Superior Court >Lower Court And Admin Appeals DUI's

a.) 2d Sample
LC2003-000091-001 DT State V. Williams Due Process does not require a 2nd breath sample on an Intoxilyzer machine.
LC2001-000342 State v. McRae DUI; second sample
LC2001-000424 State v. Russell DUI; second sample
LC2001-000790 State v. Martin No separate sample req'd if Intoxilyzer used.

b.) Alcohol-Related Offenses, non-DUI
LC2003-000397-001 DT State v. Lemke 4-244.33 (under 21 driving w/ alcohol in body) is not a lesser included offense of DUI.
LC2001-000468 State v. Switzenberg Oper. veh. w BAC; underage consumption

c.) Blood Draw
LC2005-000285-001 DT State v. Petersen sufficiency of evidence whether blood drawer was qualified person
LC2003-000826-001 DT State v. Novalla Blood drawn for med. purposes w/out warrant
LC2003-000166-001 DT State v. Ukeneskey police officer trained as phlebotomist was qualified to draw blood.
LC2002-000281 State v. Cingel Seizure of blood drawn for medical purposes pursuant to 28-1388(E)
LC2002-000368 State v. Combs Phlebotomist was a "qualified person" to perform blood draw.
LC2001-000561 State v. Kibarian ARS 28-1388(E) for medical purposes
LC2001-000634 State v. Miller Blood draw pursuant to ARS § 28-1321
TEMP0001 State v. ______ DUI Blood Draw - Affirm
TEMP0002 State v. ______ DUI Blood Draw - Reverse

d.) HGN Test
LC2001-000135 State v. Warren DUI; HGN test
LC2001-000136 State v. McLeod DUI; HGN; suff of evid.
LC2001-000384 State v. Fujimoto Corpus delicti appeal (denial of); DUI; HGN test
LC2001-000391 Dejeet v. State DUI; HGN evid.; mot. in limine

return to top

e.) Intoxilyzer Data
LC2002-000131 State v. Secondo Right to consult with counsel
LC2002-000061 State v. Gill No viol of Rt. to Counsel in DUI case; def called his mother, not an atty.
LC2001-000069 State v. Flores DUI; Mot. to suppr; DUI data
LC2001-000111 State v. Sullivan DUI; const'ty; mot. to suppress; sufficiency of evidence
LC2001-000166 State v. James DUI missing data; suppr. of evid; proper maint of test eqp
LC2000-002174 State v. Lopez DUI - adopt rulings, findings, holding of Hentges
LC1999-000457 State v. Armstrong DUI; data destroyed; mot. to suppress

return to top

f.) Intoxilyzer Operating Correctly
LC2003-000340-001 DT State v. Carrillo DUIS - variations of body temp & breathing patterns not relevant w/out factual basis
LC2002-000659 State v. Kruidenier reliability of breath test was a question for jury.
LC2002-000655 State v. Palomino DUIS - affin denial of suppression mot. re operation of Intoxilyzer.
LC2002-000165 State v. Jennings Intoxilyzer operating correctly
LC2002-000159 State v. Eversull Intoxilyzer operating correctly; alt. method of admitting breath test results
LC2002-000352 State v. Kalos prima facie evid that Intoxilyzer was operating correctly.
LC2001-000866 State v. Nantonie DUI; BAC > .10; failure to stop at red light; failure to drive on right side of road

return to top

g.) Motion for Retrial
LC2001-000042 State v. Icenogle DUI; for mistrial; police officer testimony

return to top

h.) Motion to Dismiss/Suppress
LC2003-000139-001 DT State v. Haven limited right to counsel during DUI investigation.
LC2003-000112-001 DT State v. Rodriguez "std. of review" on a motion to dismiss or suppress
LC2003-000111-001 DT State v. Westall std. on Mot. to Suppress - foundation for Intoxilyzer results
LC2002-000019 State v. Wise Standard of Review
LC2001-000840 State v. Devlin Standard of Review
LC2001-000858 State v. Browder DUI - limited right to counsel in DUI investigation

return to top

i.) Phlebotomist
LC2002-000592 State v. Brown police officers are not disqualified from performing blood draws.
LC2003-000313-001 DT State v. Blair "Law of case doctrine" applic appellate decisions; reconsideration by judge appropriate where new case law (ou point) decided.
LC2003-000166-001 DT State v. Ukeneskey police officer trained as phlebotomist was qualified to draw blood.
LC2002-0000467 State v. Goodman Form does not coerce "no recollection"
CV2001-010240 Shafer v. Goodman Blood draw; leg quals of phlebotomist
CV2001-011726 Vukovich v. Switzer Blood draw; leg quals of phlebotomist
LC2001-000234 State v. Hernandez Blood draw; leg quals of phlebotomist
LC2001-000410 State v. Sembach Phlebotomist's qualifications
LC2001-000443 State v. Waite Phlebotomist; blood draw
LC2001-000448 State v. Williams Rt. to confront; DUI; leg quals of phlebotomist
LC2001-000559 State v. Scales Phlebotomist qualifications
LC2001-000714 State v. Turner Blood draw; leg quals of phlebotomist. Name spelled "Tyrner."
LC2001-000779 State v. Palmer Phlebotomist's qualifications

return to top

j.) Rebut Testimony
LC2001-000298 State v. Secrest DUI; rebuttal testimony

return to top

k.) Various
LC2004-000076-001 DT State v. Thompson No error by trial judge in denying def.'s mot. to continue where def.'s expert (Chester Flaxmayer) not avail. for the trial. Def. has resp. to subpoena and schedule his experts - or, to find an alternate expert. Flaxmayers schedule may not dictate the courts schedule.
LC2003-000378-001 DT State v. Dykman No viol. of due process (def.'s right to gather exculp. evid.) where def. held by police 6 hours after arrest.
LC2003-000824-001 DT State v. Clay State bears burden of justifying decision to end def's phone call to atty during DUI investigation.
LC2003-000686-001 DT State v. Filas Def. not elgible for two-for-one time on extreme DUI charge.
LC2003-000384-001 DT State v. Moyer Jr. gen. expert testimony about personal ' effect on breath test not admissible unless tied to evid. in the case - Guthrie case.
LC2003-000313-001 DT State v. Blair "Law of case doctrine" applic to appellate decisions; reconsideration by judge appropriate where new case law (ou point) decided.
LC2003-000304-001 DT State V. Bustamante "corpus delicti" in DUI case req. evid of "reas. inference" that some intox. person was driving at the time of the offense.
LC2003-000071-001 DT State v. Culleeny DUI; blood drawn for Med - purposes admissible
LC2002-000650 State V. Oconnor "home arrest" is not jail w/in meaning of 28-1382(F)
LC2002-000595 State v. Mcdonough DUI; blood drawn for Med - purposes admissible
LC2002-000031 Espinoza v. State Independent blood sample - dism. aff'd.
LC2002-000089 State v. Harris DUI is not a victimless crime
LC2002-000029 State v. Winter Multiplicitous charges; Extreme DUI
LC2001-000085 State v. Won DUI; BAC > .10; mot to suppr; lang. problem
LC2001-000121 State v. Guthrie DUI; rate of blood alcohol; mot. in limine
LC2001-000209 State v. George DUI; no current reg'n; improper jury instr.
LC2001-000470 State v. Indicavitch Agg DUI; DUI, minor present; rqmt for speedy restitution
LC2001-000522 Huffman v. State Suff. of evid; DUI/var; mot. to suppr.
LC2001-000598 State v. Schaeffer 5th A viol of DP, DUI, other traffic viols
LC2001-000631 State v. Williams DUI; BAC > .10; speed not reas./prudent; mot to dismiss; denial of access to atty
LC2001-000680 State v. Simpson DUI; breath-to-blood ratio evid.
LC2001-000760 Mason v. State App by State; mot. to suppr; leg quals of phleb.; rev'd & rem'd to Scottsdale City Ct.
LC2001-000840 State v. Devlin Intoxilyzer results may be admitted pursuant to "Deason"
LC2001-000211 State v. Portell DUI; suppr. of evid; maint of test eqp; guilt aff'd.
LC2001-000232 State v. Norton DUI; mot. to suppr.; data destroyed
LC2001-000247 State v. Depascal DUI; mot. to suppr.; waiver of objn
LC2001-000319 State v. Costa DUI; sufficiency of evidence

return to top

l.) Sentence
LC2003-000705-001 DT State v. Davis def. convicted of Extreme DUI w/ a prior of resisting arrest is not elgible for home detention.

return to top