Civil Court Case Information - Case History

« Return to search results

Case Information

Case Number:

CV2001-016305

Judge:

Julian, Melissa

File Date:

9/20/2001

Location:

Downtown

Case Type:

Civil

Party Information

Party Name

Relationship

Sex

Attorney

Party Name

Crane Elementary School District

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

None

Attorney

TIMOTHY HOGAN

Party Name

Creighton Elementary School District

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

None

Attorney

TIMOTHY HOGAN

Party Name

Globe Unified School District

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

None

Attorney

TIMOTHY HOGAN

Party Name

Murphy Elementary School District

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

None

Attorney

TIMOTHY HOGAN

Party Name

Pinon Unified School District

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

None

Attorney

TIMOTHY HOGAN

Party Name

Tolleson Elementary School District

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

None

Attorney

TIMOTHY HOGAN

Party Name

Tolleson Union High School District

Relationship

Plaintiff

Sex

None

Attorney

TIMOTHY HOGAN

Party Name

(8)State Of Arizona

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

Attorney

Peter Baird

Party Name

State Of Arizona Board Of Education

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

None

Attorney

Peter Baird

Party Name

Maria Cano

Relationship

Intervenor

Sex

Female

Attorney

Thomas Liddy

Party Name

Clarence Patchin

Relationship

Intervenor

Sex

Male

Attorney

Thomas Liddy

Party Name

Martha Patchin

Relationship

Intervenor

Sex

Female

Attorney

Thomas Liddy

Party Name

Thomas Horne

Relationship

Defendant

Sex

Male

Attorney

Peter Baird

Case Documents

Filing Date

Description

Docket Date

Filing Party

Filing Date

5/14/2007

Description

ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal

Docket Date

5/16/2007

Filing Party

Filing Date

5/14/2007

Description

MAN - Order Of Mandate

Docket Date

5/16/2007

Filing Party

NOTE:

AFFIRMED

Filing Date

5/11/2007

Description

TSP - Transcript of Proceedings

Docket Date

5/18/2007

Filing Party

NOTE:

NOVEMBER 17 2003, JUDIE BRYANT

Filing Date

12/5/2006

Description

LET - Letter

Docket Date

12/9/2006

Filing Party

Filing Date

5/13/2004

Description

CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt

Docket Date

5/17/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

TRANSMITTAL/

Filing Date

5/5/2004

Description

CAO - Court Of Appeals Order

Docket Date

5/6/2004

Filing Party

Filing Date

2/12/2004

Description

CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt

Docket Date

3/16/2004

Filing Party

Filing Date

2/12/2004

Description

LET - Letter

Docket Date

3/16/2004

Filing Party

NOTE:

RE FILING FEES

Filing Date

1/29/2004

Description

AIX - Appeals Index

Docket Date

3/16/2004

Filing Party

Filing Date

12/30/2003

Description

NAP - Notice Of Appeal

Docket Date

12/31/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

12/19/2003

Description

JDI - Judgment Of Dismissal

Docket Date

12/31/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

WITH PREJUDICE

Filing Date

12/4/2003

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

12/10/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

FOR ENTRY OF JUDGMENT

Filing Date

12/1/2003

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

12/10/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF LODGING PROPOSED FORM OF JUDGMENT

Filing Date

11/27/2003

Description

019 - ME: Ruling

Docket Date

11/27/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

11/19/2003

Description

020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement

Docket Date

11/19/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

11/12/2003

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

11/28/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

FOR LEAVE TO SUPPLEMENT RECORD

Filing Date

11/12/2003

Description

MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment

Docket Date

11/18/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

AUTHORITIES CITED BY PLAINTIFFS IN SUPPORT OF THEIR/ PARTIAL

Filing Date

11/12/2003

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

11/18/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO DEFENDANTS CONTROVERTING STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF RESPONSE OPPOSING PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

11/12/2003

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

11/18/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

ON THIER MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

10/30/2003

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

11/7/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OPPOSING PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

10/30/2003

Description

ODI - Order Of Dismissal

Docket Date

11/17/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

WITH PREJUDICE AS TO ARIZONA STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION AND THOMAS HORNE

Filing Date

10/30/2003

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

11/28/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

CONTROVERTING/ AND STATEMENT OF FACTS IN SUPPORT OF RESPONSE OPPOSING PLAINTIFFS MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

10/24/2003

Description

SFD - Stipulation For Dismissal

Docket Date

11/4/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

VOLUNTARY WITH PREJUDICE (AS TO ARIZONA STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION AND THOMAS HORNE)

Filing Date

10/24/2003

Description

094 - ME: Oral Argument Set

Docket Date

10/24/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

10/17/2003

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

10/24/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION TO SUSPEND TRIAL DATE

Filing Date

10/17/2003

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

10/24/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO PLAINTIFFS STATEMENT OF CONTROVERTING AND ADDITIONAL FACTS IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

10/17/2003

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

10/24/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

IN FURTHER SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

10/10/2003

Description

MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment

Docket Date

10/27/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

PARTIAL/

Filing Date

10/10/2003

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

10/31/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION FOR PARTIAL SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

10/3/2003

Description

ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal

Docket Date

10/3/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

10/3/2003

Description

CAO - Court Of Appeals Order

Docket Date

10/3/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

ORDER DECLINING JURISDICTION

Filing Date

9/29/2003

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

10/7/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO SUSPEND TRIAL DATE

Filing Date

9/29/2003

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

10/8/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

9/29/2003

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

10/8/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT ON CLAIMS AGAINST STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION AND SUPERINTENDENT OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTION

Filing Date

9/29/2003

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

10/9/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO DEFENDANTS STATEMENT OF FACTS AND STATEMENT OF CONTROVERTING AND ADDITIONAL FACTS IN OPPOSITION TO DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

9/16/2003

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

10/14/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

GRANTING THE DEFENDANTS MOTION AND ALLOWING THEM LEAVE TO FILE A COMBINED MOTION TO SUSPEND TRIAL DATE AND MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT NOT TO EXCEED 20 PAGES

Filing Date

9/12/2003

Description

SOF - Statement Of Facts

Docket Date

10/10/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANTS MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

Filing Date

9/12/2003

Description

EXH - Exhibit

Docket Date

10/30/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

APPENDIX TO DEFENDANTS MOTION TO SUSPEND TRIAL DATE

Filing Date

9/12/2003

Description

MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment

Docket Date

9/25/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/12/2003

Description

MSJ - Motion For Summary Judgment

Docket Date

9/25/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

ON CLAIMS AGAINST STATE BOARD OF EDUCATION AND SUPERINTENDENT OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTION

Filing Date

9/12/2003

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

9/25/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

FOR LEAVE TO EXCEED PAGE LIMITATIONS

Filing Date

9/12/2003

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

9/25/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO SUSPEND TRIAL DATE

Filing Date

9/2/2003

Description

LOW - List Of Witnesses/Exhibit/Evidence

Docket Date

9/20/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

8/27/2003

Description

AIX - Appeals Index

Docket Date

9/18/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

8/19/2003

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

9/16/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

THAT THE TOLLESON ELEMENTARY SCHOOL DISTRICT AND TOLLESON UNION HIGH SCHOOL DISTRICT BE DISMISSED AS PLAINTIFFS IN THE ABOVE CAPTIONED MATTER

Filing Date

8/15/2003

Description

SFD - Stipulation For Dismissal

Docket Date

9/2/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

CERTAIN PARTIES

Filing Date

8/6/2003

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

8/12/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

REGARDING APPLICATION FOR WITHDRAWAL AND SUBSTITUTION OF COUNSEL

Filing Date

7/30/2003

Description

APL - Application

Docket Date

8/14/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

FOR WITHDRAWAL AND SUBTITUTION OF COUNSEL

Filing Date

7/3/2003

Description

LOW - List Of Witnesses/Exhibit/Evidence

Docket Date

7/15/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

6/16/2003

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

6/19/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF WITHDRAWAL OF PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE TO RULE 34 REQUEST

Filing Date

6/13/2003

Description

ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal

Docket Date

6/16/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

6/13/2003

Description

MAN - Order Of Mandate

Docket Date

6/16/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

AFFIRMED

Filing Date

6/2/2003

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

6/19/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO DEFENDANTS RULE 34 REQUEST FOR INSPECTION AND PHOTOGRAPHS

Filing Date

4/30/2003

Description

089 - ME: Trial Setting

Docket Date

4/30/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

4/29/2003

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

6/16/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

PRETRIAL SCHEDULING

Filing Date

4/25/2003

Description

MEM - Memorandum

Docket Date

6/3/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

RULE 16 JOINT PRETRIAL CONFERENCE

Filing Date

4/24/2003

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

6/3/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

STIPULATED JOINT PRETRIAL SCHEDULE

Filing Date

3/26/2003

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

4/8/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

SUBSTITUTION DEFENDANTS

Filing Date

3/26/2003

Description

041 - ME: Scheduling Conference Set

Docket Date

3/26/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

3/24/2003

Description

STP - Stipulation

Docket Date

6/2/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO SUBSTITUTE DEFENDANT SUPERINTENDENT OF PUBLIC INSTRUCTION

Filing Date

3/21/2003

Description

021 - ME: Nunc Pro Tunc Order

Docket Date

3/24/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

VACATING THE JUDGMENT OF DISMISSAL DATED 11-29-2002 NUNC PRO TUNC

Filing Date

3/20/2003

Description

026 - ME: Pretrial Conference Set

Docket Date

3/20/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

3/20/2003

Description

066 - ME: Case Reassigned

Docket Date

3/20/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

3/17/2003

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

4/4/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

GRANTING MOTION TO ASSOCIATE COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE

Filing Date

3/14/2003

Description

NJR - Notice of change of Judge for right

Docket Date

3/24/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

3/10/2003

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

3/20/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO ASSOCIATE COUNSEL PRO HAC VICE

Filing Date

1/13/2003

Description

066 - ME: Case Reassigned

Docket Date

1/13/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

12/31/2002

Description

NJR - Notice of change of Judge for right

Docket Date

2/6/2003

Filing Party

Filing Date

12/27/2002

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

1/9/2003

Filing Party

NOTE:

OF ASSOCIATION OF COUNSEL

Filing Date

12/10/2002

Description

ATR - Appeals Transmittal Receipt

Docket Date

12/18/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

12/4/2002

Description

047 - ME: Judgment Of Dismissal

Docket Date

12/4/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

11/26/2002

Description

CAO - Court Of Appeals Order

Docket Date

11/26/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

TO TRANSMITT ORIGINAL RECORD ON APPEAL WITHIN 15 DAYS

Filing Date

11/16/2002

Description

ALT - Appeals Letter Of Transmittal

Docket Date

11/16/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

11/16/2002

Description

CAO - Court Of Appeals Order

Docket Date

11/16/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

DECLINING JURISDICTION

Filing Date

9/20/2002

Description

CAR - Court Of Appeals Receipt

Docket Date

11/27/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/16/2002

Description

AIX - Appeals Index

Docket Date

11/22/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

SUPPLEMENTAL

Filing Date

9/12/2002

Description

LET - Letter

Docket Date

11/27/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

RE: FILING FEES

Filing Date

9/12/2002

Description

AIX - Appeals Index

Docket Date

11/27/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

9/12/2002

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

12/4/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

COURT OF APPEALS / REGARDING FILING FEE

Filing Date

8/19/2002

Description

ANS - Answer

Docket Date

8/21/2002

Filing Party

Defendant(8)

Filing Date

7/22/2002

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

10/12/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

GRANTING EXTENSION OF TIME

Filing Date

7/15/2002

Description

NAP - Notice Of Appeal

Docket Date

7/24/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(7)

Filing Date

7/12/2002

Description

STP - Stipulation

Docket Date

7/30/2002

Filing Party

Defendant(8)

NOTE:

TO EXTEND TIME TO FILE ANSWER

Filing Date

7/10/2002

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

7/30/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

DENYING MOTION TO INTERVENE

Filing Date

6/25/2002

Description

019 - ME: Ruling

Docket Date

6/25/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

6/12/2002

Description

020 - ME: Matter Under Advisement

Docket Date

6/12/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

6/11/2002

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

6/26/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

FOR ENTRY OF FINAL APPEALABLE ORDER

Filing Date

5/9/2002

Description

019 - ME: Ruling

Docket Date

5/9/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

4/15/2002

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

5/1/2002

Filing Party

Defendant(8)

NOTE:

IN SUPPORT OF THEIR MOTION TO DISMISS

Filing Date

4/8/2002

Description

NOH - Notice Of Hearing

Docket Date

4/19/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

MOTION TO DISMISS

Filing Date

4/2/2002

Description

REL - Reply

Docket Date

4/17/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

TO PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE TO MOTION TO INTERVENE AND DEFENDANT STATE OF ARIZONA; OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO INTERVENE

Filing Date

3/26/2002

Description

ANS - Answer

Docket Date

3/28/2002

Filing Party

Defendant(8)

NOTE:

OPPOSITION TO MOTION TO INTERVENE

Filing Date

3/26/2002

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

4/10/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

TO MOTION TO INTERVENE

Filing Date

3/22/2002

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

4/9/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

TO EXCEED PAGE LIMIT

Filing Date

3/22/2002

Description

RES - Response

Docket Date

4/9/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

TO MOTION TO DISMISS

Filing Date

3/22/2002

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

4/9/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

UNSIGNED - POR HAC VICE

Filing Date

3/13/2002

Description

023 - ME: Order Entered By Court

Docket Date

3/13/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

3/7/2002

Description

MOT - Motion

Docket Date

3/8/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

TO INTERVENE AND MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT

Filing Date

3/7/2002

Description

APL - Application

Docket Date

3/27/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

FOR ADMISSION PRO HAC VICE OF CLINT BOLICK

Filing Date

3/7/2002

Description

ORD - Order

Docket Date

3/27/2002

Filing Party

NOTE:

THAT THE PLAINTIFFS RESPONSE TO THE MOTION TO DISMISS WILL BE FILED ON 03-22-02

Filing Date

2/28/2002

Description

STP - Stipulation

Docket Date

3/19/2002

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

REGARDING BRIEFING SCHEDULE

Filing Date

2/26/2002

Description

311 - ME: 150 Day Minute Entry

Docket Date

2/26/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

2/15/2002

Description

066 - ME: Case Reassigned

Docket Date

2/15/2002

Filing Party

Filing Date

2/11/2002

Description

MTD - Motion To Dismiss

Docket Date

3/6/2002

Filing Party

Defendant(8)

NOTE:

& MEMORANDUM IN SUPPORT

Filing Date

9/26/2001

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

9/27/2001

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

P9 SERVED 09/21/01

Filing Date

9/26/2001

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

9/27/2001

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

P8 SERVED 09/21/01

Filing Date

9/26/2001

Description

AFS - Affidavit Of Service

Docket Date

9/27/2001

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

P10 SERVED 09/21/01

Filing Date

9/26/2001

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

10/5/2001

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

Filing Date

9/26/2001

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

10/5/2001

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

Filing Date

9/26/2001

Description

SUM - Summons

Docket Date

10/5/2001

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

Filing Date

9/20/2001

Description

COM - Complaint

Docket Date

9/21/2001

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

Filing Date

9/20/2001

Description

CCN - Cert Arbitration - Not Subject

Docket Date

9/21/2001

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

Filing Date

9/20/2001

Description

NOT - Notice

Docket Date

9/21/2001

Filing Party

Plaintiff(1)

NOTE:

OF CLIAM OF UNCONSTITUTIONALITY

Case Calendar

Date

Time

Event

Date

6/10/2002

Time