Civil Court Case Information - Case History

« Return to search results
Case Information
Case Number: CV2003-004880 Judge: Moskowitz, Frank
File Date: 3/13/2003 Location: Downtown
Case Type: Civil  
Party Information
Party Name Relationship Sex Attorney
Paul J Phillips   Plaintiff  Male  Mia Alexia 
Mayo Clinic Arizona   Defendant    Barry Halpern 
Mayo Clinic Scottsdale   Defendant    Barry Halpern 
Mayo Foundation   Defendant    Robert Feinberg 
Mayo Clinic Hospital   Defendant    Barry Halpern 
Mayo Clinics In Our Care   Defendant    Robert Feinberg 
Mayo Regional Practices Arizona   Defendant    Barry Halpern 
Mayo Foundation For Medical Education And Research   Defendant    Robert Feinberg 
Mayo Health Plan Arizona   Defendant    Barry Halpern 
Mayo Management Services Inc   Defendant    Robert Feinberg 
Mayo Healthcare Network   Defendant    Robert Feinberg 
Maricopa County Creditor   In The Matter Of (IMO)    Pro Per 
Case Documents
Filing Date Description Docket Date Filing Party
10/4/2007  DEW - Disposition Of Exhibit Worksheet  10/9/2007   
8/3/2007  LED - 2.8 (d) Letter  8/9/2007   
12/20/2006  ODI - Order Of Dismissal  12/22/2006   
NOTE: WITH PREJUDICE 
11/20/2006  078 - ME: Case On Dismissal Calendar  11/20/2006   
11/17/2006  SFD - Stipulation For Dismissal  11/28/2006   
NOTE: WITH PREJUDICE 
11/17/2006  NOS - Notice Of Settlement  11/28/2006   
11/2/2006  ORD - Order  11/8/2006   
NOTE: AUTHORIZING ADDITIONAL TIME FOR FILING OF NOTICE OF ACCEPTANCE OF REMITTITUR 
10/30/2006  STP - Stipulation  11/6/2006   
NOTE: FOR ADDITIONAL TIME FOR FILING OF NOTICE OF ACCEPTANCE OF REMITTITUR 
10/23/2006  025 - ME: Case Status Minute Entry  10/23/2006   
10/23/2006  ORD - Order  10/30/2006   
NOTE: MINUTE ENTRY NOTICE AND / 
10/19/2006  019 - ME: Ruling  10/19/2006   
10/16/2006  005 - ME: Hearing  10/16/2006   
10/16/2006  088 - ME: Case Transferred  10/16/2006   
10/13/2006  NOF - Notice Of Filing  10/20/2006   
NOTE: SUPPLEMENTAL EXHIBIT REGARDING OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR REMITERATUR 
10/10/2006  RES - Response  10/11/2006   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR RELIEF FROM JUDGMENT ON THE COURTS COMPARATIVE FAULT RULING PURSUANT TO RULES 60C1 AND C6 AND ALTERNATIVELY MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION PURSUANT TO RULES 7/12 AND 59 
10/10/2006  REL - Reply  10/11/2006   
NOTE: ERRATA TO DEFENDANTS/ IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS RENEWED MOTION FOR JUDGMENT AS A MATTER OF LAW OR ALTERNATIVELY MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL OR ALTERNATIVELY FOR REMITTITUR 
10/10/2006  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  10/11/2006   
NOTE: 1. TO PLAINTIFFS STATEMENT OF COSTS AND 2 OBJECTION TO FORM OF JUDGMENT 
10/5/2006  019 - ME: Ruling  10/5/2006   
10/5/2006  MOT - Motion  10/10/2006   
NOTE: DEFENDANTS' FOR CLARIFICATION REGARDING JUDGMENT AND RELIEF FROM JDUGMETN IN REGARD TO UNSERVED OR NON-EXISTENT PARTIES PURSUANT TO RULE 60 
10/2/2006  REL - Reply  10/3/2006   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS RENEWED MOTION FOR JUDGMENT AS A MATTER OF LAW OR ALTERNATIVELY MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL OR ALTERNATIVELY FOR REMITTITUR 
9/27/2006  MOT - Motion  9/29/2006   
NOTE: FOR RELIEF FROM JUDGMENT ON THE COURT'S COMPARATIVE FAULT RULING PURSUANT TO RULES 60(C)(1) AND (C)(6) ALTERNATIVELY, MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION PURSUANT TO RULES 7.1 AND 59 
9/21/2006  025 - ME: Case Status Minute Entry  9/21/2006   
9/20/2006  019 - ME: Ruling  9/20/2006   
9/19/2006  SJU - Satisfaction Of Judgment  9/19/2006   
9/18/2006  RES - Response  9/21/2006   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' RENEWED MOTION FOR JUDGMENT AS A MATTER OF LAW OR ALTERNATIVELY MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL OR ALTERNATIVELY FOR REMITTUTUR 
9/15/2006  MOT - Motion  9/20/2006   
NOTE: DEFENDANT'S EXPEDITED FOR STAY OF EXECUTION OF JUDGMENT 
9/15/2006  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  9/15/2006   
9/15/2006  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  9/15/2006   
9/15/2006  019 - ME: Ruling  9/15/2006   
9/13/2006  JUD - Judgment  9/19/2006   
NOTE: Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties 
9/8/2006  MOT - Motion  9/13/2006   
NOTE: FOR IN-PERSON ORAL ARGUMENT 
9/7/2006  020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement  9/7/2006   
8/30/2006  MCO - Motion To Continue  9/1/2006   
NOTE: COURT'S ORAL ARGUMENT HEARING REGARDING POST-TRIAL MATTERS 
8/30/2006  MOT - Motion  9/1/2006   
NOTE: DEFENDANTS' RENEWED FOR JUDGMENT AS A MATTER OF LAW OR ALTERNATIVELY MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL OR ALTERNATIVELY FOR REMITTITUR 
8/18/2006  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  8/18/2006   
8/15/2006  RES - Response  8/17/2006   
NOTE: MAYO CLINIC'S/ TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR JUDGMENT AFTER TRIAL AS TO THE AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE OF COMPARATIVE NEGLIGENCE 
8/10/2006  ORD - Order  8/14/2006   
NOTE: DENYING MAYO CLINIC TO EXCEED THE PAGE LIMIT FOR THEIR MOTION FOR RENEWED JUDGMENT AS A MATTER OF LAW MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL OR ALTERNATIVELY REMITTITUR 
8/8/2006  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  8/11/2006   
NOTE: TO MOTION FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT AND OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS PROPOSED JUDGMENT 
8/8/2006  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  8/11/2006   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS STATEMENT OF COSTS 
8/4/2006  MOT - Motion  8/9/2006   
NOTE: EXPEDITED/ TO EXCEED PAGE LIMIT FOR RENEWED MOTION FOR JUDGMENT AS A MATTER OF LAW, OR ALTERNATIVELY, MOTION FOR NEW TRIAL, OR ALTERNATIVELY, FOR REMITTITUR 
8/2/2006  SOC - Statement Of Costs  8/9/2006   
8/2/2006  NOT - Notice  8/9/2006   
NOTE: OF SUBMISSION OF ALTERNATE FORM OF JUDGMENT 
8/2/2006  MOT - Motion  8/9/2006   
NOTE: RENEWAL OF MOTION FOR JUDGMENT AGAINST TRIAL AS TO THE AFFIRMATIVE DEFENSE OF COMPARATIVE NEGLIGENCE 
7/28/2006  MOT - Motion  8/2/2006   
NOTE: FOR STAY PROCEEDINGS ON JUDGMENT 
7/26/2006  012 - ME: Trial  7/26/2006   
7/25/2006  MOT - Motion  8/2/2006   
NOTE: FOR RULE 68D REMEDIES CONCERNING DEFENDANTS REJECTION OF PLAINTIFFS OFFER OF JUDGMENT AND SUBSEQUENT VERDICT AT TRIAL 
7/25/2006  RES - Response  7/31/2006   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO STAY PROCEEDINGS ON JUDGMENT 
7/21/2006  012 - ME: Trial  7/21/2006   
7/21/2006  012 - ME: Trial  7/21/2006   
7/20/2006  085 - ME: Conference  7/20/2006   
7/20/2006  012 - ME: Trial  7/20/2006   
7/20/2006  REQ - Request  7/24/2006   
NOTE: PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL/ FOR MODIFIED JURY INSTRUCTION 
7/20/2006  REQ - Request  7/24/2006   
NOTE: SUPPLEMENTAL JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND FORM OF SPECIAL VERDICT 
7/20/2006  JNO - Jury Note  7/26/2006   
7/20/2006  JNO - Jury Note  7/26/2006   
7/20/2006  JNO - Jury Note  7/26/2006   
7/20/2006  JNO - Jury Note  7/26/2006   
7/20/2006  VER - Verdict  7/26/2006   
NOTE: UNSIGNED 
7/20/2006  VER - Verdict  7/26/2006   
NOTE: SIGNED 
7/20/2006  WSH - Worksheet  7/26/2006   
NOTE: TRIAL - HEARING 
7/20/2006  JJF - Judgment For Jury Fees  8/2/2006   
NOTE: Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties 
7/20/2006  EXW - Exhibits Work Sheet  8/18/2006   
7/19/2006  JIN - Jury Instructions  7/26/2006   
NOTE: FINAL 
7/19/2006  JNO - Jury Note  7/26/2006   
7/19/2006  JQU - Jury Question  7/26/2006   
7/19/2006  MEM - Memorandum  7/24/2006   
NOTE: SUPPLEMENTAL/ OF LAW REGARDING SCOPE OF PLAINTIFFS REBUTTAL 
7/19/2006  MOT - Motion  7/26/2006   
NOTE: TO ORDER DEFENDANTS TO REFRAIN FROM IMPROPER ARGUMENT 
7/18/2006  RES - Response  7/21/2006   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS JULY 17, 2006 TRIAL MEMORANDUM AND SUBMISSION OF TRANSCRIPT TESTIMONY 
7/18/2006  RES - Response  7/21/2006   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL REQUESTED JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND FORM OF SPECIAL VERDICT 
7/18/2006  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  7/21/2006   
NOTE: DEFENDANT MAYO CLINIC ARIZONAS/ TO PLAINTIFFS SUPPLEMENTAL REQUEST FOR MODIFIED JURY INSTRUCTION 
7/18/2006  012 - ME: Trial  7/18/2006   
7/17/2006  NOT - Notice  7/19/2006   
NOTE: SUBMISSON OF TRANSCRIPT TESTIMONY NECESSARY FOR REVIEW BY THE COURT FOR ADJUDICATION OF PLAINTIFFS ANTICIPATED CHALLENGES TO EXPERT TESTIMONY ON BASIS OF FOUNDATION AND NON-DISCLOSURE AND TRIAL MEMORANDUM 
7/17/2006  NOT - Notice  7/19/2006   
NOTE: OF SUBMISSION OF ADDITIONAL TRIAL EXHIBIT #192 
7/17/2006  MOT - Motion  7/19/2006   
NOTE: FOR JUDGMENT AS A MATTER OF LAW 
7/17/2006  MOT - Motion  7/19/2006   
NOTE: FOR ORDER PRECLUDING COMMENT ON EXTRANEOUS MATTERS NOT RECEIVED INTO EVIDENCE;AND SUPPLEMENTAL PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS 
7/13/2006  022 - ME: Order Signed  7/13/2006   
7/12/2006  012 - ME: Trial  7/12/2006   
7/12/2006  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  7/17/2006   
NOTE: & MOTION TO QUASH PLAS SUBPOENA TO DEFENSE EXPERT DR DUGEL 
7/12/2006  MOT - Motion  7/17/2006   
NOTE: TO PRECLUDE DEFS FROM OFFERING EVIDENCE OF TIME OF ALTERATION OF EXHIBIT 2 MEDICAL RECORD FOR REASON OF NON DISCLOSURE & LACK OF FOUNDATION 
7/12/2006  MOT - Motion  7/17/2006   
NOTE: TO STRIKE & OR DEEM WAIVED DEFS UNTIMELY OBJECTIONS TO PLAS DEPOSITION TESTIMONY SET FORTH BY PAGE & LINE REFERENCE IN THE JOINT PRETRIAL STATEMENT FILED BY THE PARTIES ON 8-17-05 
7/12/2006  RES - Response  7/17/2006   
NOTE: TO DEFS OBJECTION & MOTION TO QUASH PLAS SUBPOENA TO DEFENSE EXPERT DR DUGEL 
7/12/2006  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  7/17/2006   
NOTE: TO DEFS DESIGNATION OF DEPOSITION TESTIMONY NON DISCLOSURE & UNFAIR SUPRISE 
7/7/2006  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  7/13/2006   
NOTE: TO PLAS PAGE LINE DESIGNATIONS 
7/5/2006  LET - Letter  7/26/2006   
7/5/2006  JQU - Jury Question  7/26/2006   
7/5/2006  JQU - Jury Question  7/26/2006   
7/3/2006  012 - ME: Trial  7/3/2006   
7/3/2006  012 - ME: Trial  7/3/2006   
6/30/2006  012 - ME: Trial  6/30/2006   
6/28/2006  012 - ME: Trial  6/28/2006   
6/28/2006  JQU - Jury Question  7/26/2006   
6/27/2006  JQU - Jury Question  7/26/2006   
6/27/2006  JQU - Jury Question  7/26/2006   
6/26/2006  JIN - Jury Instructions  7/26/2006   
6/26/2006  JUL - Jury List - Restricted if Filed after 1/1/2008  7/26/2006   
6/26/2006  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  6/30/2006   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S TO DEFENDANT'S EXHIBITS 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF DEBBI JASKOWSKI BY TERI L HOSKINS ON 07/08/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: VIDEOCONFERENCE/ OF SUZANNE M DODSON BY CAROLINE L MILLER ON 12/23/06 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: VIDEOTAPED/ OF DAVID REDFORD LILJENQUIST MD BY JENNIFER PANCRATZ ON 07/27/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF DR JOHN CREASMAN BY BRENDA J BROWN ON 03/12/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF PRAVIN U DUGEL MD BY CAROLE A WHIPPLE ON 09/15/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF DAVID W HANSON MD BY RACHELLE K YOUNG ON 03/26/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF JENNIFER LANG BY TERI L HOSKINS ON 07/14/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF PAUL J HUGHES BY JANE M DOYLE ON 02/18/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF THOMAS MCPHEE MD BY CAROLE A WHIPPLE ON 04/21/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: CONTINUED TELEPHONIC/ OF CHERI CHANDLER BY RACHELLE K YOUNG ON 07/06/04 VOLUME II 
6/26/2006  TSP - Transcript of Proceedings  8/8/2006   
NOTE: BY DENISE S COUVARAS ON 06/17/06 
6/26/2006  TSP - Transcript of Proceedings  8/8/2006   
NOTE: BY DENISE S COUVARAS ON 06/16/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF JOHN STROM BY JENNIFER PANCRATZ ON 07/22/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: VIDEOTAPED/ OF JOHN CUSTER BY TERI L HOSKINS ON 07/06/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF JUDY DECHANT BY GEORGE B FINN III ON 12/20/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF JULIE ABRAHAM BY TERI L HOSKINS ON 07/14/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF CHERI CHANDLER BY CAROLE A WHIPPLE ON 06/25/04 
6/26/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF ROBERTA HUGHES BY SOMMER E GREENE ON 06/24/04 
6/23/2006  021 - ME: Nunc Pro Tunc Order  6/23/2006   
6/23/2006  RES - Response  6/28/2006   
NOTE: PLAINTIFFS TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION OF DENIAL OF DEFENDANTS' MOTION IN LIMINE NO 12 
6/23/2006  MIL - Motion In Limine  6/28/2006   
6/23/2006  NOF - Notice Of Filing  6/28/2006   
NOTE: PLAINTIFFS' OF EXHIBITS RELEVANT TO COURTS' ADJUDICATION OF PENDING MOTIONS OF THE PLAINTIFF 
6/23/2006  MFR - Motion For Reconsideration  6/28/2006   
NOTE: OF GRANT OF SUMMARY JUDGMENT AS TO PLAINTIFFS' CLAIM FOR PUNITIVE DAMAGES 
6/23/2006  NOT - Notice  6/28/2006   
NOTE: OF INVOCATION OR RULE EXCLUDING WITNESSES 
6/23/2006  MOT - Motion  6/28/2006   
NOTE: EXPEDITED TO REQUIRE TESTIMONY OF FORMER COUNSEL AS MATERIAL FACT WITNESS 
6/23/2006  MOT - Motion  6/28/2006   
NOTE: EXPEDITED TO REQUIRE DEFENDANTS TO PROVIDE FULL DISCLOSURE CONCERNING MATERIAL WITNESS PAULA ASH OR THE NAME AND IDENTITY OF SAID PERSON USING AN ALIAS 
6/22/2006  RES - Response  6/28/2006   
NOTE: DEFENDANTS' TO PLAINTIFF'S EXPEDITED MOTION TO REQUIRE TESTIMONY OF DEFENSE COUNSEL 
6/22/2006  RES - Response  6/28/2006   
NOTE: DEFENDANTS' TO EXPEDITED MOTION TO REQUIRE DEFENDANTS TO PROVIDE FULL DISCLOSURE CONCERNING MATERIAL WITNESS PAULA ASH 
6/20/2006  027 - ME: Pretrial Conference  6/20/2006   
6/20/2006  MOT - Motion  6/22/2006   
NOTE: EXPEDITED TO REQUIRE DEFENDANTS TO PROVIDE FULL DISCLOSURE CONCERNING MATERIAL WITNESS PAULA ASH OR THE NAME AND IDENTITY OF SAID PERSON USING AN ALIAS 
6/20/2006  MOT - Motion  6/22/2006   
NOTE: EXPEDITED TO REQUIRE TESTIMONY OF FORMER COUNSEL AS MATERIAL FACT WITNESS 
6/19/2006  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  6/21/2006   
NOTE: OF PLAINTIFF'S CIVIL TRIAL SUBPOENA 
6/19/2006  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  6/21/2006   
NOTE: OF PLAINTIFF'S CIVIL TRIAL SUBPOENA 
6/19/2006  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  6/21/2006   
NOTE: OF PLAINTIFF'S CIVIL TRIAL SUBPOENA 
6/16/2006  MFR - Motion For Reconsideration  6/19/2006   
NOTE: DENIAL OF MOTION IN LIMINE NO 2 REGARDING PRECLUDING CRITICISMS AGAINST MAYO CLINIC EMPLOYERS 
6/16/2006  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  6/16/2006   
6/15/2006  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  6/19/2006   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS TRIAL EXHIBITS 
6/15/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF ANTHONY DEBEUS MD BY DOREEN M LOBOCK ON 01/27/04 
6/15/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF PAUL J PHILLIPS BY JANE M DOYLE ON 01/26/04 
6/15/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF J SHEPARD BRYAN III MD BY JANE M DOYLE ON 03/29/04 
6/15/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF LUWANNA T PHILLIPS BY MICHAELA H DAVIS ON 12/03/04 
6/15/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF JOHN MAGGIANO MD BY DARA C SCHULER ON 06/12/04 
6/15/2006  DPR - Deposition Report  8/8/2006   
NOTE: OF RICHARD G CARRIKER MD BY JANE M DOYLE ON 01/30/04 
6/13/2006  NOT - Notice  6/16/2006   
NOTE: TIME ESTIMATES FOR TRIAL 
6/13/2006  MOT - Motion  6/16/2006   
NOTE: TO REINSTATE PRETRIAL MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE OF IN THE ALTERNATIVE CONTINUE THE PRE-TRIAL MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE 
6/9/2006  MCO - Motion To Continue  6/12/2006   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S THE PRETRIAL MANAGEMENT CONFERENCE SET FOR JUNE 14 2006 AT 8:45 AM 
5/30/2006  RES - Response  6/1/2006   
NOTE: IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 12 RE DR MAGGIANO'S OPINIONS AND REQUEST FOR CONSIDERATION OF JUDGMENT AS A MATTER OF LAW 
5/30/2006  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  5/31/2006   
NOTE: OF PLAINTIFF'S CIVIL TRIAL SUBPONEA 
5/30/2006  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  5/31/2006   
NOTE: OF PLAINTIFF'S CIVIL TRIAL SUBPOENA 
5/30/2006  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  5/31/2006   
NOTE: OF PLAINTIFF'S CIVIL TRIAL SUBPOENA 
5/30/2006  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  5/31/2006   
NOTE: OF PLAINTIFF'S CIVIL TRIAL SUBPOENA 
5/30/2006  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  5/31/2006   
NOTE: OF PLAINTIFF'S CIVIL TRIAL SUBPOENA 
5/29/2006  085 - ME: Conference  5/29/2006   
5/17/2006  MIL - Motion In Limine  5/19/2006   
NOTE: DEFENDANT MAYO CLINIC ARIZONA'S NO 12 RE DR MAGGIANO'S OPINIONS AND REQUEST FOR CONSIDERATION OF JUDGMENT AS A MATTER OF LAW IF GRANTED 
5/16/2006  085 - ME: Conference  5/16/2006   
3/24/2006  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  3/24/2006   
2/23/2006  NOT - Notice  2/24/2006   
NOTE: OF TRIAL CONFLICT 
12/7/2005  ORD - Order  12/21/2005   
NOTE: STRIKING PLAINTIFF'S OFFER OF PROOF AND AMENDED DISCLOSURE STATEMENT ATTACHED THERETO 
11/29/2005  NOT - Notice  12/6/2005   
NOTE: OFFER OF JUDGMENT TO DEFENDANTS 
11/3/2005  MOT - Motion  11/8/2005   
NOTE: TO STRIKE PLAINTIFF'S OFFER OF PROOF IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT RELEVANT TO OCTOBER 20 2005 HEARING AND ATTACHED UNTIMELY AMENDED DISCLOSURE STATEMENT 
10/24/2005  089 - ME: Trial Setting  10/24/2005   
10/20/2005  NOT - Notice  10/26/2005   
NOTE: OFFER OF PROOF IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT RELEVANT TO OCTOBER 20,2005 HEARING 
8/30/2005  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  8/30/2005   
8/26/2005  REL - Reply  8/30/2005   
NOTE: DEFENDANT MAYO CLINIC ARIZONA'S IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION TO STRIKE AFFIDAVIT OF DR JOHN M MAGGIANO 
8/22/2005  028 - ME: Status Conference Set  8/22/2005   
8/17/2005  STA - Statement  8/22/2005   
NOTE: JOINT PRETRIAL 
8/16/2005  RES - Response  8/19/2005   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO STRIKE AFFIDAVIT OF DR JOHN M MAGGIANO 
8/15/2005  RES - Response  8/19/2005   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO STRIKE AFFIDAVIT OF DR JOHN M MAGGIANO 
8/4/2005  REL - Reply  8/11/2005   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF PAUL PHILLIPS' IN SUPPORT OF HIS MOTION TO STRIKE DEFENDANT'S UNTIMELY MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 
7/25/2005  RES - Response  7/29/2005   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO STRIKE DEFENDANTS UNTIMELY MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 
7/15/2005  019 - ME: Ruling  7/15/2005   
7/13/2005  RES - Response  7/20/2005   
NOTE: IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT (WITHOUT WAIVER OF PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO STRIKE UNTIMELY MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT) 
7/13/2005  MOT - Motion  7/20/2005   
NOTE: TO STRIKE DEFENDANTS UNTIMELY MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 
7/13/2005  SOF - Statement Of Facts  7/20/2005   
7/8/2005  MCC - Mot/Cont On Inactive Calendar  7/18/2005   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S 
6/28/2005  MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment  7/13/2005   
NOTE: DEFENDANT MAYO CLINIC ARIZONA'S RE CAUSATION 
6/28/2005  SOF - Statement Of Facts  7/13/2005   
NOTE: DEFENDANT MAYO CLINIC ARIZONA'S IN SUPPORT OF ITS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT RE CAUSATION 
6/21/2005  RES - Response  6/23/2005   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SANCTIONS, ATTORNEYS FEES AND TAXABLE COSTS (ORAL ARGUMENT REQUESTED) 
6/20/2005  RES - Response  6/24/2005   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS EXPEDITED MOTION TO RESTORE CASE TO ACTIVE CALENDAR UPON ANNOUNCEMENT OF READINESS FOR TRIAL; REQUEST FOR SETTING OF TRIAL; MOTION TO PERMIT CASE TO PROCEED IN ABSENCE OF JOINT PRETRIAL STATEMENT AND OR UPON PLAINTIFFS PROPOSED PRETRIAL STATEMENT; MOTION FOR FINAL PRETRIAL CONFERENCE AND FOR DISPOSITION OF PRETRIAL MOTIONS 
6/1/2005  MOT - Motion  6/7/2005   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S EXPEDITED TO RESTORE CASE TO ACTIVE CALENDER UPON ANNOUNCEMENT OF READINESS FOR TRIAL 
6/1/2005  MSE - Motion To Set & Cert/Readiness  6/13/2005   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S 
5/31/2005  MOT - Motion  6/7/2005   
NOTE: FOR TAXABLE COSTS 
5/9/2005  078 - ME: Case On Dismissal Calendar  5/9/2005   
3/24/2005  081 - ME: Trial Vacated  3/24/2005   
3/23/2005  STA - Statement  3/28/2005   
NOTE: JOINT PRETRIAL/ SUBMISSION 
3/18/2005  RES - Response  3/24/2005   
NOTE: TO PLAITNIFF'S MOTIONS IN LIMINE 
2/14/2005  REL - Reply  2/18/2005   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT 
2/14/2005  REL - Reply  2/18/2005   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION RE MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT RE PUNITIVE DAMAGES 
2/14/2005  REL - Reply  2/18/2005   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO STRIKE PLAINTIFF'S JOINT PRETRIAL STATEMENT 
2/8/2005  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  2/8/2005   
1/31/2005  SOF - Statement Of Facts  2/7/2005   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S SUBMITTTED IN OPPOSITION TO MAYO DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT 
1/31/2005  RES - Response  2/4/2005   
NOTE: IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT 
1/31/2005  RES - Response  2/4/2005   
NOTE: IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION REGARDING MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT REGARDING PUNITIVE DAMAGES 
1/31/2005  RES - Response  2/4/2005   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO STRIKE PLAINTIFFS JOINT PRETRIAL STATEMENT 
1/31/2005  NOT - Notice  2/4/2005   
NOTE: OF WITHDRAWAL OF PLAINTIFFS JOINT PRETRIAL STATEMENT 
1/12/2005  019 - ME: Ruling  1/12/2005   
1/10/2005  MOT - Motion  1/18/2005   
NOTE: FOR SUMMARY DISPOSITION REGARDING MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT REGARDING PUNITIVE DAMAGES 
1/10/2005  MOT - Motion  1/18/2005   
NOTE: TO STRIKE PLAINTIFFS JOINT PRETRIAL STATEMENT 
12/2/2004  OBJ - Objection/Opposition.  12/8/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S TO FIRST DISCOVERY ORDER OF SPECIAL MASTER 
11/23/2004  RES - Response  12/1/2004   
NOTE: TO MOTION TO COMPEL DEFENDANTS' RESPONSES TO PLAINTIFF'S DISCOVERY 
11/22/2004  ORD - Order  12/2/2004   
NOTE: FIRST DISCOVERY OF SPECIAL MASTER 
11/16/2004  MTC - Motion To Compel  11/23/2004   
NOTE: RESPONSES TO PLAINTIFFS UNIFORM INTERROGATORIES MOTION FOR HEARING UPON OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS UNIFORM INTERROGATORIES MOTION FOR SANCTIONS 
11/16/2004  MTC - Motion To Compel  11/23/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S/DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S DISCOVERY 
11/16/2004  CER - Certificate  11/24/2004   
NOTE: OF COUNSEL PURSUAN TO RULE 26(G) 
11/16/2004  REL - Reply  11/24/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S CONCERNING PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL EXPERT FILE OF DR CRAIG SUITER AS REQUIRED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SUBPOENA 
11/16/2004  REL - Reply  11/24/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S TO DEFENDANTS RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL COMPLETE AND SECOND SET OF MEDICAL RECORDS EXCHANGED BY DEFENDANTS PURSUANT TO RULE 26.2(A) 
11/16/2004  REL - Reply  11/24/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S CONCERNING PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL EXPERT FILE OF DR CRAIG SUITER AS REQUIRED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SUBPOENA 
11/15/2004  RES - Response  11/23/2004   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL COMPLETE AND 2ND SET OF MEDICAL RECORDS EXCHANGED BY DEFENDANTS 
11/8/2004  REL - Reply  11/18/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S TO DEFENDANTS' RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL DATE FOR EXAMINATION OF PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL MEDICAL RECORDS AND FILES 
11/8/2004  RES - Response  11/19/2004   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL EXPERT FILE OF DR CRAIG SUITER 
11/4/2004  064 - ME: Trial Continued/Reset  11/4/2004   
11/3/2004  REP - Report  11/16/2004   
NOTE: DISCOVERY 
10/29/2004  CER - Certificate  11/4/2004   
NOTE: OF COUNSEL IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL COMPLETE AND 2ND SET OF MEDICAL RECORDS 
10/29/2004  MTC - Motion To Compel  11/4/2004   
NOTE: COMPLETE AND 2ND SET OF MEDICAL RECORDS EXCHANGED BY DEFENDANTS 
10/27/2004  RES - Response  11/4/2004   
NOTE: TO PALINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL DEATE FOR EXAMINATION OF PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL MEDICAL RECORDS AND FILES 
10/21/2004  RES - Response  10/27/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO LIMINE NO 8 RE HANDWRITING EXPERT 
10/20/2004  NOT - Notice  11/5/2004   
NOTE: RULE 26(G) COMPLAINCE PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO COMPEL EXPERT FILE OF DR CRAIG SUITER AS REQUIRED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SUBPOENA SERVED 
10/20/2004  MTC - Motion To Compel  10/27/2004   
NOTE: EXPERT FILE OF DR CRAIG SUITER AS REQUIRED IN ACCORDANCE WITH SUBPOENA SERVED 
10/20/2004  RES - Response  10/28/2004   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 1 RE PAUL HUGHES TRAFFIC VIOLATIONS 
10/20/2004  RES - Response  10/28/2004   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 2 RE PRECLUDING CRITICISMS AGAINST ANY MAYO CLINIC EMPLOYEES 
10/20/2004  RES - Response  10/28/2004   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 9 RE BUILDING AND CODING 
10/20/2004  RES - Response  10/28/2004   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 10 TO PRECLUDE REFERENCE TO UNSUBSTANTIATED ALLEGATIONS 
10/20/2004  RES - Response  10/28/2004   
NOTE: DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 7 RE SPECULATION OF DR MCPHEE 
10/20/2004  RES - Response  10/28/2004   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 6 RE DR SUITER 
10/20/2004  RES - Response  10/28/2004   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 5 RE FINANCIAL STATUS OF THE DEPARTMENT OF OPTHAMOLOGY 
10/20/2004  RES - Response  10/28/2004   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 4 RE OPINIONS OF SUBSEQUENT TREATING PHYSICIANS 
10/20/2004  RES - Response  10/28/2004   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 3 TO PRECLUDE ALL NON QUALIFIED WITNESSES FROM SPECULATING AS TO STANDARD OF CARE OR CAUSATION ISSUES 
10/20/2004  RES - Response  10/28/2004   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION IN LIMINE NO 11 RE SIZE OF LAW FIRM 
10/7/2004  MTC - Motion To Compel  10/20/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S DATE FOR EXAMINATION OF PLAINTIFF'S ORIGINAL MEDICAL RECORDS AND FILES 
10/7/2004  CER - Certificate  10/18/2004   
NOTE: OF COUNSEL IN SUPPORT OF PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL DATE FOR EXAMINATION OF PLAINTIFFS ORIGINAL MEDICAL RECORDS AND FILES 
10/6/2004  081 - ME: Trial Vacated  10/6/2004   
10/5/2004  REQ - Request  10/12/2004   
NOTE: SUGGESTED VOIR DIRE QUESTION 
10/5/2004  STA - Statement  10/12/2004   
NOTE: PRETRIAL/ 
10/5/2004  REQ - Request  10/12/2004   
NOTE: PROPOSED VOIR DIRE 
10/5/2004  REQ - Request  10/12/2004   
NOTE: PROPOSED JURY INSTRUCTIONS 
10/5/2004  MIL - Motion In Limine  10/12/2004   
NOTE: NUMBER 11 REGARDING SIZE OF LAW FIRM 
10/5/2004  MIL - Motion In Limine  10/12/2004   
NOTE: NUMBER 10 TO PRECLUDE REFERENCE TO USUBSTANTIATED ALLEGATIONS 
10/5/2004  MIL - Motion In Limine  10/12/2004   
NOTE: NUMBER 9 REGARDING BILLING AND CODING 
10/5/2004  MIL - Motion In Limine  10/12/2004   
NOTE: NUMBER 8 REGARDING HANDWRITING EXPERT 
10/5/2004  MIL - Motion In Limine  10/12/2004   
NOTE: NUMBER 7 REGARDING SPECULATION OF DR MCPHEE 
10/5/2004  MIL - Motion In Limine  10/12/2004   
NOTE: NUMBER 6 REGARDING DR SUITER 
10/5/2004  MIL - Motion In Limine  10/12/2004   
NOTE: NUMBER 5 REGARDING FINANCIAL STATUS FO THE DEPARTMENT OF OPTHAMOLOGY 
10/5/2004  MIL - Motion In Limine  10/12/2004   
NOTE: NUMBER 4 REGARDING OPINIONS OF SUBSEQUENT TREATING PHYSICIANS 
10/5/2004  MIL - Motion In Limine  10/12/2004   
NOTE: NUMBER 3 TO PRECLUDE ALL NON QUALIFIED WITNESSES FROM SPECULATING AS TO STANDARD OF CARE OF CAUSATION ISSUES 
10/5/2004  MIL - Motion In Limine  10/12/2004   
NOTE: NO 2 RE PRECLUDING CRITICISMS AGAINST ANY MAYO CLINIC EMPLOYEES 
10/5/2004  MIL - Motion In Limine  10/12/2004   
NOTE: NO 1 RE PAUL HUGHES TRAFFIC VIOLATIONS 
10/4/2004  REQ - Request  10/8/2004   
NOTE: JURY INSTRUCTIONS AND PROPOSED VERDICT FORM 
10/4/2004  MIL - Motion In Limine  10/8/2004   
10/1/2004  RES - Response  10/12/2004   
NOTE: TO PLAITNIFFS EXPEDITED MOTION FOR EXTENSION OF SCHEDULING ORDER DEADLINES AND RESPONSE TO PLAITNIFFS MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE OF PRE TRIAL CONFERENCE AND TRIAL 
9/30/2004  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  9/30/2004   
9/29/2004  MOT - Motion  10/1/2004   
NOTE: EXPEDITED/ FOR EXTENSION OF SCHEDULING ORDER DEADLINES MOTION FOR CONTINUANCE OF PRETRIAL CONFERENCE AND TRIAL 
9/29/2004  REQ - Request  10/7/2004   
NOTE: EXPEDITED PLAINTIFF'S FOR EXPEDITED HEARING ON PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO EXTEND SCHEDULING ORDRE DEADLINES 
9/16/2004  NOT - Notice  9/22/2004   
NOTE: PROPOSED DISCOVERY SPECIAL MASTERS 
9/2/2004  RES - Response  9/8/2004   
NOTE: DEFENDANTS' TO MOTION FOR ADDITIONAL TIME FOR WITNESS JOHN MAGGIANO MD TO READ AND SIGN DEPOSITION 
9/2/2004  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  9/2/2004   
9/1/2004  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  9/1/2004   
8/27/2004  NOT - Notice  9/1/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S FIRST AMENDED OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
8/26/2004  MOT - Motion  8/31/2004   
NOTE: FOR ADDITIONAL TIME FOR WITNESS JOHN MAGGIANO MD TO READ AND SIGN DEPOSITION 
8/24/2004  REL - Reply  8/27/2004   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF ITS SECOND MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER AND RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO STRIKE 
8/23/2004  RES - Response  8/26/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S TO DEFENDANTS' THIRD MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 
8/20/2004  MOT - Motion  8/26/2004   
NOTE: DEFENDANT'S THIRD FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 
8/19/2004  NOT - Notice  8/31/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DISCOVERY TO DEFENDANTS 
8/19/2004  NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure  8/31/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S EIGHTH SUPPLEMENTAL 
8/19/2004  NOT - Notice  8/31/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S OF COMPLIANCE WITH COURT'S MINUTE ENTRY OF AUGUST 3 2004 
8/13/2004  NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure  8/19/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S SEVENTH SUPPLEMENTAL 
8/12/2004  RES - Response  8/18/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S TO DEFENDANTS' SECOND MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO STRIKE 
8/12/2004  NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure  7/19/2005   
NOTE: PLAINTIFF'S SIXTH SUPPLEMENTAL 
8/5/2004  019 - ME: Ruling  8/5/2004   
8/3/2004  NOT - Notice  8/5/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
8/3/2004  005 - ME: Hearing  8/3/2004   
7/29/2004  MOT - Motion  8/4/2004   
NOTE: SECOND/ FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 
7/26/2004  REL - Reply  7/28/2004   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF EXPERT WITNESS CRAIG SUITER MD AND PETITION TO DESIGNATE ANOTHER STANDARD OF CARE EXPERT WITNESS 
7/19/2004  ORD - Order  7/22/2004   
NOTE: DENYING PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO EXCEED THE PAGE LIMITATION 
7/15/2004  RES - Response  7/23/2004   
NOTE: AND OBJECTION TO DEFENDANTS NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF EXPERT WITNESS DR CRAIG SUITER AND PETITION TO DESIGNATE ANOTHER STANDARD OF CARE EXPERT WITNESS 
7/15/2004  019 - ME: Ruling  7/15/2004   
7/13/2004  ORD - Order  7/19/2004   
NOTE: RESOLVING DEFENDANTS EXPEDITED MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 
7/12/2004  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  7/12/2004   
7/7/2004  CER - Certificate  7/13/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFFS/ OF ATTEMPTED RESOLUTION 
7/7/2004  RQH - Request For Hearing  7/13/2004   
NOTE: EXPEDITED, ON PLAINTIFFS MOTION TO COMPEL DISCLOSURES; MOTION TO COMPEL RESPONSES TO UNIFORM INTERROGATORIES; HEARING UPON OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS UNIFORM INTERROGATORIES AND MOTION FOR SANCTIONS 
7/7/2004  MOT - Motion  7/14/2004   
NOTE: FOR LEAVE TO EXCEED PAGE LIMIT REGARDING PLAINTIFFS COMPEL DISCLOSURES; MOTION TO COMPEL RESPONSES TO UNIFORM INTERROGATORIES; HEARING UPON OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS UNIFORM INTERROGATORIES AND MOTION FOR SANCTIONS 
7/7/2004  MTC - Motion To Compel  7/15/2004   
NOTE: MANDATORY DISCLOSURES; MOTION TO COMPEL RESPONSES TO PLAINTIFFS UNIFORM INTERROGATORIES; MOTION FOR HEARING UPON OBJECTIONS TO PLAINTIFFS UNIFORM INTERROGATORIES; AND MOTION FOR SANCTIONS 
7/6/2004  REL - Reply  7/12/2004   
NOTE: TO MAYO DEFENDANTS RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT AND PLAINTIFFS ALTERNATIVE MOTION TO PERMIT FURTHER AMENDMENT TO COMPLAINT TO CONFORM TO COURT RULINGS 
7/1/2004  NOT - Notice  7/8/2004   
NOTE: OF WITHDRAWAL OF EXPERT WITNESS CRAIG SUITER MD AND PETITION TO DESIGNATE ANOTHER STANDARD OF CARE EXPERT WITNESS 
7/1/2004  MOT - Motion  7/8/2004   
NOTE: FOR EXPEDITED HEARING RE NOTICE OF WITHDRAWAL OF EXPERT WITNESS CRAIG SUITER MD AND PETITION TO DESIGNATE ANOTHER STANDARD OF CARE EXPERT 
6/28/2004  REL - Reply  7/1/2004   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO STRIKE TESTIMONY OF EXPERT AND RESPONSE TO ALTERNATIVE MOTION TO DEFER ADJUDICATION OF MOTION TO STRIKE 
6/28/2004  REL - Reply  7/1/2004   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO STRIKE TESTIMONY OF EXPERTS AND RESPONSE TO ALTERNATIVE MOTION TO DEFER ADJUDICATION OF MOTION TO STRIKE 
6/25/2004  NOT - Notice  7/7/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
6/24/2004  023 - ME: Order Entered By Court  6/24/2004   
6/21/2004  005 - ME: Hearing  6/21/2004   
6/21/2004  RES - Response  8/10/2011   
NOTE: TO MOTION FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT 
6/18/2004  004 - ME: Hearing Continued  6/18/2004   
6/16/2004  005 - ME: Hearing  6/16/2004   
6/16/2004  RES - Response  6/23/2004   
NOTE: IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO STRIKE AND ALTERNATIVE MOTION TO DEFER ADJUDICATION OF MOTION TO STRIKE 
6/16/2004  RES - Response  6/23/2004   
NOTE: IN OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO STRIKE AND ALTERNATIVE MOTION TO DEFER ADJUDICATION OF MOTION TO STRIKE 
6/16/2004  MOT - Motion  6/22/2004   
NOTE: FOR EXPEDITED RULING RE: RESCHEDULING OF DEPOSITIONS IN FOLLOW-UP TO RULING ON MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 
6/10/2004  RES - Response  6/17/2004   
NOTE: TO MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 
6/8/2004  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  6/8/2004   
6/8/2004  ORD - Order  6/11/2004   
NOTE: GRANTING DEFENDANTS MOTION TO EXCEED THE PAGE LIMITATION 
6/8/2004  ORD - Order  6/11/2004   
NOTE: GRANTING DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR EXPEDITED HEARING REGARDING PROTECTIVE ORDER 
6/2/2004  MOT - Motion  6/4/2004   
NOTE: FOR EXPEDITED HEARING REGARDING MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 
6/2/2004  MOT - Motion  6/4/2004   
NOTE: TO STRIKE TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFFS EXPERT WILLIAM J FLYNN 
6/2/2004  MOT - Motion  6/4/2004   
NOTE: TO STRIKE TESTIMONY OF PLAINTIFFS EXPERTS CHRISTINA MELNYKOVYCH AND CHAROL SPAULDING 
6/2/2004  MOT - Motion  6/4/2004   
NOTE: TO EXCEED PAGE LIMIT FOR MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 
6/2/2004  MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment  6/4/2004   
NOTE: PARTIAL/ REGARDING PUNITIVE DAMAGES 
6/2/2004  REQ - Request  6/7/2004   
NOTE: RULE 16/ FOR STATUS CONFERENCE 
6/2/2004  SOF - Statement Of Facts  6/7/2004   
NOTE: IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT REGARDING PUNITIVE DAMAGES 
6/2/2004  CER - Certificate  6/7/2004   
NOTE: OF COUNSEL PURSUANT TO RULE 26(G) IN SUPPORT OF MAYOS MOTION FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 
6/2/2004  MOT - Motion  6/7/2004   
NOTE: FOR LEAVE TO FILE AMENDED COMPLAINT 
6/2/2004  NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure  6/7/2004   
NOTE: FIFTH SUPPLEMENTAL 
6/2/2004  MOT - Motion  6/14/2004   
NOTE: FOR PROTECTIVE ORDER 
5/28/2004  NOT - Notice  6/9/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
5/28/2004  NDE - Notice Of Deposition  6/9/2004   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANT 
5/28/2004  NOT - Notice  6/9/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
5/28/2004  NOT - Notice  6/9/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
5/28/2004  NOT - Notice  6/9/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
5/28/2004  NOT - Notice  6/9/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
5/18/2004  NOT - Notice  5/24/2004   
NOTE: OF DEPOSITION TO DEFENDANT 
5/18/2004  NOT - Notice  5/24/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
5/18/2004  NOT - Notice  5/24/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
5/18/2004  NOT - Notice  5/24/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
5/18/2004  NOT - Notice  5/24/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
5/18/2004  NOT - Notice  5/24/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
5/13/2004  APL - Application  5/18/2004   
NOTE: FOR COMMISSION TO TAKE FOREIGN DEPOSITION 
5/7/2004  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  5/7/2004   
4/12/2004  NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure  4/23/2004   
NOTE: FOURTH SUPPLEMENTAL 
4/6/2004  NOT - Notice  4/14/2004   
NOTE: PLAINTIFFS OFFER OF JUDGMENT TO DEFENDANTS 
4/1/2004  NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure  4/14/2004   
NOTE: 3RD SUPPLEMENTAL 
4/1/2004  NOT - Notice  4/14/2004   
NOTE: 3RD AMENDED/OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION VIDEO TAPED AND AUDIO TAPED DEPOSITION 
3/30/2004  APL - Application  4/8/2004   
NOTE: FOR COMMISSION TO TAKE FOREIGN DEPOSITION 
3/23/2004  RES - Response  4/9/2004   
NOTE: 1ST SUPPLEMENTAL/TO REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF DOCUMENTS 
3/19/2004  NOT - Notice  4/7/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF FIRST SUPPLEMENTAL INTERROGATORIES 
3/17/2004  NOT - Notice  4/14/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF SUBPOENA DUCES TECUM TO DEPOSITION 
3/12/2004  089 - ME: Trial Setting  3/12/2004   
3/11/2004  NOT - Notice  4/7/2004   
NOTE: 3RD AMENDED/OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
3/9/2004  083 - ME: Conference Reset/Cont  3/9/2004   
3/5/2004  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  3/5/2004   
3/1/2004  RES - Response  4/8/2004   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFFS PAUL J PHILLIPS EXPEDITED EMERGENCY EX PARTE MOTION TO TAKE POSSESSION OF THE MEDICAL RECORDS FOR DELIVERY TO THE CLERK OF THE SUPERIOR COURT FOR PRESERVATION OF MATERIAL EVIDENCE 
3/1/2004  RES - Response  4/14/2004   
NOTE: ERRATA TO DEFENDANTS/TO PLAINTIFFS PAUL J PHILLIPS EXPEDITED EMERGENCY EX PARTE MOTION TO TAKE POSSESSION OF THE MEDICAL RECORDS FOR DELIVERY TO THE CLERK OF THE SUPERIOR COURT FOR PRESERVATION OF MATERIAL EVIDENCE 
2/25/2004  MOT - Motion  4/14/2004   
NOTE: EX PARTE/TO TAKE POSSESSION OF THE MEDICAL RECORDS FOR DELIVERY TO THE CLERK OF THE SUPERIOR COURT FOR PRESERVATION OF MATERIAL EVIDENCE 
2/20/2004  NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure  4/14/2004   
NOTE: 2ND SUPPLEMENTAL 
2/20/2004  NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure  4/14/2004   
NOTE: 2ND SUPPLEMENTAL 
2/20/2004  NOT - Notice  4/14/2004   
NOTE: 2ND AMENDED/OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION VIDEO TAPED AND AUDIO TAPED DEPOSITION 
2/2/2004  ORD - Order  4/7/2004   
NOTE: ON STIPULATION TO CONTINUE EXPERT DISCLOSURE DEADLINE 
1/30/2004  NOT - Notice  4/14/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
1/30/2004  NOT - Notice  4/14/2004   
NOTE: 1ST AMENDED/OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
1/30/2004  NOT - Notice  4/14/2004   
NOTE: 1ST AMENDED/OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
1/30/2004  NOT - Notice  4/14/2004   
NOTE: 1ST AMENDED/OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
1/27/2004  SFC - Stipulation For Continuance  4/14/2004   
NOTE: EXPERT DISCLOSURE DEADLINE 
12/9/2003  NOT - Notice  3/5/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
12/9/2003  NOT - Notice  3/5/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
12/9/2003  NOT - Notice  3/5/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
12/9/2003  NOT - Notice  4/8/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
12/9/2003  NOT - Notice  4/8/2004   
NOTE: OF SERVICE OF DEPOSITION 
11/27/2003  029 - ME: Status Conference  11/27/2003   
11/20/2003  MEM - Memorandum  12/5/2003   
NOTE: JOINT COMPREHENSIVE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE 
11/10/2003  NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure  11/20/2003   
NOTE: INITIAL 
11/10/2003  NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure  11/20/2003   
NOTE: 1ST SUPPLEMENTAL 
11/4/2003  041 - ME: Scheduling Conference Set  11/4/2003   
9/23/2003  005 - ME: Hearing  9/23/2003   
8/22/2003  REL - Reply  1/20/2004   
NOTE: TO PLAINTIFF'S RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS' MOTION TO STRIKE COMPLAINT 
8/20/2003  311 - ME: 150 Day Minute Entry  8/20/2003   
8/13/2003  094 - ME: Oral Argument Set  8/13/2003   
8/12/2003  RES - Response  10/8/2003   
NOTE: TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO STRIKE COMPLAINT PLAINTIFF'S ALTERNATIVE MOTION FOR LEAVE TO AMEND PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT SHOULD MOTION TO STRIKE BE GRANTED 
8/5/2003  MOT - Motion  8/25/2003   
NOTE: TO STRIKE COMPLAINT 
8/1/2003  NOT - Notice  12/3/2003   
NOTE: OF EXCHANGE OF MEDICAL RECORDS 
8/1/2003  NOT - Notice  12/3/2003   
NOTE: OF EXCHANGE OF MEDICAL RECORDS 
7/28/2003  REQ - Request  2/6/2004   
NOTE: FOR COMPREHENSIVE PRETRIAL CONFERENCE 
7/23/2003  CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject  10/29/2003   
7/23/2003  ANS - Answer  7/31/2003   
NOTE: PAID 
7/7/2003  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  7/15/2003   
NOTE: MAYO REGIONAL PRACTICES ARIZONA SERVED SERVED 07/03/03 
7/7/2003  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  7/15/2003   
NOTE: MAYO CLINIC HOSPITAL SERVED 07/03/03 
7/7/2003  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  7/15/2003   
NOTE: MAYO REGIONAL PRACTICES ARIZONA SERVED 07/03/03 
7/7/2003  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  7/15/2003   
NOTE: MAYO HEALTH PLAN ARIZONA SERVED 07/03/03 
7/7/2003  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  7/15/2003   
NOTE: MAYO CLINIC SCOTTSDALE SERVED 07/03/03 
7/7/2003  AFS - Affidavit Of Service  7/15/2003   
NOTE: MAYO CLINIC ARIZONA SERVED 07/03/03 
7/7/2003  SUM - Summons  11/25/2003   
6/18/2003  322 - ME: Notice Of Intent To Dismiss  6/18/2003   
3/21/2003  NJT - Not Demand For Jury Trials  9/19/2003   
3/13/2003  COM - Complaint  3/18/2003   
3/13/2003  CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject  3/18/2003   
Case Calendar
Date Time Event
9/19/2003  9:45  Oral Argument 
11/25/2003  9:00  Pre-Trial Conference 
3/10/2004  8:30  Oral Argument 
3/22/2004  8:30  Pre-Trial Conference 
6/15/2004  9:30  Oral Argument 
6/16/2004  16:30  Emergency Hearing 
6/17/2004  14:30  Emergency Hearing 
7/30/2004  10:30  Oral Argument 
10/8/2004  9:45  Pre-Trial Conference 
10/22/2004  8:45  Pre-Trial Conference 
11/1/2004  9:15  Pre-Trial Conference 
11/1/2004  9:30  Trial 
3/25/2005  9:00  Pre-Trial Conference 
4/18/2005  9:30  Trial 
10/20/2005  8:45  Oral Argument 
5/12/2006  14:30  Pre-Trial Conference 
5/26/2006  8:45  Pre-Trial Conference 
6/14/2006  8:45  Pre-Trial Conference 
6/15/2006  14:30  Pre-Trial Conference 
6/16/2006  10:00  Pre-Trial Conference 
6/26/2006  9:30  Trial 
6/27/2006  9:30  Trial 
6/28/2006  9:30  Trial 
6/29/2006  9:30  Trial 
7/5/2006  9:00  Trial 
7/13/2006  9:30  Trial 
7/17/2006  9:30  Trial 
7/18/2006  9:30  Trial 
7/19/2006  9:30  Trial 
7/20/2006  9:30  Trial 
9/6/2006  9:00  Oral Argument 
9/14/2006  10:00  Pre-Trial Conference 
9/18/2006  10:00  Oral Argument 
10/13/2006  8:45  Oral Argument 
11/2/2006  9:00  Status Conference 
11/17/2006  11:30  Status Conference 
Judgments
Date (F)or / (A)gainst Amount Frequency Type Status
9/13/2006  F:Paul J Phillips  $3,500,000.00  One Time  Principal   
  A: Mayo Clinic Arizona         
  A: Mayo Clinic Scottsdale         
  A: Mayo Foundation         
  A: Mayo Clinic Hospital         
  A: Mayo Clinics In Our Care         
  A: Mayo Regional Practices Arizona         
  A: Mayo Foundation For Medical Education And Research         
  A: Mayo Health Plan Arizona         
  A: Mayo Management Services Inc         
  A: Mayo Healthcare Network         
7/20/2006  F:Maricopa County Creditor  $2,166.00  One Time  Judgment for Jury Fees  Satisfied 
  A: Mayo Clinic Arizona