Civil Court Case Information - Case History

« Return to search results

Case Information

Case Number:

CV2002-012583

Judge:

Pineda, Susanna

File Date:

7/2/2002

Location:

Downtown

Case Type:

Civil

Party Information

Party Name

Relationship

Sex

Attorney

Party Name

Eric McClure

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

Male

Attorney

Sid Horwitz

Party Name

Goldberg & Osborne

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

Attorney

Daniel Zanon

Party Name

Barry Shalen

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

Male

Attorney

Daniel Zanon

Party Name

Rudolph And Rudolph

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

None

Attorney

Kent Turley

Party Name

Rudolph And Rudolph Llc

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

None

Attorney

Mark Rudolph

Party Name

Paul Rudolph

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

Male

Attorney

Mark Rudolph

Party Name

Cathy Shalen

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

Female

Attorney

Pro Per

Party Name

Michelle A Rudolph

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

Female

Attorney

Pro Per

Case Documents

Filing Date

Description

Docket Date

Filing Party

Filing Date

3/3/2004

Description

ODI - Order Of Dismissal

Docket Date

4/7/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

WITH PREJUDICE OF THE COMPLAINT AND COUNTERCLAIM

Filing Date

12/17/2003

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

4/13/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

GRANTING MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

12/3/2003

Description

NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure

Docket Date

4/8/2004

Filing Party

Filing Date

11/25/2003

Description

078 - ME: Case On Dismissal Calendar

Docket Date

12/1/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

11/24/2003

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

12/8/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF NO OBJECTION TO ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

11/10/2003

Description

005 - ME: Hearing

Docket Date

11/10/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

10/30/2003

Description

REQ - Request

Docket Date

3/18/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

FOR COURT REPORTER

Filing Date

10/16/2003

Description

NOF - Notice Of Filing

Docket Date

2/26/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

AFFIDAVIT OF PAUL B RUDOLPH

Filing Date

10/9/2003

Description

094 - ME: Oral Argument Set

Docket Date

10/9/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/26/2003

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

2/14/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

RUDOLPH'S STATEMENT OF FACTS TO THEIR MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT RE DE NOVO ISSUE

Filing Date

9/26/2003

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

2/24/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH TO PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE TO RUDOLPHS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT THAT PLAINTIFF MCCLURE MUST PROVE HIS ENTIRE UNDERLYING CASE DE NOVO

Filing Date

9/18/2003

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

12/26/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

COUNTERTCLAIMANTS' OF JOINDER IN DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH & RUDOLPHS' MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

9/15/2003

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

12/30/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANTS PAUL AND MICHELE RUDOLPHS' OF JOINDER IN DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH & RUDOLPHS' MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH THAT PLAINTIFF MCCLURE MUST PROVE HIS ENTIRE UNDERLYING CASE DO NOVO

Filing Date

9/12/2003

Description

OBJ - Objection/Opposition

Docket Date

1/6/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH & RUDOLPH TO PROPOSED ORDER GRANTING PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

9/10/2003

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

1/9/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

SEPARATE OF PLAINTIFF ERIC MCCLURE IN SUPPORT OF RESPONSE TO MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH THAT PLAINTIFF MCCLURE MUSH PROVE HIS ENTIRE ENDERLYING CASE DE NOVO

Filing Date

9/10/2003

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

1/9/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

PLAINTIFF'S TO MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH THAT PLAINTIFF MCCLURE MUST PROVE HIS ENTIRE UNDERLYING CASE DE NOVO

Filing Date

9/8/2003

Description

NOF - Notice Of Filing

Docket Date

1/20/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

ORIGINAL AFFIDAVIT OF PAUL RUDOLPH

Filing Date

9/5/2003

Description

019 - ME: Ruling

Docket Date

9/5/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

8/29/2003

Description

MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment

Docket Date

1/23/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH THAT PLAINTIFF MCCLURE PROVE HIS ENTIRE UNDERLYING CASE DE NOVO

Filing Date

8/29/2003

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

1/23/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

8/29/2003

Description

MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment

Docket Date

1/23/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH THAT PLAINTIFF MCCLURE MUST PROVE HIS ENTIRE UNDERLYING CASE DE NOVO

Filing Date

8/19/2003

Description

020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement

Docket Date

8/19/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

7/29/2003

Description

NNF - Not Of Non-Parties At Fault

Docket Date

12/4/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

7/17/2003

Description

ODI - Order Of Dismissal

Docket Date

2/17/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

WITH PREJUDICE DEFENDANTS GOLDBERG & OSBORNE AND BARRY AND CATHY SHALEN

Filing Date

7/16/2003

Description

NOF - Notice Of Filing

Docket Date

11/29/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

AFFIDAVIT OF PAUL B RUDOLPH

Filing Date

7/16/2003

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

11/29/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

RUDOLPH'S TO PLAINTIFF'S OPPOSITION TO RUDOLPH'S CROSS-MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

7/16/2003

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

11/29/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH IN SUPPORT OF THEIR REPLY ON THEIR CROSS-MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

7/11/2003

Description

SFD - Stipulation For Dismissal

Docket Date

11/22/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

WITH PREJUDICE AS TO DEFENDANTS GOLDBERG & OSBORNE AND DEFENDANTS SHALEN

Filing Date

7/9/2003

Description

094 - ME: Oral Argument Set

Docket Date

7/9/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

7/2/2003

Description

NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure

Docket Date

11/6/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF PLAINTIFFS SECOND SUPPLEMENTAL/

Filing Date

7/1/2003

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

11/18/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

MCCLURE'S TO RESPONSE OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH TO MCCLURE'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT AND MCCLURE'S OPPOSTION TO RUDOLPH'S CROSS-MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

7/1/2003

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

11/18/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

MCCLURE'S TO STATEMENT OF FACTS OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH

Filing Date

6/25/2003

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

11/14/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH IN SUPPORT OF RESPONSE TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

6/25/2003

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

11/5/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH TO PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT AS TO RUDOLPH LIEN AND CROSS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

6/6/2003

Description

MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment

Docket Date

10/30/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

PARTIAL

Filing Date

6/6/2003

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

10/30/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

PLAINTIFF'S IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

5/9/2003

Description

JUD - Judgment

Docket Date

6/11/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

Notice of filing and entry provided to the parties

Filing Date

3/17/2003

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

9/10/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF LODGING AMENDED FORM OF JUDGMENT

Filing Date

3/17/2003

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

9/10/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF LODGING FORM OF JUDGMENT

Filing Date

3/7/2003

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

9/9/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OFFER OF JUDGMENT PURSUSANT TO RULE 68 ARCP

Filing Date

2/24/2003

Description

019 - ME: Ruling

Docket Date

2/24/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

1/30/2003

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

6/3/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION TO RECONSIDER AND CROSS-MOTION TO CLARIFY AND/OR CORRECT

Filing Date

1/28/2003

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

6/18/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF SERVICE OF THE PRELIMINARY EXPERT OPINION OF RICHARD C GRAMLICH

Filing Date

1/17/2003

Description

019 - ME: Ruling

Docket Date

1/17/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

1/6/2003

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

2/25/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

DEFENDANTS GOLDBERG & OSBORNE AND SHALENS JOINDER IN DEFENDNAT RUDOLPHS/OF NON-PARTIES AT FAULT

Filing Date

1/2/2003

Description

NNF - Not Of Non-Parties At Fault

Docket Date

5/15/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

12/31/2002

Description

NNF - Not Of Non-Parties At Fault

Docket Date

7/19/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

12/17/2002

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

4/1/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH TO PLAINTIFF'S MOTION FOR RECONSIDERATION AND/OR CLARIFICATION AND CROSS MOTION FOR CLARIFICATION AND/OR CORRECTION

Filing Date

12/4/2002

Description

MFR - Motion For Reconsideration

Docket Date

4/12/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

AND/OR CLARIFICATION

Filing Date

12/3/2002

Description

019 - ME: Ruling

Docket Date

12/3/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

11/28/2002

Description

020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement

Docket Date

11/28/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

11/26/2002

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

5/9/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS OFFER OF JUDGMENT DEFENDANTS TO RUDOLPH & RUDOLPH, RUDOLPH & RUDOLPH LLC AND PAUL AND MICHELLE RUDOLPH

Filing Date

11/26/2002

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

5/9/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF SERVICE OF PLAINTIFFS OFFER OF JUDGMENT DEFENDANTS TO GOLDBERG & OSBORNE AND BARRY AND CATHY SHALEN

Filing Date

11/21/2002

Description

STA - Statement

Docket Date

5/9/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

JOINT ALTERNATIVE DISPUTE RESOLUTION

Filing Date

10/3/2002

Description

019 - ME: Ruling

Docket Date

10/3/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/27/2002

Description

094 - ME: Oral Argument Set

Docket Date

9/27/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/27/2002

Description

NSD - Notice of Service Re: 26.1 Disclosure

Docket Date

11/22/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

INITIAL

Filing Date

9/26/2002

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

12/3/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

JOINDER OF DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH IN/ OF DEFENDANTS GOLDBERG AND OSBORNE TO PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE TO MOTION OF DEFENDANTS GOLDBERG AND OSBORNE TO REQUIRE PLAINTIFF TO SERVE EXPERT OPINION AFFIDAVIT

Filing Date

9/23/2002

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

11/20/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

IN SUPPORT OF MOTION TO DISMISS

Filing Date

9/23/2002

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

11/20/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

IN SUPPORT OF MOTION FOR AN ORDER REQUIRING PLAINTIFF TO OBTAIN & SERVE A PRELIMINARY EXPERT OPINION AFFIDAVIT

Filing Date

9/12/2002

Description

094 - ME: Oral Argument Set

Docket Date

9/12/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/3/2002

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

11/2/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO GOLDBERG & OSBORNES MOTION TO DISMISS AND DEFENDANTS RUDOLPHS JOINDER

Filing Date

9/3/2002

Description

OBJ - Objection/Opposition

Docket Date

11/2/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO MOTION FOR ORDER REQUIRING PLAINTIFFS PRELIMINARY EXPERT OPINION AFFIDAVIT

Filing Date

8/27/2002

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

11/2/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF LIMINED JOINDER BY DEFENDANTS RUDOLPH IN CO DEFENDANT GOLDBERG & OSBERNE'S MOTIONT TO DISMISS

Filing Date

8/27/2002

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

11/2/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

FOR ORDER REQUIRING PLAINTIFFS PRELIMINARY EXPERT OPINION AFFIDAVIT

Filing Date

8/21/2002

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

11/7/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO DISMISS AND/OR MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMRY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

8/20/2002

Description

CCE - Controverting Certificate

Docket Date

11/4/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

8/20/2002

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

11/5/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

FOR ORDER REQUIRING PLAINTIFFS PRELIMINARY EXPERT OPINION AFFIDAVIT

Filing Date

8/20/2002

Description

ANS - Answer

Docket Date

8/29/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

8/19/2002

Description

MTD - Motion To Dismiss

Docket Date

1/9/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

8/15/2002

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

10/31/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO COUNTERCLAIM OF DEFENDANTS COUNTERCLAIMANTS PAUL RUDOLH AND RUDOLH & RUDULPH LLC

Filing Date

8/15/2002

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

10/31/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO DEFENDANTS RUDOLPHS MOTION TO DISMISS FOR FAILURE TO STATE CLAIM AND/OR MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

8/15/2002

Description

AFD - Affidavit On Default

Docket Date

10/31/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

8/15/2002

Description

ADE - Application For Default

Docket Date

10/31/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

AGAINST DEFENDANTS BARRY AND CATHY SHALEN AND GOLDBERG & OSBORNE

Filing Date

7/29/2002

Description

MTD - Motion To Dismiss

Docket Date

10/21/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

FOR FAILURE TO STATE CLAIM AND/OR MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMRY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

7/29/2002

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

10/21/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

7/29/2002

Description

CCE - Controverting Certificate

Docket Date

10/22/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

AS TO COMPULSORY ARBITRATION

Filing Date

7/29/2002

Description

ANS - Answer

Docket Date

8/5/2002

Filing Party

Defendant(4)

Filing Date

7/29/2002

Description

ANS - Answer

Docket Date

8/5/2002

Filing Party

Defendant(5)

NOTE:

AND COUNTERCLAIM

Filing Date

7/24/2002

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

10/18/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

7/24/2002

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

10/18/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

7/24/2002

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

7/29/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

P4 SERVED 07-18-02

Filing Date

7/24/2002

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

7/29/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

P6,8 SERVED 07-18-02

Filing Date

7/23/2002

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

7/24/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

P2 SERVED 7-17-02

Filing Date

7/22/2002

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

8/14/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

Filing Date

7/11/2002

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

7/12/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

P7 SERVED 07-07-02

Filing Date

7/11/2002

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

7/12/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

P5 SERVED 07-09-02

Filing Date

7/11/2002

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

10/3/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

7/11/2002

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

10/3/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

7/3/2002

Description

NOF - Notice Of Filing

Docket Date

8/14/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

EXHIBITS TO COMPLAINT

Filing Date

7/2/2002

Description

COM - Complaint

Docket Date

7/5/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

Filing Date

7/2/2002

Description

CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject

Docket Date

7/5/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

Case Calendar

Date

Time

Event

Date

11/25/2002

Time

14:30

Event

Oral Argument

Date

11/25/2002

Time

14:30

Event

Oral Argument

Date

8/14/2003

Time

16:00

Event

Oral Argument

Date

11/7/2003

Time

9:30

Event

Oral Argument

Judgments

Date

(F)or / (A)gainst

Amount

Frequency

Type

Status

Date

5/9/2003

(F)or / (A)gainst

F: Rudolph And Rudolph Llc, Paul Rudolph
A: Eric McClure

Amount

Frequency

One Time

Type

Judgment Only

Status