil
Party Information
Party Name
Relationship
Sex
Attorney
Party Name
David J Walls
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Male
Attorney
Kevin Keenan
Party Name
Geraldine M Walls
Relationship
Plaintiff
Sex
Female
Attorney
Kevin Keenan
Party Name
Denise Smith
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Female
Attorney
PETER KLINE
Party Name
Valley Radiologists Ltd
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Attorney
PETER KLINE
Party Name
Francisco C Espinoza
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Male
Attorney
Vincent Montell
Party Name
Francisco C Espinoza M D, P C
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Attorney
Vincent Montell
Party Name
Larry R Ryan
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Male
Attorney
Peter Wittekind
Party Name
John C Lincoln Health Network
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Attorney
STEPHEN BULLINGTON
Party Name
Herbert D Goodman M D, P C
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Attorney
James Broening
Party Name
Colleen Ryan
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Female
Attorney
Peter Wittekind
Party Name
Robert Smith
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Male
Attorney
PETER KLINE
Party Name
Colleen Ryan
Relationship
Defendant
Sex
Female
Attorney
Pro Per
Party Name
Maricopa County Creditor
Relationship
In The Matter Of (IMO)
Sex
Attorney
Pro Per
Case Documents
Filing Date
Description
Docket Date
Filing Party
Filing Date
2/6/2008
Description
DEW - Disposition Of Exhibit Worksheet
Docket Date
2/14/2008
Filing Party
Filing Date
12/7/2007
Description
LED - 2.8 (d) Letter
Docket Date
12/7/2007
Filing Party
Filing Date
11/22/2005
Description
SJU - Satisfaction Of Judgment
Docket Date
11/29/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
10/27/2005
Description
JUD - Judgment
Docket Date
11/2/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties
Filing Date
10/18/2005
Description
SJU - Satisfaction Of Judgment
Docket Date
10/27/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
FOR JURY FEES
Filing Date
10/3/2005
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
10/11/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO PLAINTIFFS OBJECTION TO DEFENDANTS STATEMENT OF TAXABLE COSTS
Filing Date
9/21/2005
Description
OBJ - Objection/Opposition
Docket Date
9/27/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS' TO DEFENDANT'S STATEMETNOF TAXABLE COSTS
Filing Date
9/9/2005
Description
SOC - Statement Of Costs
Docket Date
9/16/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
DEFENDANT'S TAXABLE
Filing Date
9/8/2005
Description
EXW - Exhibits Work Sheet
Docket Date
9/20/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
9/6/2005
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
9/12/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF LODGING PROPOSED FORM OF JUDGMENT
Filing Date
9/2/2005
Description
012 - ME: Trial
Docket Date
9/2/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
9/1/2005
Description
012 - ME: Trial
Docket Date
9/1/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/31/2005
Description
012 - ME: Trial
Docket Date
8/31/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/31/2005
Description
JJF - Judgment For Jury Fees
Docket Date
9/9/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties
Filing Date
8/31/2005
Description
JIN - Jury Instructions
Docket Date
9/13/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
FINAL
Filing Date
8/31/2005
Description
WSH - Worksheet
Docket Date
9/13/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/31/2005
Description
VER - Verdict
Docket Date
9/13/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/31/2005
Description
VER - Verdict
Docket Date
9/13/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/26/2005
Description
012 - ME: Trial
Docket Date
8/26/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/25/2005
Description
012 - ME: Trial
Docket Date
8/25/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/25/2005
Description
DPR - Deposition Report
Docket Date
9/23/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF DAVID JOHN WALLS OCTOBER 9, 2003, BY LORI L. YEAGER
Filing Date
8/25/2005
Description
DPR - Deposition Report
Docket Date
9/23/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF GERALDINE MARIE WALLS OCTOBER 9, 2003 BY LORI L YEAGER
Filing Date
8/24/2005
Description
JQU - Jury Question
Docket Date
9/13/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/24/2005
Description
JQU - Jury Question
Docket Date
9/13/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/24/2005
Description
JQU - Jury Question
Docket Date
9/13/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/24/2005
Description
JQU - Jury Question
Docket Date
9/13/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/23/2005
Description
JUL - Jury List - Restricted if Filed after 1/1/2008
Docket Date
9/13/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/23/2005
Description
JIN - Jury Instructions
Docket Date
9/13/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
PRELIMINARY
Filing Date
8/22/2005
Description
DPR - Deposition Report
Docket Date
9/23/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF MARTIN A SCHWARTZ M.D. APRIL 12, 2004 BY EDWARD G HARRISON
Filing Date
8/22/2005
Description
DPR - Deposition Report
Docket Date
9/23/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF SKIP T HECK AUGUST 6, 2004 BY LINDA BLACKMON
Filing Date
8/22/2005
Description
DPR - Deposition Report
Docket Date
9/23/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF GLENN B ROTHMAN APRIL 7, 2004 BY JEAN L LEA
Filing Date
8/22/2005
Description
DPR - Deposition Report
Docket Date
9/23/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF DAVID WILLIAM EISELE MD JULY 12, 2004 BY KIM RUPIPER
Filing Date
8/22/2005
Description
DPR - Deposition Report
Docket Date
9/23/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF WILLIAM W HORSLEY M.D APRIL 6, 2004 BY KIM RUPIPER
Filing Date
8/22/2005
Description
DPR - Deposition Report
Docket Date
9/23/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF LAWRENCE ROBERT RYAN D.O DECEMBER 3, 2003 BY KIM RUPIPER
Filing Date
8/22/2005
Description
DPR - Deposition Report
Docket Date
9/23/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF DENISE SMITH MD OCTOBER 27,2003 BY JILL FULKERSON
Filing Date
8/22/2005
Description
DPR - Deposition Report
Docket Date
9/23/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF FRANCISCO C ESPINOZA MD DECEMBER 10, 2003 BY KIM RUPIPER
Filing Date
8/10/2005
Description
REQ - Request
Docket Date
8/17/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
FOR COURT REPORTER DURING TRIAL
Filing Date
8/1/2005
Description
005 - ME: Hearing
Docket Date
8/1/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/1/2005
Description
064 - ME: Trial Continued/Reset
Docket Date
8/1/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
7/29/2005
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
8/4/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO RECONSIDER COURT RULING ON DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NUMBER TWO REGARDING PERSONAL PRACTICES OF EXPERTS
Filing Date
7/27/2005
Description
MFR - Motion For Reconsideration
Docket Date
8/5/2005
Filing Party
NOTE:
COURTS RULING ON DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NUMBER TWO REGARDING PERSONAL PRACTICES OF EXPERTS
Filing Date
2/10/2005
Description
064 - ME: Trial Continued/Reset
Docket Date
2/10/2005
Filing Party
Filing Date
9/21/2004
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
9/28/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS' SUPPLEMENTAL TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION IN LIMINE NO 6 RE DR HECK
Filing Date
9/2/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
9/9/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
SUPPLEMENT/ RE SKIP HECK NO 6
Filing Date
8/26/2004
Description
064 - ME: Trial Continued/Reset
Docket Date
8/26/2004
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/19/2004
Description
NOF - Notice Of Filing
Docket Date
8/31/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TIME ESTIMATES FOR TRIAL
Filing Date
8/18/2004
Description
REQ - Request
Docket Date
8/20/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
JOINT PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Filing Date
8/18/2004
Description
REQ - Request
Docket Date
8/20/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS PROPOSED FORM OF VERDICT
Filing Date
8/18/2004
Description
REQ - Request
Docket Date
8/20/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS PROPOSED VOIR DIRE
Filing Date
8/18/2004
Description
REQ - Request
Docket Date
8/20/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
PLAINTIFFS ADDITIONAL PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS
Filing Date
8/18/2004
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
8/20/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
JOINT SUMMARY OF THE CASE TO BE READ BY THE COURT TO THE JURY
Filing Date
8/18/2004
Description
STA - Statement
Docket Date
8/20/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
JOINT PRETRIAL/
Filing Date
8/17/2004
Description
REQ - Request
Docket Date
8/31/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
DEFENDANTS SMITH AND VALLEY RADIOLOGIST LTDS PROPOSED VOIR DIRE
Filing Date
7/23/2004
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
7/28/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO DEFENSE MOTION IN LIMINE NO 2 RE PERSONAL PRACTICES OF EXPERTS
Filing Date
7/23/2004
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
7/28/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO DEFENSE MOTION IN LIMINE NO 3 RE: SCOPE OF TESTIMONY BY PLAINTIFFS EXPERTS
Filing Date
7/23/2004
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
7/28/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 4 RE DR ROTHMAN
Filing Date
7/23/2004
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
7/28/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO DEFENSE MOTION IN LIMINE NO 5 RE LOST WAGES
Filing Date
7/23/2004
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
7/28/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 6 RE DR HECK
Filing Date
7/23/2004
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
7/28/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO DEFENSE MOTION IN LIMINE NO 1 RE ACR GUIDELINES
Filing Date
7/19/2004
Description
ORD - Order
Docket Date
7/28/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
RESCHEDULING THE FINAL TRIAL MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE
Filing Date
7/16/2004
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
7/27/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 4
Filing Date
7/16/2004
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
7/27/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 5
Filing Date
7/16/2004
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
7/27/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 6
Filing Date
7/16/2004
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
7/27/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 3
Filing Date
7/16/2004
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
7/27/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO PLAINTIFFS MOTIONS IN LIMINE NOS 1 AND 2
Filing Date
7/12/2004
Description
STP - Stipulation
Docket Date
7/27/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO RESCHEDULE THE FINAL TRIAL MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE
Filing Date
7/7/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
7/15/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
NO 3 RE DEFENDANTS AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSES
Filing Date
7/7/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
7/15/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
NO 1
Filing Date
7/7/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
7/15/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
NO 5 RE: INCREASED COST OF HEALTHCARE
Filing Date
7/7/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
7/15/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
NO 6 RE: PRECLUDING EVIDENCE OF THE TAX CONSEQUENCES OF A RECOVERY BY PLAINTIFFS
Filing Date
7/7/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
7/15/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
NO 4 RE: PRIOR LAWSUITS INVOLVING DEFENDANTS, EXPERTS OR TREATING PHYSICIANS
Filing Date
7/7/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
7/15/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
NO 2 RE: PRECLUDING ANY REFERENCE TO THE STANDARD OF CARE OF ANY HEALTHCARE PROVIDER OTHER THAN DENISE SMITH MD
Filing Date
7/7/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
7/15/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
NO 1 RE: PRECLUDING ANY FAULT BY NON-PARTIES
Filing Date
7/7/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
7/15/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
NO 6
Filing Date
7/7/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
7/15/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
NO 5
Filing Date
7/7/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
7/15/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
NO 3: SCOPE OF TESTIMONY BY PLAINTIFFS EXPERTS
Filing Date
7/7/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
7/15/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
NO 4 CAUSATION TESTIMONY
Filing Date
7/7/2004
Description
MIL - Motion In Limine
Docket Date
7/15/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
NO 2
Filing Date
6/11/2004
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
6/17/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF SERVICE OF OFFER OF JUDGMENT TO DEFENDANTS SMITH AND VALLEY RADIOLOGISTS LTD
Filing Date
5/5/2004
Description
STA - Statement
Docket Date
5/11/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
JOINT OF OUTCOME OF MEDIATION
Filing Date
3/17/2004
Description
ODI - Order Of Dismissal
Docket Date
4/7/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
DEFENDANTS OTHER THAN SMITH AND VALLEY RADIOLOGISTS LTD
Filing Date
3/11/2004
Description
STD - Stipulation To/For Dismissal
Docket Date
4/8/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
DEFENDANTS OTHER THAN SMITH AND VALLEY RADIOLOGISTS LTD
Filing Date
2/11/2004
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
4/1/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF TRIAL CONFLICTS
Filing Date
11/25/2003
Description
NNF - Not Of Non-Parties At Fault
Docket Date
4/12/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
DEFENDANT HERBERT C GOODMAN MD PC DBA NORTHWEST MEDICAL CENTER'S
Filing Date
9/10/2003
Description
089 - ME: Trial Setting
Docket Date
9/10/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/27/2003
Description
MEM - Memorandum
Docket Date
1/14/2004
Filing Party
NOTE:
JOINT COMPREHENSIVE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE/
Filing Date
8/13/2003
Description
026 - ME: Pretrial Conference Set
Docket Date
8/13/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
8/1/2003
Description
066 - ME: Case Reassigned
Docket Date
8/1/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
7/24/2003
Description
NJR - Notice of change of Judge for right
Docket Date
12/12/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
7/14/2003
Description
041 - ME: Scheduling Conference Set
Docket Date
7/14/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
7/9/2003
Description
NOT - Notice
Docket Date
11/14/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF SERVICE OF PLAINTFFS MEDICAL RECORDS TO DEFENDANTS
Filing Date
7/2/2003
Description
NAR - Notice Of Appearance
Docket Date
10/29/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
OF DEFENDANTS AND REQUEST FOR COMPRENSIVE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE
Filing Date
7/2/2003
Description
ANS - Answer
Docket Date
7/10/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
PAID
Filing Date
6/27/2003
Description
CCA - Cert Compulsory Arbitration
Docket Date
11/10/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
6/27/2003
Description
NJT - Not Demand For Jury Trial
Docket Date
11/10/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
6/27/2003
Description
ANS - Answer
Docket Date
7/2/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
PAID
Filing Date
6/9/2003
Description
ACS - Acceptance Of Service
Docket Date
6/21/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
FRANCISCO C ESPINOZA AND JANE DOE SERVED 06/05/03
Filing Date
6/5/2003
Description
RES - Response
Docket Date
11/12/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
TO PLAINTIFFS' CERTIFICATE OF COMPULSORY ARBITRATION
Filing Date
6/5/2003
Description
NJT - Not Demand For Jury Trial
Docket Date
11/12/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
6/5/2003
Description
ANS - Answer
Docket Date
6/14/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
PAID
Filing Date
6/4/2003
Description
ANS - Answer
Docket Date
6/6/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
PAID
Filing Date
6/4/2003
Description
CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject
Docket Date
10/27/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/30/2003
Description
NJT - Not Demand For Jury Trial
Docket Date
7/12/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/30/2003
Description
CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject
Docket Date
7/12/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/30/2003
Description
ANS - Answer
Docket Date
6/10/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
PAID
Filing Date
5/29/2003
Description
AAS - Affidavit Of Attempted Service
Docket Date
6/20/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/29/2003
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
6/20/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
LARRY R AND COLLEN RYAN SERVED 5/29/03
Filing Date
5/29/2003
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
11/22/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/29/2003
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
11/22/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/29/2003
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
11/22/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/20/2003
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
10/23/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/20/2003
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
10/23/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/19/2003
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
6/2/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
FRANCISCO C ESPINOZA MD PC SERVED 05-12-03
Filing Date
5/19/2003
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
6/2/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
JOHN C LINCOLN HEALTH NETWORK SERVED 05-08-03
Filing Date
5/19/2003
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
6/2/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
DENISE J SMITH SERVED 05-09-03
Filing Date
5/19/2003
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
6/2/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
HERBERT D GOODMAN MD PC SERVED 05-09-03
Filing Date
5/19/2003
Description
AFS - Affidavit Of Service
Docket Date
6/2/2003
Filing Party
NOTE:
VALLEY RADIOLOGISTS LTD SERVED 05-09-03
Filing Date
5/19/2003
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
10/17/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/19/2003
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
10/17/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/19/2003
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
10/17/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/19/2003
Description
SUM - Summons
Docket Date
10/17/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/6/2003
Description
COM - Complaint
Docket Date
5/8/2003
Filing Party
Filing Date
5/6/2003
Description
CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject
Docket Date
5/8/2003
Filing Party
Case Calendar
Date
Time
Event
Date
9/3/2003
Time
9:15
Event
Pre-Trial Conference
Date
9/3/2003
Time
9:15
Event
Pre-Trial Conference
Date
8/16/2004
Time
8:30
Event
Pre-Trial Conference
Date
8/24/2004
Time
8:45
Event
Pre-Trial Conference
Date
9/8/2004
Time
9:30
Event
Trial
Date
2/4/2005
Time
8:45
Event
Pre-Trial Conference
Date
2/25/2005
Time
9:30
Event
Trial
Date
7/29/2005
Time
8:45
Event
Pre-Trial Conference
Date
8/19/2005
Time
9:30
Event
Trial
Date
8/23/2005
Time
9:30
Event
Trial
Date
8/24/2005
Time
9:30
Event
Trial
Date
8/25/2005
Time
9:30
Event
Trial
Date
8/30/2005
Time
9:30
Event
Trial
Date
8/31/2005
Time
9:30
Event
Trial
Judgments
Date
(F)or / (A)gainst
Amount
Frequency
Type
Status
Date
10/27/2005
(F)or / (A)gainst
F:  Denise Smith, Valley Radiologists Ltd
A: David J Walls
Amount
$12,562.93
Frequency
One Time
Type
Costs
Status
Satisfied
Date
8/31/2005
(F)or / (A)gainst
F:  Maricopa County Creditor
A: David J Walls
Amount
$974.70
Frequency
One Time
Type
Judgment for Jury Fees
Status
Satisfied